top of page

Why I Cried at Project Hail Mary (and It Wasn't Just Something in My Eye)

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jun 4
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Plato feared art's power to offer the masses cheap catharsis, while Freud argued it lets us process our hardest feelings. But maybe there's an even deeper psychological reason for the tears we shed in front of a moving work of art.

Not long ago I went to see Project Hail Mary in the theater. “Saw” is a big word, since I spent half the movie crying. I'm not much of a crier. And yet there I was, sniffling in the dark like a kid. It reminded me of a few businesspeople I know, who use transatlantic flights as cover to weep quietly at the little screen in front of them.

The question of how art affects us is ancient. As any student of art or philosophy knows, long before the invention of cinema, Plato identified the emotional effect art has on us and considered it deeply dangerous. In his ideal state, he argued, there would be no room for poetry — meaning art in its broadest sense.

According to Plato, art offers cheap catharsis, the kind we haven't paid for. It lets us experience deep emotional release without the moral effort or the real-world consequences that ought to accompany such feelings. I cry over the fate of the lone astronaut, or the feelings of the strange alien, without ever being called on to actually help them solve their problems.

Plato's anxiety doesn't come from art failing — it comes from art succeeding too well. Plato understood that art bypasses our rational control mechanisms and speaks directly to the lower, appetitive, emotional parts of the psyche. In The Republic, he describes how the playwright feeds and cultivates these elements, which are by nature prone to imbalance, and in doing so weakens the rational element that's supposed to govern us.

The greatest danger, in his view, is that emotional identification in the amphitheater will atrophy us: if we get used to weeping over the bitter fate of fictional characters, we'll struggle to summon the gravity, restraint, and self-discipline required to deal with real suffering in the real world.

Organized Chaos

The deep difference between this historical anxiety about art's power and the modern psychological view lies in the concept of sublimation. It's commonly said that Sigmund Freud claimed the first person who cursed instead of throwing a rock was the one who started civilization (since a curse is a sublimation compared to the option of throwing a stone).

Over the last hundred years, it's become widely accepted to see the experience of “consuming” art as entering a protected, controlled zone where we can encounter our most terrifying or most isolating feelings — but without risking real disintegration. And isn't that exactly what Plato said? Not quite — because from the artist's side, the work isn't just emotional release, but an active act of gaining mastery over chaos, raising entropy to a higher level of order.

Art takes the most dangerous, threatening, and idiosyncratic materials of one's inner life and processes them into a coherent structure, rhythm, or narrative. In doing so, it turns the artist's private, wordless encounter with the sharp corners of the world into an accessible aesthetic structure.

And from the other side, when we, as an audience, receive this processed result, our tears aren't a sign of weakness or of addiction to illusion, but evidence of a healthy psychological process that lets us touch, analyze, digest, feel, put into words, understand, and deal with grief or anxiety buried deep, deep within us.

Instead of choking off these feelings through repression, numbing, or venting them in the wrong places and letting them wreck our lives, sublimation raises them to a cultural and spiritual level and lets us walk out of the theater or close the book feeling comforted, more aware, and more connected to ourselves — making art the most essential mechanism we have for preserving our sanity within culture.

Why I Cried at Project Hail Mary (and It Wasn't Just Something in My Eye) - illustration

A Collective Sunset

But in conversations I've had recently with women artists, I came across another idea: we cry at the movies, at a performance, or in front of a book because art dissolves, if only for a moment, a formidable psychological loneliness that begins in early childhood.

Around age five or six, I think, a lot of children run into a certain question. The question. We look at the color pink and ask: “When I say ‘pink,’ do I see exactly the same thing you see when you say ‘pink’?”

Very quickly we learn that although we can share the word, we can never share the conscious experience itself — the qualia, as the concept is sometimes called, of our own inner world.

And that's the other reason a shared aesthetic experience is fundamentally different from watching a sunset. When an entire crowd lets out a gasp of admiration at a spectacular pink sky, the shared experience is largely biological.

Evolution wired our systems to respond to shifts in light and to the horizon line; it's a reflex of the human species. Whoever first thought a sunset was beautiful, or that flowers were wonderful, probably found it a little easier to hold on through the hardships of existence. But art is the product of a specific, intentional consciousness.

When a director cuts a scene to a particular rhythm, or a musician shifts from a minor key to a major one, they're mapping out a complex, nonverbal inner landscape. And when the way some other, unfamiliar person maps emotion happens to match the way we map emotion, we're granted a powerful confirmation and validation that comes from two separate sources.

The first source is synchronic, and in a sense you can also think of it as horizontal: it's the relief of shattering loneliness in that very moment. That's what happens when you gasp or laugh together with an entire movie theater (well, 30 other people), or when you're reading a book and you know that generations of readers shivered at that exact same sentence.

The second source is vertical, and in a way it's deeper and more unsettling: it's the understanding that this precise reaction is exactly what the artist was trying to achieve. When a work of art stirs in you the specific emotion its creator spent months, years, or centuries planning for, it means the creator knew you before you even existed.

She anticipated in advance the fragile, secret architecture of your psyche. In that moment of aesthetic alignment, in a museum or in front of a written poem, you're looking at the art, but you actually feel seen by it — while it promises you that your own “pink,” in the end, is the very same pink everyone else sees.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page