Do Anti-Anxiety Medications Simply Buy the Brain Time?
Updated: Oct 22
Some anxious patients worry the pills will make them complacent in the face of danger, and some depressed patients fear they'll make them give up on life. But maybe, sometimes, the medication just pauses the most automatic script for a moment.
Galit (a pseudonym), 35, lives inside a storm that never settles. Her anxiety is severe, relentless, and cruelly hops from one object to the next. Until we got through Covid (some friendships in her life never recovered, having failed to meet the standard), her thoughts were locked onto her kids' struggles fitting in at school, and once that front went quiet for a moment, of course the race toward dictatorship began, followed by the endless war, which spared her no reasons to worry.
But even when the fear of cruise missiles from Iran passes through her for a moment, it's immediately replaced by existential worry over the quality of the relationship between her younger children and their older siblings. In short, inside Galit's head, a terrifying voice echoes, and the only way to appease it is to try to control every single detail of her surroundings.
And she does control it, even when the price is wars of attrition and endless fights with the people close to her — the ones whose decisions about their own physical safety, finances, and everything else, depend on them.
A few years ago, in one of our sessions, when she voiced terrible suffering and acknowledged the existence of this destructive voice, I asked her if she thought it might be worth consulting a psychiatrist. I watched immediately as the terrifying voice inside her rose up and flatly refused to give her permission.
Only once we moved to chair work, and she sat alternately in an empty chair representing that anxiety-inducing part of herself, was she able to put her fear of medication into words: “The medication will knock you out,” she said, crying to herself, “it'll make you complacent and leave you exposed to danger, just like all the other idiots who don't understand how dangerous the world is!”
On Numbness and Sensitivity
The case of Ran, a 45-year-old programmer, looks completely different at first glance. Ran suffers from severe, chronic loneliness, and can't understand why none of the romantic or social connections he starts ever develop. In the therapy room, it really does seem like he's trying to “give himself over” to people.
I can't be a fly on the wall in the situations he describes, but on the face of it, he seems to be doing things more or less right, and it's hard to point to a concrete mistake. And yet — it's as if he's handing out pills to the people around him, and everyone drops the pills and leaves him alone.
Last summer, when the loneliness turned into abysmal despair and Ran began voicing suicidal thoughts, I raised the possibility of a medication consultation. His reaction was immediate and fortified. He argued that I was trying to get him to simply accept his bitter fate and live with the loneliness without fighting it (had I just gotten tired of him? he wondered).
This, even as the despairing, painful voice inside him is exactly what pushes him, again and again, to pick up the pieces and go on yet another date, and another. For Ran, depression was the engine, and medication was perceived as an anesthetic that would extinguish his last chances at a life worth living.
As a therapist, I've come across every kind of resistance to medication. There are people who like feeling that they're getting themselves out of trouble on their own, there are those sensitive to side effects, but there are also those whose resistance to medication stems from the very same source as their problem.
Like Galit, some anxious patients worry that medication will make them complacent. They believe that their constant vigilance and their catastrophizing inner voice are the only things truly protecting them.
And then there are the depressed patients who fear it will dull their senses and lead them to passively accept a bleak, grim reality. Both fears rest on a shared assumption: that medication is a blunt chemical tool meant to force them to accept whatever currently feels unbearable to them.

Buying the Brain Time
But over the years, from watching patients using various anti-anxiety and antidepressant medications, I've developed an entirely different way of conceptualizing the experience of drug treatment, in the cases where it works. In those cases, medication doesn't blur consciousness — it enlarges the margin the brain has for dealing with the signals arriving from its surroundings.
Metaphorically speaking, and to some degree neurologically as well, at any given moment our brain is flooded with countless stimuli and vague signals from its environment, ones we can't know for certain are good or bad for us. The brain processes them through a global filtering system that works nonstop, sorting stimuli into “positive” and “negative.”
And more specifically, psychologically speaking, there's a system meant to prevent danger and a system meant to prevent shame: the first examines whether the signal from the environment is safe or dangerous, and the second examines whether the signal is tied to an experience that grants a sense of worth or triggers shame.
When we're in ordinary emotional health, the brain takes a moment to examine this data objectively. But under the rule of an anxiety-inducing or depressive voice, the system defaults rigidly to “better safe than sorry.”
In these cases, the brain isn't able to explore and stay curious — it jumps to immediate conclusions to protect itself. So an unclear text message from the bank gets filed instantly in the “danger” drawer, and a neutral glance from someone standing in line gets filed instantly in the “shame” drawer.
When drug treatment works, what's happening can be described as a microscopic, chemical pause added to the sorting process. It buys the brain one more fraction of a second. Thanks to this slight delay, the brain gains the room to examine the vague signal for just one more beat, a moment before the drawer of conclusions slams shut.
Instead of immediately translating a physical sensation into a terminal illness, this delay lets a person consider that maybe it's just a passing allergy. Instead of seeing a coworker's tired expression as a personal rejection, this reprieve makes room to understand that they might just be having a hard day.
The Option to Sit With Ambiguity
The moment we're able to sit inside ambiguity instead of rushing to a negative interpretation, the entire sorting mechanism changes. By the very nature of the process, when signals are examined in a measured way, an enormous share of them turn out to be entirely neutral, and some even turn out to be positive.
As a result, our behavior also changes organically. The signals stop signaling existential danger or a fundamental flaw in the person, and the urge to avoid or sink into despair fades on its own. At this point, patients usually climb onto a positive ramp of action, where they dare to take small risks that bear fruit and improve their quality of life. In the end, the medication doesn't change who they are — it simply gives the brain room to breathe, and to understand that the world isn't as hostile as their exhaustion led them to believe.
I want to stress: the purpose of this column isn't to recommend that people take medication, since drug treatment carries many complex implications that need to be weighed carefully. The only purpose here is to dissolve this particular kind of fear, by offering a glimpse into the phenomenology of medication's effect, as it's reflected to me at the clinical level.
The effect of that same chemical fraction of a second on Galit's and Ran's lives illustrates well the power of this pause to change the face of reality and pry open the locked drawers.
In Galit's case, her life improved immeasurably. In her own words, she still sees the terrifying thoughts that arise in her, but she no longer gets lost inside them. She describes this new experience as a kind of “meditation in a pill” — to the point that she doesn't understand why not everyone uses it.
To this day, Ran can't put his finger on exactly what the pills do. But as I said, from where I sit, this was the explanation for why his dates started going so much better. And that extra second, which let him not panic and decide that the experience — the WhatsApp message, the glance, the touch — was negative, contributed to the fact that two months after he started taking the pills, after long years of emotional drought, he met the man of his life.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




