Repeat After Me: "I Wish I Could, But I Really Don't Want To"
Updated: Oct 22
Passover is a good opportunity to look at four defense mechanisms that hurt us, and to understand that our own personal exodus from slavery to freedom can move forward if we're willing to disappoint others
The Torah speaks of four daughters: one a Victim, one a Judge, one Clueless, and one who doesn't know how to disappoint anyone. What does the Victim say? "My life is just so hard." And so, per the laws of Passover, you tell her: "It's not all about you."
What does the Judge say? "He is really not okay." Note: he — not she. Because she's excluded herself from the equation, she is, above all, the guilty one. So you, too, should grit your teeth and tell her: "This is why I'm going to therapy — me, not you." Had she gone to therapy, she'd have already discovered that she's not okay either.
What does Clueless say? "I didn't know." So tell her: "Well, now you know."
And as for the one who doesn't know how to disappoint — you open the conversation for her, as it is said: "Until you agree to disappoint, you will have no life, my sister."
Passover is a good opportunity to look at four defense mechanisms that do us harm, and to start dealing with them. Playing the victim, being judgmental, cluelessness, and overachieving can look like innate, unchangeable personality traits. But from a therapeutic point of view, they can be seen as less-than-optimal coping strategies that allow the person using them (unconsciously, of course) to mask uncomfortable feelings they struggle to bear.
There's no hard-and-fast rule that lets us look at a particular coping style and deduce exactly which uncomfortable feeling the person in front of us is avoiding, but there are common patterns: someone who struggles to bear their own aggression will often only be able to "hold" the anger they feel once they've converted it into a sense of victimhood. Someone experiencing sadness and humiliation they can't tolerate may often turn those feelings into righteous rage. But one of the patterns I find most intriguing — and identify with the most — is the overachiever, who, even when not hurting anyone around them, ends up emotionally and energetically depleted, and increasingly misanthropic.
This time, I want to think about the one who has to agree to disappoint people. People develop this particular defense for all sorts of reasons, and I'd guess there are about as many paths that lead someone to this coping style as there are people who've adopted it. But one component that stands out in at least some of these paths is anxiety. Many people who struggle to disappoint others grew up with a parental figure nearby who reacted very harshly whenever the child failed to meet their emotional needs.
I want to characterize a specific subtype here, so let me be precise: parental demandingness can take different forms. There are the "standard" narcissistic parents we know from literature and film — the kind who expect their child to bring them trophies and admiration from the world. A parent like this sees the child as an object, or an extension of their own body, whose role in the world is to serve the parent's self-image.
It's important to understand that this kind of parent leaves their mark on the child not only through criticism, but through praise as well. In other words, it's easy to see the damage a demanding, narcissistic parent causes a child who fails at the task the parent has assigned them. That child grows up with insults and humiliations whose cost is easy to imagine. But this kind of parent also produces traumatic patterns in children who excel — who do meet the task. In a different way, but with similar intensity to their less successful counterparts, the high-achieving child internalizes the fact that there's a price tag on their parent's love, and that it's entirely conditional. Fail to deliver the goods, and the love is void too.
But there's another style of parental behavior that can leave a child with a severe fear of situations where they fail to please someone else. If the narcissistically organized parent I described above seems, on the surface, larger than life and full of criticism toward the people around them, there's also the parent who appears, on the surface, to be falling apart, unable to cope with life, and full of admiration for everyone around them — and who can raise a child who, in adulthood, struggles to set limits on what others expect of them.
In this pattern, the child repeatedly experiences their parent — let's say, for the sake of example, the mother — as a damsel in distress tied to the train tracks, with the child the only one who can untie the ropes and save her moments before the train runs her over. Often, by the way, that train is the other parent — the father, in this example. It could be the mother who's afraid the father will be angry when he finds out she took their daughter shopping (a trip that might have been entirely necessary for the daughter), and who asks the daughter to lie to the father to save her own skin. It could be the mother who doesn't know how to manage money, and asks the child to do it for her.
The dysfunctional parent can also simply be depressed, anxious, and confused, and draw the child into the finest details of their psychological world and relationships, expecting the child to be their psychologist, their best friend, or their own parent. Each of these variations does what's known in therapeutic jargon as parentification — trapping the child in a dynamic where the child is the one who chronically holds the parental role, while the parent allows themselves to occupy the child's place. I stress the word "chronically" here, to make clear that placing responsibility on children — even responsibility with some parental dimensions — can actually be developmentally important, as long as it isn't constant and ongoing, and as long as it doesn't come at the expense of the child's essential needs.
These are only some of the paths, and as I said, there are others. But at the center of each of them is a repeated experience of a child facing a parent who might react very harshly if the child doesn't meet their emotional needs. Whether the parent gets angry, or cries, whether the parent is disappointed, or falls apart — either way, the child may develop in a way that greatly amplifies their fear of other people: growing up dreading situations where they need to set a limit with someone else, and becoming anxious about situations where they might fail to meet the expectations of people around them, or people who matter to them.
Their difficulty bearing these feelings is often what leads to the overachieving that's the starting point of this piece. This coping style produces people who wear themselves down, because they tend to feel that "everything is on them" — even regarding people and situations that aren't remotely within their purview — and at an intensity that isn't sustainable, meaning it can't be maintained over the long run without damaging their physical or mental health (to the extent there's even a difference between the two).
So what do we say to these boys and girls who can't bring themselves to disappoint anyone? First of all: go to therapy. But in the meantime, in moments when you're highly activated by someone else's expectations of you, try reminding yourself of the following:
1. You're feeling a lot of pressure right now from X's expectation of you, but,
2. Your pressure doesn't come only from this trigger — it also comes from your personal history, which is why you're so afraid of disappointing people.
3. The facts show that, over the course of your life, there have been plenty of times you didn't manage to meet everyone's every need, and things turned out fine anyway — maybe even better for everyone — and so,
4. Even though right now you feel an overwhelming urge to sacrifice your own needs to please X, doing so will have long-term consequences, and instead you can respond to X's expectations differently — for instance,
5. By saying to them, "I wish I could, but I really don't want to."
I'm joking, of course — but honestly, I'm completely serious.

This Week's Recommendations
Health: Fermented foods
A great deal of solid recent research shows that one of the simplest, best things you can do for your immune system is to add fermented foods to your diet. Fermented foods like sauerkraut, kimchi, pickled cucumbers, various kinds of yogurt, and of course kombucha do a lot of good for the health of our microbiome (our gut bacteria), and in turn for our immune system. Note that this doesn't mean pickles that come in cans — those don't contain live microbes, and the whole point here is to introduce live microbes into our digestive system. Likewise, make sure you're not choosing fermented foods that are also loaded with sugar — because then what did we even accomplish?
Meditation: Making mandalas in Procreate
Two notes: 1. This recommendation is only relevant if you have a computer or tablet that lets you work with a stylus (like an iPad Pro). 2. This is about creating mandalas, not coloring them in. For this, open up this rich, gorgeous app, go to actions > drawing guide > edit drawing guide > symmetry > options > radial > done, and start doodling. Within a moment you'll get why it's so much fun.
Research: The Weizmann Institute's 10K disease-prediction study
I signed up within ten minutes of hearing about this study, and a few people I care about — and who care about me — signed up right after me. I'll let the researchers speak for themselves: "The 10K Project is a long-term observational study collecting data on lifestyle and disease in the Israeli population. We're following the study population over time to try to find associations between exposure to certain factors and the onset of disease."
Participants receive their own test results, some of which aren't available anywhere else. The tests include DNA sequencing, microbiome mapping, blood sugar response to various foods, and results from additional tests — all over the course of 25 years, depending on how long the participant stays in the study.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




