Why It's Easier to Fight with Others Than with Ourselves
Fights with a partner, a family member, or a colleague can be perfectly justified. But sometimes they also let us avoid facing the conflicting wishes inside us.
Alon arrives for our session with his nerves frayed. He's in his early forties, married, the father of twins, and in the family he grew up in — himself and his two sisters — there's a longstanding tradition: everything is done together. Holidays, birthdays, trips, even ordinary Fridays. “That's just how it's always been with us,” he says, almost apologetically. The trouble is that his wife wants — “and it's legitimate,” he says, “I get where she's coming from” — a lot more autonomy for their own family.
They got a kind of “exemption” when the twins were born, but it expired after a year, and now his wife's wish for a marriage that isn't always subordinate to his family of origin's calendar leaves him feeling torn in two. “They pull me one way, she pulls me the other,” he says. “I'm stuck in the middle, and I can't do it anymore.”
He's worn out by the nagging, the eye-rolling, the dread of the next event nobody can agree on. Sometimes, he tells me, he just wants to quit — the family, the tradition, all of it. I believe him, of course. But from where I sit, this rift — between his sisters and his wife, between the family he grew up in and the family he built — isn't really, or at least isn't only, a rift between two outside forces. It's a tension that lives inside him.
Part of him still wants to remain that family's son and brother. Maybe he likes feeling protected and belonging somewhere; maybe next to his two older sisters he still gets to play the sweet child who can do no wrong. And another part of him wants, and genuinely enjoys, his new roles — he loves being a husband and a father.
These two parts don't sit easily together. But as long as Alon frames the story as a war between his sisters and his wife, pulling him in opposite directions like the two horses on the old Levi's label, he doesn't have to feel that war going on inside himself.
A Cover Version
Romi, sixty, is deeply committed to vulnerable populations. She donates from everything she has, and needless to say, she's vegan. She feels very much at peace with herself. But she is not at peace with her husband's work — he's a successful CEO who has spent decades running a company that advances none of the values Romi believes in, and actively undermines some of them.
Romi's problem, ostensibly, is with her husband. But as in Alon's case, in therapy she'll discover that one of the reasons her partner is so hard for her to be with is that it's easier to fight with him than with the part of her that loves flying around the world with the children and grandchildren, trading in the car every year, and living free of the burden of earning a living.
It's easy to see why we tend to tell ourselves a story that hides our inner conflict from us. Genuine ambivalence is a particularly uncomfortable state: it isn't easy to hold two contradictory truths about ourselves at the same time.
We are still our parents' children, and also no longer are. The family that raised us comes first, but the family we built and chose also comes first. We do everything we can to become independent, but we also enjoy feeling protected.

Toward One Integrated Picture
A picture this complicated, even a perfectly normal one, makes it hard for us to hold onto a simple, consistent picture of ourselves. Like Romi, it's far easier to find a person who opposes our wishes — and if we're really lucky, like Alon, we might find two outside forces pulling us in opposite directions.
In both cases, we get to skip the need to choose between two parts of ourselves: ‘Mother Teresa’ or ‘the hedonist,’ ‘the spoiled little brother’ or ‘the perfect husband and father.’ It's easier to let others fight it out in place of at least one side of ourselves, as with Romi, or even in place of both sides, as with Alon — to watch the struggle from the sidelines, raise our voice, and feel like a victim of circumstance.
And this is hard for all of us. But the more narcissistic, borderline, or histrionic a person's defenses, the harder it is for them to contain inner conflict, and the more they need someone else to embody, on their behalf, the side of the conflict they can't bear to touch. When a person with one of these personality patterns finds the perfect actor for the role — a partner, a parent, a colleague — they cast them in it, and then set about fighting them with everything they have.
The Rival Is You
The more rigid and severe the personality disorder, the fiercer the battle with this imagined enemy becomes — more prone to repeat itself, and more destructive in its potential. As a therapist, when someone in this kind of state comes into the clinic — say, someone who's divorced and still burns with hatred for their ex, keeps picking fights with them, and keeps reliving the hard parts of the relationship long after the separation — I usually find it very difficult to invite them to look inward, because that glimpse feels especially threatening to them. They prefer the life-and-death battle they've staged for themselves out in the open.
My job, of course, isn't to announce to Alon that ‘it's not them, it's you,’ or to tell Romi that she's lying to herself and actually enjoys having her husband hold, on her behalf, all the traits she condemns — so that she gets to feel ‘good’ while still flying business class to Thailand every holiday.
There are good reasons to avoid that. Alon and Romi are already being blamed by the people they're in conflict with, and they don't need me blaming them too. In Alon's case, the family pressure is real, and his wife's expectations are legitimate. In Romi's case too, her husband is making choices that would be better for him, for her, and for the planet if they were different. So it would be strange to paint a picture in which it's all only in their heads.
The therapeutic work is to help Alon, Romi, and all of us in situations like these hold two things at once: that there is a real conflict out there, usually with people who matter to us or are at least close to us, and that at the same time there is a conflict inside us that we haven't yet opened up, haven't addressed, and haven't learned to live with any better.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




