top of page

Why Does Psychological Therapy Help Even When "Nothing" Happens in It?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 6
5 min read

Updated: Oct 25

Most therapy sessions don't end in any visible breakthrough. But the mere knowledge that someone is listening and willing to help may itself signal to the brain that it's safe to turn down the pain

In emotion-focused therapy, you work hard. You go hunting for the pain, you sit the patient down across from an empty chair, you guide them to imagine all kinds of scenes, and you don't just make it harder for them to talk about the experience from a safe distance — you actively coax them into feeling it, right there in the clinic. The theory is that the only way to change maladaptive emotional responses is for the person to actually arrive at the adaptive emotional response, in the clinic itself, with the therapist's help.

The adaptive responses push the maladaptive ones out and replace them, the way adult teeth push out baby teeth. But in a great many sessions — don't tell anyone, but in the overwhelming majority of them — no dramatic therapeutic work happens at all.

There's no dialogue with an empty chair, no elaborate imagery exercises, no major insight, no visible emotional transformation. Sometimes the therapist and the patient simply stay close to an experience that access to had been blocked, because it had been rejected, hidden, or carried alone. And yet the patient may still leave feeling relieved. Why?

When Pain Speaks

The answer has to do with pain, and with what it's actually trying to tell us. I think that somewhere back in childhood, every one of us asks why we feel pain at all. And then we understand why. I'm old enough to remember the children born with that rare syndrome that leaves them unable to feel pain at all. They usually died before the age of nine. A child who can't feel pain keeps walking on a broken leg, doesn't notice a severe burn, or ignores an infection until serious damage has already been done.

Pain exists, then, to inform a person that there's a problem they need to deal with. But one of the interesting details is that the message doesn't stay entirely inside the body. Pain changes the face, the voice, the posture, the attention, and the behavior of the person experiencing it. We wince, we sigh, we withdraw, we cry, we grab the injured area, or we scream.

I always think about this when I step into a bath that's too hot and my face contorts, even though I'm perfectly aware there's no one around to respond to that message. But the wince is involuntary. My husband, too, sighs deeply every single time something is bothering him. When I ask (or, let's be honest, complain) what's wrong now, he tells me not every sigh needs a response from me.

And I have a hard time understanding how he doesn't get that those sighs put me on edge. My point is that the interesting thing here is that part of what we do when we're in pain is meant to make our distress visible to the people around us. As social creatures, these displays alert others that something is wrong, and that help may be needed.

A few months ago I suffered from sharp pains around my jaw. The pain lasted for a few days, with breaks in between, and if it had turned out I was giving birth to an alien through my mouth, I honestly wouldn't have been surprised. But every single time I spoke to a doctor and started describing what I was feeling, the pain would ease up a little. Eventually the whole syndrome vanished on its own (adding it to the list of things I blame our leadership for), but that episode sharpened something for me: the injury or illness itself can remain completely unchanged while the experience of the pain changes.

The placebo effect is another phenomenon that illuminates this same process. When we expect that a treatment will bring us relief, that expectation alone can often reduce pain, even when the treatment itself contains no active pain-relieving ingredient.

Why Does Psychological Therapy Help Even When "Nothing" Happens in It? - illustration

It may be that the reason is this: even though the underlying problem hasn't been solved, the moment the brain sees that we've responded to the signal and reached out for help, it turns the alarm volume down a notch. That's at least what happened in my own case — the pain in my jaw vanished spontaneously (and a well-known doctor told me about that: "When there's no diagnosis — that's a good thing!").

Legible Suffering

And what about emotional pain? I think tears are a good bridge connecting the two kinds of pain. A wound can be seen, but emotional pain can't. Tears translate an internal emotional state into a physical signal for the people around us, and they tell the world: I'm going through something too big to handle alone. The fact that both physical pain and emotional distress can produce tears doesn't prove the two experiences are neurologically identical. But it does show that they share a common language.

The body uses changes in the face, the voice, the breath, the posture, and the eyes to make our suffering legible to the people around us. Tears that originate in emotional distress show us that, by our nature, human suffering isn't meant to be a private event — it inevitably expresses itself in a form that has the potential to mobilize attention, closeness, and concern.

Of course, we don't have to expose every feeling, and privacy matters a great deal. It's also clear that we differ from one another in how we process pain, and that sharing our pain with others only helps us when the response we get is the right one. If we share our pain with someone who tends toward defensiveness or self-absorption, our situation can actually get worse.

Sharing a difficult past experience doesn't change the past. In certain cases, telling the same story over and over can even delay recovery. But concealment carries a price of its own: when emotional pain is hidden out of shame, fear of being a burden, or the sense that no one would understand, we're left not only with the original suffering — but with the loneliness surrounding it too.

In all likelihood, the signal of pain that's meant to kick us in the rear and get us to ask others for help will only get worse for as long as we don't act on it. Without overstating the analogy to those unfortunate children who died young because they couldn't feel physical pain, it's worth emphasizing the shared principle: we aren't behaving in a way that serves our own survival if we don't recognize our emotional pain, interpret it, act on it, and ask for help.

Let's return, then, to the question of why therapy helps even when you're not working within some particular method. If anything, one of today's guiding axioms is that the single strongest predictor of treatment quality is the relationship between therapist and patient — not this or that technique. The placebo effect is part of the explanation here, if we understand it correctly. An attentive therapist signals to the brain that the person is receiving help. Nothing may actually get solved, but the moment a person is in good hands, there's a real chance that something will shift for the better, and the alarm can start to quiet down.

So many people say, "What's the point of going to therapy? What good will it actually do?" But just like physical pain, psychological pain can ease even when its source hasn't disappeared, simply because help now feels possible. That may be exactly why sessions in which, supposedly, "nothing" happened turn out to be critical to our psychological state — and why it's worth talking to someone about whatever you're carrying.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page