top of page

Why Do We Talk Endlessly About the Very Things We Deny?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 21
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The more explaining, self-persuading, and effort a "no" requires, the more likely it is hiding a feeling too hard to say outright.

“I’m not angry at my mother for leaving my father and us, I really do understand her,” Yarden tells me in the clinic, systematically pulling at a loose thread on her sweater. A few hours later, in a completely different situation, a husband tells his wife: “It’s not that I’m jealous of your new friend from work, I just think it’s strange that you spend so much time with him, that’s all.”

What do these two moments have in common? On the surface, they’re about understanding and concern. In practice, they’re classic examples of how the mind uses negation (“I don’t feel X”) to have its cake and eat it too.

Denying what we feel about a particular subject often lets us bring a loaded topic to the surface while simultaneously buying ourselves time before we actually have to be in contact with the feelings it stirs up.

Confessing to the Nonexistent

Freud described this phenomenon a century ago, in his classic 1925 paper “Negation.” He gives the example of a patient who says something like: “Now you’ll think I want to say something insulting, but I really don’t mean to.” Another example is a patient sharing a dream, wondering who a certain figure in it might represent, and asking: “Is it my mother?” then immediately answering: “No.”

Freud suggests that at precisely this point the therapist should set the record straight and assume that if the patient denied it, that’s exactly the sign that the figure in the dream represents his mother. Psychoanalytic interpretation can, in effect, simply disregard the negation “it’s not my mother” and extract from it the pure content of the thought: “it is my mother.”

In practice, he argues, the full sentence folded inside “it’s not my mother” is: “The thought that it’s my mother did occur to me, but I’m not able to deal with that thought right now, so I won’t grant it any validity or importance at this stage.” In other words, negation lets the repressed slip into consciousness in a form easy enough to contain.

You can think of it like a lychee peel. Through evolution, a tough rind developed to keep predators (awareness) from eating (being in contact with) the fruit (the emotional truth). According to Freud, when a patient dismisses an idea as “highly implausible” or as a feeling especially foreign to him, he is, without meaning to, actually confessing to the truth.

The Repressed, Laid on the Table

But you don’t need years of psychoanalytic training to know this. From a certain age on, it becomes clear to us that there are sentences in which the “no” part is just background noise, a kind of inner contract we make with ourselves: “I’ll allow myself to think about the anger, the jealousy, or a particular fear, on the condition that I get to declare right away that it doesn’t exist.”

Negation is a kind of truth that leaks out, betraying what’s really occupying us mentally. Because whatever it looks like on television panels, speech is nonetheless a precious resource. Our psychic energy is limited, and we don’t waste words denying things that aren’t really there.

Think of it like the limits on what gets published in a paper like The New York Times. In the reviews section, for instance, you’ll mostly find reviews analyzing recommended content, unless it’s a major work that simply has to be addressed, in which case you might also find a negative review there. But as a rule, a negative review of a minor work won’t run there. Because there isn’t really enough room to address everything in the world.

The point is that if my patient truly weren’t angry at her mother, the subject probably wouldn’t come up at all, or it would be mentioned as a dry fact rather than as a defense. The moment she felt the need to declare that she isn’t angry, she in effect placed the concept of “anger” on the table as the main lens through which she experiences her mother’s abandonment.

And as I said, you don’t even need to be a psychologist to experience this. In everyday life, this verbal acrobatics is common, and it often serves the attempt to preserve our own dignity.

The husband who says “I’m not jealous” is trying to protect his ego from the sense of inferiority that comes with jealousy. He translates the feeling into “logical” criticism about time management, to make it more legitimate. We do it all the time: “It doesn’t annoy me, I just find it ridiculous,” or “It doesn’t scare me, it just seems odd to me.”

Why Do We Talk Endlessly About the Very Things We Deny? - illustration

Invested in Denial

That said, sometimes we really do say “no” and mean it. How do you tell the difference between denial meant to hide a burning feeling and a calm, authentic, factual negation? To distinguish between them, I look for the “excess” — everything beyond the dry words themselves.

The first sign that a negation is truly just a negation is the absence of excess emotional charge. Authentic negation is usually “boring,” stated in a factual, offhand tone, like dry information. Denial, by contrast, is often stated in a tone that’s too emphatic, too fast, or in a charged whisper. There’s urgency to it — the person feels they need you to believe the feeling doesn’t exist.

Another measure is the test of relentless preoccupation. When negation is part of a defense mechanism, the person keeps talking about the very subject they just denied. For example, my patient says “I’m not angry at my mother,” and then spends ten minutes explaining why she’s not angry, or describing her mother’s behavior.

Well, now we’re talking about her mother, aren’t we? Meaning she’s still emotionally invested in the subject. The anger is present through its own description. In authentic negation, the subject simply fades away. You say “no” and move on, with no need to justify the absent feeling.

You can of course also look at body language and physiological cues. Our attunement to a subject’s denial is a good example of how, as therapists, we’re sometimes working at learning to stop listening and start noticing. Our feelings speak through the body, and sometimes they do it far more precisely than words do.

In denial, you can sometimes make out a clenched jaw, the picking at a sweater thread, or an avoidance of eye contact. We try to see whether there’s alignment or contradiction between the verbal content and the bodily signals. In defensive negation, there’s a contradiction between the reassuring words and the bodily tension. In authentic negation, the body is relaxed, and there’s no strain in the vocal cords. The words and the body are telling the same story of ease.

Another difference lies in the ability to play with the idea. A person in denial usually can’t bear the possibility that they’re wrong. If I ask my patient whether perhaps she’s a little angry at her mother after all, and she responds with angry dismissal or sharp sarcasm, I’ve probably touched an exposed nerve.

But if she’s authentically negating the possibility, there’s a better chance she’ll respond with curiosity. If someone is able to entertain the possibility that their negation is inaccurate, without being rattled by it, they’re probably not all that threatened by it.

And of course, we also ask ourselves whether the negation is plausible. In therapy or in a close relationship, we have information about the context, and we use it to ask ourselves whether it makes sense that a person wouldn’t feel this or that in the situation they’re describing.

If someone describes a serious injustice and says it “doesn’t bother her,” the negation is almost certainly emotional disconnection or a defense, because ordinary human reality dictates a different response.

In the end, the question isn’t what was said, but how much energy went into saying it. The more explaining, self-persuading, and physical effort a “no” requires, the more likely it is that we’re looking at a truth still primping in front of the mirror, one more moment before it’s ready to step out fully exposed.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page