top of page

What Discovering Your Partner's Sexual Fantasy Can Do for You

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 29, 2016
6 min read

How an open conversation about sex can save your love life

A few weeks ago, I wrote here about the relational psychoanalyst Stephen Mitchell's view that the secret to keeping love alive long-term is recognizing that we don't actually know our partner. One of the most effective ways to remind ourselves that our partner isn't the predictable type we imagine him to be is to ask him the questions we don't normally dare to ask. Not about money — about the other subject.

The person who blazed the trail in couples therapy on this front is the couples and sex therapist Esther Perel. Perel's book "Mating in Captivity: Unlocking Erotic Intelligence" became a worldwide bestseller. Perel shook up the conservative world of couples therapy by arguing that when couples become too comfortable with each other, the price of that cozy closeness can be the loss of desire.

Of all the solutions Perel points to, the most basic one is simply starting to talk about sex. Most couples lack a language that lets them talk about desires, preferences, and fantasies. Without that language, they're stuck with whatever sex life happened to form between them, like an unspoken agreement. If the sex is great, fine — but how are they supposed to deal, say, with the common situation where the woman doesn't come?

Perel offers a basic recipe for talking about sex: obviously, you don't have this conversation in bed, in the middle of trying a new position. It's also not a good idea to open with, and dwell only on, what isn't working for you. She suggests opening the conversation by directing a few basic questions at your partner: What would make our sex life more exciting for you? When do you feel most free? When are you most drawn to me? What compliment would you like to hear from me? Is there something you'd like us to try?

Take your own experiences and put them into words, Perel says. Which means it's time to tell her about that frog position you love so much, and ask if she even knows you love it. Check with her whether she enjoys the frog style too, and whether there's a way to make that particular position more enjoyable for her as well. Also ask what she's craving — does she want to feel more connected to you during sex, or does she want to feel like prey being pounced on? If you had to sum up Perel's whole teaching in one question, it would be this: what does it for you?

This sounds excruciatingly embarrassing, and maybe you've already tried it and it went nowhere. It's still worth trying again, because Perel promises that most women would actually want to be asked these questions. Broadly speaking, Perel is convinced that most women would be happy for more information to pass between them and their partner than what's contained in the words "I'm coming." Of course, alongside the questions about what's working, it's also very important to finally say that you're a little less into that one move with the mayonnaise — and you're allowed to explain why.

What Discovering Your Partner's Sexual Fantasy Can Do for You - illustration

For women who are afraid to name the elephant in the room, Perel urges: explain to your partner how long it takes you to get turned on, and make clear that it matters to you that he has patience and doesn't get bored. Most men want their partners to enjoy sex, she promises, and if they see that it's actually working, they'll have plenty of motivation to listen to your guidance.

But a real conversation about sex is obviously more than small talk, and there's no need to settle for Esther Perel's basic phrasebook. The psychoanalyst Suzanne Iasenza reminds us that the breadth of the questions shapes the answers we get. Desire, as we know, refuses to sort itself neatly into a spreadsheet. In her landmark paper, "What Is Queer About Sex? Expanding Sexual Frames in Theory and Practice," she catalogs many variations of sexual attraction, far more diverse than "bisexuality" or men who like to have sex while dressed in women's clothing. She notes that the long human menu also includes: satisfaction with your own biological sex alongside a wish for society to treat you as the other sex; sexual attraction to a person who is changing their gender; an inability to identify with either gender; the ability to enjoy sex only while imagining you belong to the other gender; married heterosexuals having an affair with someone of the same sex; lesbians who sleep with men; gay men who fantasize about women during sex; people who enjoy being hurt and/or humiliated; straight people who enjoy anal penetration, and more.

In other words, if we really want to know our partner, it's worth challenging our basic definitions instead of settling for the simple grid of food, drink, man, woman. About a decade ago, the family therapist Arlene Lev proposed a more developed model for defining our sexual identity. According to Lev's model, sexual identity is actually made up of four axes: sex (male-female), gender (man-woman), sexual role (masculine-feminine), and sexual orientation (heterosexual-homosexual) (the spectrum is laid out in her book "Transgender Emergence: Therapeutic Guidelines for Working With Gender-Variant People and Their Families"). In other words, today I might identify sexually as a woman, in a woman's body, in a feminine role, attracted to women, and tomorrow I might think of myself as a woman, in a woman's body, in a masculine role, attracted to both women and men (and that's just two days). Indeed, if we think of ourselves as sliding along each of these axes, the long list of sexual variations above starts to look perfectly logical.

But since this framework isn't the basis of our sex education, and isn't socially accepted, most of us still find it hard to put the mental — or literal — strap-on on the table. For this reason, in her clinical work with couples, Iasenza, like many therapists, interviews each partner separately about their sexual history, and then creates the conditions that allow them to tell each other what they know about themselves.

In the joint conversation, Iasenza reframes the couple's sexual problem as an opportunity for growth and development. She reminds them that, in most cases, couples struggling with sex (and plenty who aren't) grew up in households without open, positive communication about sex, and had to scrounge for information outside the home. By the end of this conversation, she's also laid the groundwork for the next one. In her view, a lack of open communication about sex leaves many couples living with a very narrow sexual menu. The risk is that the moment that one dish on the menu becomes unavailable, for psychological or physical reasons, both partners are left hungry. That starvation diet is part of the problem.

So, as part of the solution, Iasenza suggests couples expand their sexual menu through "homework." Each partner is asked to prepare an independent list of sexual ideas. The list should be as long as possible and include the greatest possible number of sensual, erotic, or sexual ideas. The instruction is not to censor any idea for being too tame (like watching a sunset) or too strange for their taste (mayonnaise, again). Ideas go on the list regardless of whether your partner would like them or recoil from them. In her clinical experience, she writes, the simple act of making these lists already broadens each partner's perspective and puts them in a more playful, daring frame of mind about sex. Further down the list, it also helps kick-start conversation about those embarrassing corners of our fantasies, and allows for expressing every axis of sexual identity.

The added benefit of a long list is that it reduces the embarrassment involved in voicing one specific request to your partner (see that Little Red Riding Hood costume in the closet...? wink). This way, instead of merely mirroring the relationship as it already is, the bed starts to become a playground where what happens there drives growth in other parts of the couple's relationship. Hey — where did you two go?


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page