Internal Chaos vs. Chronic Complaint: What's the Conflict Keeping Us Stuck?
Updated: Oct 22
Sometimes it only looks like we're searching for a solution — but our own healthy anger and sadness are blocking each other, and we're actually frozen in place.
Noa (a pseudonym, like all the names in this piece), 60, a veteran television producer, complains endlessly to anyone willing to listen (and plenty who aren't) that in every important arena of her life, everything falls on her. Whenever I try to bring her closer to her deeper feelings, we always end up stuck against the wall of the complaint. In her eyes, the problem is obvious: “I'm sick of everyone counting on me to save the day. No one takes responsibility.”
Yoav, 54, is in a relationship with a woman who's developed a kind of emotional allergy to him. Despite my attempts to help him see his own vulnerability toward her, he keeps firing off sharp little comments at home: “You're more addicted to your phone than the kids are,” or “You have time for everyone except us.” He's stuck in complaint too, and its simplest expression is: “My wife is a cold, selfish person, and she neglects me.”
Ronit, 43, a successful artist, discovered that her partner had been cheating on her for a long time. When she starts complaining about him, her listeners could leave the room and come back twenty minutes later without her noticing.
All of us can get stuck in complaint, circling the same roundabout without daring to take any of the exits. We don't always understand just how futile a chronic complaint really is. Even in therapy, it can seem like repeatedly talking about a partner's failings, or a boss's, or reality's in general, means we're actually working on the problem. But from a psychological standpoint, chronic complaint isn't an action — it's a state of paralysis.
A Defense System Gone Haywire
In Les Greenberg's emotion-focused therapy (EFT), a complaint is the result of healthy anger and sadness both trying to find expression. But every time one of them is about to move us to act, the other emotion rears up and blocks it. Healthy anger moves us to action: it lets us set boundaries, say “I'm not willing to accept this,” and change a situation. Healthy sadness is essential too: it lets us grieve, loosen our grip on what we've lost, and seek comfort.
When anger blocks sadness, or the other way around, a state of complaint forms. We're too angry to experience sadness, or too sad to fight for our place. It's like two people trying to walk through the same door at the same time: they get stuck, and spin back into the room, and the unexpressed feelings turn into a complaint.
The roundabout of complaint usually has two exits: assertive anger or adaptive sadness. How do we know which one is the right fit? One way is to ask ourselves: what internal conflict exists in this particular situation?
It's worth stressing: this isn't about passively resigning yourself to reality, but about identifying an internal clash between two psychic forces that are blocking each other and preventing movement. In emotion-focused therapy, you can often see that one of them is an adaptive emotion, and the other is a kind of “autoimmune” phenomenon — an emotional defense system that's gone haywire.

Lost in Complaint
The question “what internal conflict do I have in this situation?” is a practical version of EFT's “empty chair” technique. The therapist sets an empty chair across from the patient, and the patient alternates between sitting in the chair and on the couch where they normally sit. In the empty chair, they voice a central inner voice that's poisoning their life — usually a harsh inner critic, or a catastrophizing voice.
In most cases where patients are stuck in complaint, this chair work reveals that the aggressive voice is automatically triggering an old, maladaptive emotion. In the case of a critical voice, this is very often deep shame (“there's something wrong with me”). In the case of a catastrophizing voice, it's usually a paralyzing fear. The guiding principle in EFT is that “only emotion can change emotion.”
By the end of the process, in the case of patients stuck in complaint, we usually see that old, maladaptive response replaced by one or two healthy emotions that move them to action. The way permanent teeth push baby teeth out: healthy assertive anger is the moment patients stop shrinking in the face of the internal attack, straighten up against it, and say, “Enough, I'm not willing to let you talk to me like that anymore. I don't deserve this,” or “You're wrecking my life with all these Armageddon scenarios, let me live.”
Adaptive sadness is the moment when, instead of fearing the threat, patients manage to actually feel the pain of the suffering this self-inflicted harm has caused them. Of course, along the way, people often discover that these voices bear a less-than-coincidental resemblance to the parents who mediated reality for them in childhood.
The Anatomy of Internal Conflict
In Noa's case, she manages to say: “On the one hand, I'm dying to scream at them, to tell them no, to let them sort it out themselves. But on the other hand, there's a part of me that says if I don't save the day, they'll realize I'm too old for this field, and that I have to keep proving my added value.” When I ask Yoav to search for his own internal conflict, he says: “On the one hand, I miss her and I feel really sad and lonely, and on the other hand, I'm afraid that if I tell her that, she'll think I'm pathetic, and then she'll reject me for good.”
The solution in emotion-focused therapy is to help Noa process the shame she feels facing her inner critic, and replace it with assertive anger — once she can get angry at the inner voice demanding she be “perfect,” she'll be able to set a boundary with her colleagues without feeling guilty. In Yoav's case, the solution is to work through the catastrophizing voice until he can actually feel the adaptive sadness over the lack of closeness in his marriage. That sadness would let him approach his wife honestly and ask for intimacy — or, alternatively, let him grieve the relationship and understand he isn't getting what he needs.
If you're trying this method on yourself, remember to distinguish between a real conflict and an imagined one. Beating yourself up over how you handled a situation (“how stupid of me,” “why didn't I answer him?”) isn't an internal conflict. That's self-criticism about behavior that's already happened — a kind of inner voice trying to correct you after the fact.
There's also a more sophisticated trap, one that sometimes characterizes more rigid personality structures or personality disorders. That's Ronit's situation. When I ask her what her internal conflict is regarding her husband, she says: “I'm so angry at myself for not seeing how toxic and hurtful he was before.”
To the unsuspecting ear — including Ronit's own — this sounds like taking responsibility (“I'm angry at myself”). But here, and in similar cases, it's actually a maneuver designed to avoid the real, painful conflict: reckoning with her own aggression within the relationship, which may have contributed to the affair, or with the weaknesses that led her to look the other way at other traits of her husband's, for as long as those traits benefited her. As long as Ronit can't find, within herself, the part that genuinely co-created that dynamic with her husband, she won't identify the conflict that could actually help her out of the complaint.
The simplest formulation of a conflict that can help break the paralysis is: on the one hand, I feel (the deep emotion, say sadness) and want to do (the action that emotion points toward, say asking for a hug), and on the other hand, there's a part of me that threatens me (the threat the inner voice raises, say “only a bad person acts like that” or “if you do that, they'll leave you”).
For those able to tolerate the discomfort of a real internal conflict, the payoff is enormous. Getting off the roundabout of paralysis is an enormous relief. Either we manage to feel the healthy anger, which brings with it a biological action tendency to stand our ground, say “no,” or get up and leave; or we manage to feel healthy sadness, which brings with it the need to cry, to ask for help and closeness, and to let go.
And what about Ronit? She guards her blind spot zealously. Her ex remains an absolute monster, and she remains the foolish victim. It's hard to work through a real internal conflict with her. Ronit has expelled and disowned her own imperfect parts to protect herself. In poker, they say if you don't know who the sucker at the table is, it's you. By extension, you could say that if you can't identify your own internal conflict, you're probably the biggest problem in your own relationships.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




