top of page

The Only Toy You Need for the Next Lockdown (and for Life in General)

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 26, 2020
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

A home neurofeedback device can get every member of the family to enjoy sitting quietly for a few minutes, and opens the way to an inner journey at a time when every other kind of journey is out of reach

Until a few months ago I treated meditation the way I treat dental floss: something I really want to want to do, but can't quite summon the energy for. But since the second lockdown, something remarkable has happened: the door to meditation has opened for me, and for the first time in my life I find myself desperately wanting everyone to leave so I can meditate in peace. The path to this point was paved by a home neurofeedback device called the MUSE.

Anyone who follows this column knows I'm constantly on the hunt for self-soothing tips (or, as the commenters call it, "sponsored content"). Talk to me about the weight of weighted blankets (I recommend 9 kilos), about CBD (I like 15%), and about baking (Yotam Ottolenghi's granola will pave your way to eternal glory and win you friends). All of these are great, but the MUSE (which my son calls "the mind reader") outdoes them all.

I'll put it on the table: it is the most expensive toy I own. With the hard case, and shipping that gets it here before the coronavirus vaccine does, the device costs around 1,000 shekels. But if you have the privilege of setting aside part of your budget for mental and emotional survival, a home neurofeedback device is the right choice.

I should note that other devices in this category may well be just as good as this company's product; I've only tried this one, so it's the one I recommend. It's quite likely that you could get similar results with competing products (a few examples: Bellabee, BrainBit, Emotiv Insight, FocusBand, NeuroSky, MindWave, Versus).

How does it work? The MUSE looks like a tiara, a plastic band with sensors that sits on your forehead, right where people who aren't you park their sunglasses instead of taking them off altogether. The sensors can reliably and consistently measure the electrical frequencies of the brain at a home-use level and sort them into three states: active, neutral or calm. The device transmits the data to an app on your phone, and the app gives you real-time feedback on what it's receiving from the device.

For example, in one of the basic exercises, the user first hears a downpour of tropical rain. The better she gets at controlling her brain frequencies, the more the rain eases, and when she is completely calm and focused, birdsong is heard. When she loses concentration, the birds disappear and the rain picks up accordingly. During the session her brain activity is recorded, and at the end she receives a report showing the state of her brain activity at every moment, along with a few basic insights, such as what percentage of the session she managed to stay calm.

By this point, most people I tell about neurofeedback already understand why it's cool. Even so, I usually keep singing the praises of a device that can get even the less calm members of the household to dip their fingertips into the river of mindfulness.

It's a way into the world of meditation that requires nothing spiritual; on the contrary, it exploits our obsessive self-absorption and harnesses it, rarely, to our benefit. Instead of checking how many people liked our post, we're tempted to check how our brain works and how long we can stay focused on our breath, on a mantra, on a body scan, on counting to ten, or on staring at a white wall without boarding the train of thoughts.

Part of the MUSE's success lies in the fact that the mind, which needs a snack anyway, gets from the audio feedback a delightful snack on the one hand (me, me, me), while on the other hand it doesn't send the mind wandering across the mental landscape but brings it back to the practice.

The Only Toy You Need for the Next Lockdown (and for Life in General) - illustration

Of course, this kind of meditation doesn't have the spiritual value of the meditation we enter with the intention of contemplating the truths of life, or of vowing to ease the suffering of all living beings. It's also clear that it has the potential to harden your ego in a narcissistic way, especially if you're at risk for that. But still, even if you're a shallow narcissist using the MUSE to revel in your ability to control your own mind, for those ten minutes in which you sit quietly with the device you do less damage than usual.

As far as I'm concerned, it is unquestionably better to be pleased with yourself for hearing 80 birdcalls on the MUSE in ten minutes of practice, or for reaching 91% calm, than to spend those same ten minutes reading about the coronavirus, fighting on Facebook or sinking into Instagram hallucinations. And who knows, perhaps seeing the baseline speed at which your train of thoughts races through an ordinary day might even lead a person to deeper reflection on the rat race they're caught in.

But this is really not just a toy for pampered, hyperactive kids. When I switch off the direct-feedback element and use only its ability to record my brain activity, I find that the device deepens my real meditation. That is, I put the MUSE on my forehead and then ignore the guided meditations the app offers and the games that let me control the sounds of rain, a campfire, the sea or tribal drums around a bonfire.

Instead of all those, I play myself a guided meditation from another source (usually from my laptop), or practice meditation using other techniques I know. In this mode I give up the feedback aspect, and meditate without the signal indicating that my thoughts started to wander a moment before I noticed it.

But I keep the recording of my brain activity, and at the end of the session I check the summary of the activity the MUSE recorded during that time. You can also download the standalone app MIND MONITOR, which works with the system and has many more functions to dig into.

This method also suits people for whom the feedback part is distracting, or triggers performance anxiety ("The rain again! I'm so bad at this!"). Used this way, I learn which guided meditations I connect with easily, how much I'm improving at controlling my mind, and what state my mind is in today.

I also discovered that many researchers are interested in this technology and use similar systems to conduct brain research. They ask their subjects to work at home on things that previously required a trip to a specialized clinic, which makes the process easier for everyone involved.

I entered these worlds because of the helplessness I felt as a therapist when I couldn't help patients during the times when the coronavirus kept us physically apart, and also because the pandemic makes things harder for them in general, and I'm always looking for things that can help with restlessness, anxiety, sleep problems and hyperactivity.

I myself have learned which technique focuses me most effectively in therapy when something in a session becomes a trigger for me, and similarly I've learned which method suits me particularly well when I'm in a situation without the conditions I'm used to, such as time or privacy. I especially like using the MUSE to measure how well I can keep a clear mind even with my eyes open and while aware of my surroundings, and every such session is also a constant reminder that I need to meditate a lot more.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page