top of page

Say You Got a Parking Ticket, and You Completely Lost It

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jun 13, 2024
8 min read

Say something happens to us, and suddenly we feel sadness, guilt, and numbness that have nothing to do with what actually took place. It turns out there's something to learn from that moment — and something you can actually use it for. Take Nina, for example

Nina (a pseudonym, like all the names in this column), a 40-year-old woman with a family and a successful career, came out of a meeting to find a parking ticket on her car. She'd parked in front of a shop that was closed, the same way plenty of other people in the area were parked in front of other shops that were already closed at that hour of the day.

Discovering the ticket gave her a terrifying pounding heart, and a feeling of shock and falling apart that, by her own account, was completely out of proportion to what had actually happened. She got into her car and fought with the municipality's website on her phone until she managed to pay the fine, then tossed the ticket in the trash and tried to erase the whole incident from her mind. From the standpoint of an emotion-focused therapist, this is a textbook example of something called a "strange reaction" — and it's an excellent starting point for emotional exploration.

A strange reaction can show up in different forms: laughing, of all things, during a painful experience; crushing guilt in a situation where no guilt is really called for; overwhelming sadness where what actually happened amounts to nothing more than mild inconvenience; an inability to feel joy at the very moment something we'd hoped for finally happens; or emotional numbness in the face of an intense event. The assumption is that these reactions matter, because they're signaling underlying emotional processes that aren't visible on the surface — and the goal of exploring them is to uncover the feelings sitting underneath.

Signals Calling for Emotional Exploration

Once a strange reaction has been identified, the family of experiential therapeutic approaches (a term referring to the need to actually experience an emotional process within therapy, rather than merely talk about feelings, and which includes approaches like AEDP and schema therapy) offers several ways of working with it. One of the more effective ones is called the "affective bridge," and it uses the body's expression of emotion, along with memory and imagination, to help patients strengthen their own emotional processing.

In Nina's case, the therapist asks her to close her eyes and picture the moment she noticed the ticket on her car. She guides her to focus on the cluster of unpleasant physical sensations that arise in her because of that discovery. She asks her to relive the moment as though it were happening right now, and even to intensify the experience. Nina reports that she feels her heart pounding hard. She places a hand over her heart, at the spot where she feels the pain. She describes a choking feeling in her throat and an urge to cry. She feels her face growing hot, and a wish to disappear.

Now the therapist guides her to search as far back as she can in her past for a moment when she felt something similar. Nina immediately recalls an incident from elementary school. The therapist asks her to return to that memory and try to relive it as though it were happening in the present.

Nina recounts: "I'm ten years old, during summer vacation before fifth grade, and my parents sent me to buy my own textbooks for the new school year. I get to the bookstore on Allenby Street in Tel Aviv with a friend from the neighborhood. At first it's a little confusing, but gradually we track down all the books on the required list. It's a lot of books, and we also need to buy notebooks, and we haul everything up to the register. The clerk rings up all the books, adds up the total, and waits for me to pay. I'm ten years old, and I take out the blank, pre-signed check my parents gave me and start filling it in. But this is the very first time in my life I've ever filled out a check, and when I hand it to the clerk, he points out that I filled it in wrong, and he can't accept it."

Nina's eyes fill with tears. The therapist encourages her to dare to feel the pain flooding her in that moment, and Nina describes the terrible shame she feels — shame in front of the clerk, in front of the friend standing beside her, in front of the other people in line, in front of her parents. This is a critical point in the process, where Nina comes face to face with the primary, maladaptive emotion that's been jamming up her emotional processing system. The term "maladaptive" is a bit misleading here, because in the original context in which it formed, that sense of shame was actually adaptive.

Grown-Up Nina Looks at Child Nina

From the story, and given material that had already come up earlier in therapy, we know that Nina's parents were, for a whole host of reasons, preoccupied with themselves, and routinely expected Nina to function well beyond her years. As a precocious child, she understood early on that expressing distress wouldn't get her anywhere, and learned instead to excel in every area of life where she was capable of it. In that sense, shame, and the wish to avoid it, pushed her toward high achievement and actually served her well in childhood.

But from the therapist's vantage point, you can see that the natural emotional reaction to a situation like the one described is anger — anger at parents who allowed themselves to place more on their daughter's shoulders than her age and abilities could bear, in this case as in so many others. Anger like that would have been pointless, even harmful, for her to express as a child. That original conditioning becomes maladaptive once it follows Nina into her adult life — so that when she gets an unjustified ticket, she's flooded with that same crushing shame she felt in a similar situation as a child.

The therapist tries to harness this insight for the sake of the emotional process, and asks Nina what she needs in this very moment, standing embarrassed and ashamed in front of the store clerk. "I need someone to calm me down, someone to support me, to handle the situation and tell me it's all going to be okay," Nina says.

At every point along the way, a therapist working with experiential approaches has several options, but in this example she uses the "affective bridge." After validating Nina's need, she asks her to imagine her present-day self, at 40, stepping into the memory and standing right beside young Nina. Now the therapist asks grown-up Nina to look at child Nina and describe what she sees. The patient says she sees the child's pain and distress.

Now the therapist guides her to validate the child. Grown-up Nina now speaks out loud to the child. With the therapist's help, she says to her: "Ninush, I can see you're under an enormous amount of pressure right now. That makes total sense. Everyone's looking at you right now, and you feel like you've made a terrible mistake. You're angry at yourself for that mistake, and you feel like you're not allowed to make mistakes, and you just want to disappear. I see that, and I can understand it."

Swapping Roles in Imagination

The second stage is soothing. Grown-up Nina tells the child: "But you know, this isn't your responsibility. Look around you. Do you see any other kids here who came without their parents to buy textbooks? No. There are lots of parents here with their kids, and there are plenty of parents who came alone, but there's no other child here whose parents sent them alone to the store with a blank check. And besides — if they were already going to send you alone to buy books, they should have explained how to fill out a check first. Nobody just knows how to fill out a check if no one's ever shown them."

At this stage, the therapist asks Nina to swap roles in her imagination, and check in on what the child inside her is feeling now. Nina reports that the child already feels some relief — a loosening of the tension that had built up in her muscles, her racing heart calming down. The therapist asks Nina what she needs right now from her adult self. Nina says she needs the adult to handle the situation. The therapist guides grown-up Nina to handle it. Still with her eyes closed, Nina imagines and describes paying for the books with her credit card, then walking out of the store with the books, with young Nina, and with her childhood friend.

The therapist suggests that grown-up Nina take child Nina, with or without the friend, to do something soothing and fun. Grown-up Nina happily suggests taking both children out for ice cream by the beach. In her imagination, she puts the books in her car, and the three of them find themselves down by the sea.

Now the therapist asks Nina to use her imagination to really feel, as concretely as possible, the pleasure of spending time by the water. Nina describes the child taking off her shoes and playing with her feet in the water. She describes how, as the adult, she orders herself a beer and enjoys watching the two children play. Afterward, the grown-up buys everyone ice cream, and the three of them sit by the sea licking their cones as the sun sets. When the therapist asks Nina what the child is feeling, a smile spreads across her face. She feels light and free — the way a child is supposed to feel.

An Object to Carry Into the Present

It's time to say goodbye, and the therapist asks Nina to give the child some object or token, something she can use to summon her adult self whenever she needs her help in the future. Nina picks up a beautiful seashell, places it in the child's palm, and explains how to use it to call on her later on.

The exercise isn't over yet. The therapist now asks her to return, in her imagination, to the moment she finds the ticket on her windshield, and to try to notice any changes in her physical reaction to that trigger. Unsurprisingly, Nina reports feeling much calmer. "How rude," she says. "Why are they hassling people who aren't bothering anyone. This is an industrial zone, and at this hour none of the shops are even open. It's just harassment of the people who work here." The therapist asks her what new ways of coping have opened up for her in the face of this trigger, and Nina says that now she doesn't feel any urge to pay the ticket immediately — instead, she wants to photograph the area, and later, once she has time, appeal the ticket through the municipality's website.

The exercise ends, and Nina opens her eyes. She feels much calmer, and she's smiling. She used the "strange reaction" as a starting point for an "affective bridge." She walked across that bridge into the past and paid a visit to her original, maladaptive emotion. Through imagination, she validated the emotional pain she felt, soothed herself, and even connected, to some degree, with the anger she should have been able to feel back then, but couldn't allow herself. When she walked back across the bridge into the present, she was able to respond to the trigger with a healthy emotional reaction. That same bullying parking ticket, which had originally filled her with maladaptive guilt and shame, now stirred up something else in her: proportionate, well-aimed anger.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page