Simple Satisfaction: Why Are We Drawn to Predictable Shows Right Now?
Updated: Oct 22
Unlike the bite-sized videos on social media, which fuel constant alertness, dated and unsophisticated shows with a familiar narrative and a predictable ending offer psychological calm - and that is precisely what keeps them relevant in an age of uncertainty.
Not long ago I wrote here about how the level of stress we are living under impairs our intelligence, and I've only kept seeing evidence of it since. And it seems to me that even when the fire stops, one of the last things to return to its normal state is the ability to concentrate. Personally, I can barely get myself to open a book, and that's with comics being my favorite genre lately. Yet I do find myself able to focus on shows I'm embarrassed to admit to (fine, all right: "The Mentalist").
Embarrassing. Do I watch it just for pleasure? No - only when I'm on the exercise bike. Would I, in a normal time, actually watch anything like it in a similar situation? Absolutely not. In ordinary times, watching a show so banal that it's obvious the solution arriving at minute 14 is wrong simply because it arrived at minute 14 would have made my workout harder, not easier.
And that's not because there's nothing worth watching. Every so often a masterpiece does surface, or a near-masterpiece like "The White Lotus" - one with at least a few superb ingredients, such as the acting or the design, that manages to sweep us up, despite everything, into worlds of luxury and intrigue. But given that we've already seen the "top of the top," it seems to me that in a period like this, everything beneath that peak has a hard time holding our attention.
If in normal times we were willing to put the mental effort into a quality but demanding drama, today its cognitive "price" is too high. A show that requires us to be partners in the creative act, forces us to navigate ambivalent characters, deal with moral complexity and endure open endings that leave a knot in the stomach - has to be super satisfying for us to strike a deal with it. Give us the Kennedys!
Simple Spiritual Food
So what is going on here? Why does our sophisticated brain suddenly need spiritual food so simple that it seems a mother bird has already chewed it to make it easy for us to swallow? The answer lies in our emotional regulation mechanism in times of extreme uncertainty.
We don't even know where we are in the story - are we after the war with Iran? What exactly happened? Is what happened good? Is it terrible? And if it happened this way or that, what does it say about what happened in the previous Iran war? And how is it that opening a strait that was already open is a dramatic victory? And even if it is, how is it that closing it is also an unprecedented victory?
We don't know what the truth is, and the big story, the one that forms the backdrop against which we live our lives, doesn't really add up. When the national narrative, and with it the personal one, are broken, the brain experiences an enormous cognitive load as it tries to make sense of the incomprehensible.
In such a state, basic narrative satisfaction has enormous psychological advantages. We need our television to be predictable, closed and decisive - exactly what the "quality" shows from the second tier down can no longer deliver.
Aristotle wrote 2,400 years ago that a well-written tragedy is one in which the viewer experiences the moment of discovery a split second before the actor on stage grasps it. The tension we feel when we know what is about to happen, and the satisfaction of being right, together create a tremendous experience.
But for that to happen, the playwrights of course need to know, long before the viewer, what is going to happen; they are, after all, the architects of the entire narrative structure. This mastery only highlights the shaky architecture of shows like "The Mentalist." There, to make sure the screenwriter really does know more than the viewer, you'd have to go to the VAR, as in a soccer match where nobody is sure whether it was offside.

The Power of the Predictable
And yet, there is something wonderfully soothing about the fact that the seams are so coarse. At a time when Israeli reality feels like a sequence of events with no playwright (at best) and no poetics (in any case), the banality of a detective whose horrific trauma has not marred his angelic good looks or his gentlemanliness is not a flaw - it is the anchor.
And by the way, the success of the show about the Kennedy family demonstrates exactly our need for a narrative whose ending is known in advance. Here the whole question of who knows what in advance isn't relevant at all. In addition, in a world where we look at the political and security reality the way one watches the roulette table over a compulsive gambler's shoulder, diving into the past of American royal families offers a perfect combination of luxury and intrigue with psychological safety.
We know exactly who will be murdered and who will survive, and the pomp and splendor of yesteryear let us safely experience sadness and admiration without fearing some plot twist that, heaven forbid, will shake our already shaken world.
What makes the not-really-good shows perfect right now is the reduction in prediction load. Our brain is a machine for forecasting the future, and once you leave the television of the 1990s heading into the early 2000s, that machine already sputters like my washing machine.
But with "The Mentalist" or "The Good Wife," my brain has fun; it can rest. It knows exactly what will happen. There are no "prediction errors" that demand energy. Second, these shows offer a moral order. On formulaic television, the bad guy - whether a murderer or a disease - gets caught and justice is done within 42 to 50 minutes at most. It is a distilled catharsis that calms our sympathetic nervous system.
Of course, this is the shows' finest hour, because their characters - precisely because they will never go through anything as shattering in front of our eyes as a film character would - serve as a secure base for us; going back to Alicia Florrick or to Jake Peralta of "Brooklyn Nine-Nine" is like walking into a room with familiar friends who never change.
Until the Next Dopamine Hit
Naturally, within this comforting space there is an internal gradient of depth. Writing effective comedy is always a harder and more complex task than writing drama at the same level. And accordingly, our brain's decoding is always more rewarding when it happens in response to a sharp joke, which demands mental flexibility and a quick linking of contexts, than in response to a formulaic detective reveal.
The neurological thrill we get from laughing at a joke on "Brooklyn Nine-Nine" outdoes the satisfaction of the moment when the detective discovers that the dim-witted stable boy is actually the sophisticated murderer, just because he found a copy of "Moby Dick" in his trailer.
Still, the question arises: if I'm waxing poetic about watching "stupid television," what is the difference, really, between what I watch and what my kids watch? Why do I tell them to quit the "shorts," or roll my eyes when people watch TikTok?
If we use the dreadful expression "I feel like saying," then I feel like saying that the difference is abysmal, and it lies in the distinction between regulation and fragmentation. When I watch an episode of "The Mentalist," I give my brain a narrative sequence. There is a beginning, a middle and an end. I maintain a stable attention span for a defined period of time, which lets my parasympathetic system lower my heart rate and settle into calm.
But the bite-sized videos on social media work through a completely opposite mechanism. They are built on fragmented, fast, shifting stimuli injected into the brain every 15 seconds. Instead of calming the system, they leave it in a state of constant alertness for dopamine. Like a dolphin at a dolphinarium waiting for someone to toss it the salted fish - the brain on TikTok doesn't rest, which in the bottom line only worsens the difficulty concentrating and the feeling of stress.
If the formulaic series is a vegetable soup made with supermarket vegetables, instant couscous and a little soup powder that soothes the stomach, TikTok is a bag of gummy candy that gives you fun for a moment, but leaves you hungrier and crankier fairly soon after.
So yes, it really does embarrass me to admit that I watch Patrick Jane solve crimes in a predictable way, but I do it for all of us, because it is my psyche's way of reminding itself that there are still worlds where everything falls peacefully into place.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




