top of page

We Can Explain Almost Every Natural Phenomenon. When It Comes to Power, We're Still Hunting for Villains

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 13
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

When the world is too complex to understand who really holds power, the brain looks for someone to blame. Today, conspiracy theories play the role superstitions once played

In the past month, I found myself twice very surprised in an ordinary conversation with an intelligent person. The first conversation was with a woman in her thirties who attended the most prestigious universities and is characterized, as a rule, by impressively analytical thinking. While we were discussing the inevitable topic — will there be a war, or won't there? — she analyzed the situation while giving real weight to the mythical ruling body known as "the Illuminati."

The second person who surprised me in a similar way was a sharp, intuitive Greek woman, even though her education was fairly basic, who told me that her national ID card was about to expire and that she had no intention of renewing it. The government, she explained, wants all Greeks to switch to biometric ID cards. She refuses, because she heard that when they scan your fingerprints, "they" secretly take a drop of your blood to store your DNA in a national database.

I was reminded of these anecdotes this week when I heard from a Greek friend about a bleak superstition, common in her childhood, meant to explain why certain women only manage to give birth to one surviving child. That's when it occurred to me that today's conspiracy theories are a reincarnation of yesterday's superstitions.

Organizing the Chaos

Anthropologists and psychologists have long understood that, alongside mythologies, and after them, classic superstitions developed as primitive attempts to explain natural phenomena. Long before we knew about the existence of bacteria, meteorological processes, or genes, we already needed some set of ideas to help us explain the problems we ran into.

If crops failed again and again, or a healthy newborn suddenly died in the middle of the night, our brain demanded an explanation and used its pattern-recognition ability even when the supporting data was thin or ambiguous. That's how we invented the evil eye, vengeful spirits, and a whole array of rituals to protect against them.

Superstitions offered a kind of crude comfort, because they supplied an explanation, a villain of the week, or, failing a villain, at least a focal point that was the source of evil — and a sense that if we just acquired the secret knowledge and acted on it, we'd raise our level of protection, and even if it didn't work a hundred percent, it would at least make the world feel rational again.

Eventually, empirical science entered the picture. Scientific thinking, observation, data collection, running experiments, and gradually technology too, cleared away the fog. Malicious spirits and evil intentions were replaced by bacteria, tectonic plates, atmospheric pressure, gynecological conditions, and more.

Today (okay, not everyone), even if a person doesn't personally understand some of the health problems they're experiencing, or some of the natural phenomena they see around them, they can lean on a cultural baseline assumption that a body of scientific knowledge, and the scientific method, exist. And in principle, if a natural phenomenon occurs, science can account for it.

But today, the main source of existential anxiety isn't nature's instability — it's the opacity of human power. In other words, even when nature's instability is the thing we're actually dealing with — in the form of wildfires, floods, or extreme heat — the deep human anxiety that arises is a question about those billionaires who are plundering the Earth and letting the rest of us roast while they build themselves colonies on the moon.

Opaque Mechanisms

I have a friend, a very, very successful one, who told me he's currently trying to sell, for 10,000 euros a seat, tickets that in the future could be used as a deposit toward an apartment on another planet. Another acquaintance explained to me, after an intensive deep-dive into reading about artificial intelligence, that we have ten years left, twenty tops, before the billionaires destroy us all or we become slaves to AI.

My point is that in ancient times, power was a far more tangible phenomenon. We may not have liked the king, we probably hated the local feudal lord, and we despised the village priest — but we could point at them. We knew who owned the land, who collected the taxes, and more or less who wrote the laws.

There was always intrigue and corruption — we know that from the Bible, from Shakespeare, from Robin Hood — but our brain could still encompass the power structure and the dynamics within it. Today, though, the interplay between money, technology, and global politics takes place in "terra incognita," somewhere beyond the horizon, somewhere an ordinary citizen's eye has never reached and maybe can't reach, because power today may be driven by mechanisms whose interrelations can no longer be understood the old way. And it may be that our biology is failing us.

Our brain evolved in a small-scale social context. Within the tribe, power was a personal trait, and behind every exercise of power stood someone who could, in theory, be identified. We're cognitively equipped to understand what heroes, villains, and con men look like — our entire popular culture attests to that — but we struggle to intuitively grasp non-human systemic complexity.

We Can Explain Almost Every Natural Phenomenon. When It Comes to Power, We're Still Hunting for Villains - illustration

One Global Olympus

When we're confronted with systems that are hard for us to picture, the brain is more likely to start "playing it safe" and to favor faulty explanations that protect it, rather than (theoretically) ignoring a danger. In other words, if I see some unclear movement in the bushes and jump to find cover, but it turns out it was just the wind and not a tiger — maybe that's a little embarrassing, but nothing happened.

On the other hand, if I heard a rustle in the bush and assumed it was just the wind, and didn't notice the predator hiding there, I may have severely damaged my ability to pass my genes on to the next generation. For these reasons, evolution favored people who have a built-in bias to assume a deliberate agent lies behind every unexplained event. They managed to have more children.

In ancient times, this mechanism may have led us to believe that a child born with a certain birthmark would drive all the other children out of their parents' lives, and cause miscarriages or infant deaths. Today, when we're confronted with the sheer complexity of global institutions, that same mechanism makes us knead these distributed systems into a single mold — for instance, in the shape of a secret meeting between figures who conspire together and run the world.

There's really no difference between the imaginary room where the Illuminati supposedly convene, or where the people who decided to take blood from every innocent Greek who applies for a biometric ID card supposedly deliberate, and the way the ancient Greek concept of Mount Olympus came to be.

The ancient Greeks imagined capricious gods sitting above the clouds, quarreling, betraying, deceiving, and, along the way, changing the course of human lives without warning. We look at market crashes, wars, inflation, and policy shifts and feel the invisible touch of distant, alienated, all-powerful figures. Our suffering, or random strokes of luck, become evidence and proof of their deeds.

At Least There's Someone to Blame

If so, conspiracy theories perform the same psychological function that superstitions once performed. When we feel that the world is impossibly complex, conspiracy theory offers a narrative anchor, just as superstition once explained natural phenomena that were beyond our comprehension.

In both cases, the explanation is comforting. Why is it comforting to believe that a shadowy group like the Illuminati runs the world, or that DNA is being collected in a hidden room in a government building? First, because living in a world ruled by malicious masters is a little less distressing than living in a world driven by headless, chaotic, unmanaged complexity.

If there's an evil master plan, there's someone to blame (Hollywood movies, in which these villains are even punished, demonstrate this fantasy for us). The alternative leaves us utterly helpless. On top of that, the feeling that we possess secret knowledge, by itself, reduces the existential anxiety or the humiliation that come with that helplessness.

Conspiracy theories often develop in places where ignorance has taken root, whether by intent or not. But the cases I've described here show that conspiracy theories don't indicate stupidity, and certainly aren't always a sign of the outer limits of human intelligence.

What they indicate is that we can no longer read the map of power. Until a new kind of "science" enters the picture — in the form of transparent government, education in political and economic literacy, and genuine systemic accountability — these theories will keep popping up, expressing our refusal to surrender to forces that are trampling us.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page