top of page

Insight or Anxiety Attack? When Helplessness Disguises Itself as Enlightenment

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Apr 2
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

In times of crisis, our brains generate "insights" at a dizzying pace — but not all of them are real. There's a way to tell where they're really coming from.

In the mockumentary classic Spinal Tap, the members of the heavy metal band stand around Elvis Presley's grave, and the airheaded lead singer muses out loud, “Too much fucking perspective.” It's easy to agree with him. This current period certainly gives us too much perspective. On the other hand, when there's a lot of perspective around, life-changing insights are often born.

Encountering the impermanence and arbitrariness of everything can shift our priorities. After events like these, people may decide they need to make a change in their relationship, in their career, in how they relate to their body — in essentially any area that matters to them.

Except that the very conditions that make fertile ground for enlightenment are also characterized by extreme loss of control over our lives. And conditions like these can also stir up our inner critic, or our catastrophizing voice, which tries to help us cope with the discomfort — and, if we listen to it, can lead us into the wrong action.

So when, during a hard stretch like this, you suddenly find yourself convinced that you're in the wrong career, or not handling some health or financial issue correctly, or whatever it may be — it's essential to figure out whether you're hearing your intuition, or your critical, catastrophizing voice.

Productivity Coaches

The key to telling the two apart isn't found in the logic of the thought, but in the gut feeling. Intuition has a distinctive physical signature: when it speaks, we feel relief. Even when the message is harsh and cutting — when the inner voice tells us we're drinking too much, that we have to switch our kid to a different school, or that we owe someone an apology — listening to it comes with a physical sensation similar to the satisfaction we feel when we finally finish a puzzle. Whether we've crossed a line or need to change direction, intuition always brings with it that same sense of settling into place.

Essentially, listening to our inner voice makes us feel better. Even when we're forced to look at something we've been neglecting, it's a kind of looking that comes with a good feeling, born of the fact that we're finally addressing a part of ourselves we should have looked at long ago. It's a sensation of expansion, a kind of psychic movement toward integrity or health, in either a literal or a metaphorical sense.

Our inner critic and our catastrophizing voice, by contrast, are masters of disguise. They know how to dress up as productivity coaches, as health, financial, or relationship consultants — as experts on essentially any subject in the world. Their omnipotent illusion knows no bounds. And they certainly know how to sound realistic.

In times of crisis, like wartime, our helplessness is fuel for them. They light up when we feel powerless, and try to soothe us with the illusion that if we just do enough of something, we'll manage to escape the looming disaster — whether that disaster is existential, like a missile overhead, or interpersonal, involving humiliation.

Insight or Anxiety Attack? When Helplessness Disguises Itself as Enlightenment - illustration

Growth or Flight

The hallmark of this voice is the sense of contraction that comes with it. Its messages, even when identical to ones that could arise from the depths of our intuition, are accompanied by physical discomfort (like unease in the stomach, a tight throat, or shallow breathing), by emotional distress (like guilt, shame, or pressure), and usually by a sense of urgency too — a desperate need to immediately act on what you've just “realized,” just to silence the tormenting voice in your head. If intuition's movement is growth, this voice's movement is attack or flight.

This method of distinguishing between them rests on the fact that our bodies often process information long before our conscious minds can put it into words. The mind (meaning the thought patterns of the catastrophizing voice and the critical voice) is a master of rationalization, and if we're feeling helpless in the face of global events, these aggressive voices can easily “hijack” us and load us up with an endless to-do list whose real purpose is to hand us back a sense of control.

But our autonomic nervous system works in a more direct, simpler way, and essentially has just two modes: On — when we go into stress and are called to action — and Off — when we rest, digest, and process. When we shift our attention from the content of our thoughts to our bodily sensations, we bypass the mind's ability to lie to itself.

In psychology, people often say “if it's hysterical, it's historical” — meaning that if there's excess in how we're dealing with or talking about a situation, we're probably not fully connected to ourselves, and some kind of defense has kicked in instead.

A "Flashlight" Insight or a "Whip"

Whether it's an anxious voice telling you that, given the circumstances, you need to tighten your belt and switch to a diet of tahini and canned goods, or a shaming voice telling you that you need to stay up all night developing the app that will finally bring you your exit.

These voices usually push us toward immediate action, because they're aimed at easing the pain of shame or fear. Real intuition, by contrast, is patient, and comes with a natural calm that lets us plan our action and aim it precisely, without being impulsive. Even when both voices can deliver the exact same message, it's important to distinguish between the voices driving us to act, because maladaptive coping carries unwanted costs.

It's easy to see this if you consider that the brain essentially uses self-criticism to restore a sense of control and distract itself from external helplessness. For example: “I can't stop the war, so instead I'll become obsessive about my imagined or real failures as a mother or as a professional.”

The damage from this kind of self-talk doesn't show up when we use intuition to discover where in our lives we could express ourselves better, telling ourselves things like: “I should start volunteering, because it aligns with my values, and it will help ease my loneliness.”

So the next time a significant realization bursts in on you, demanding that you change direction, pause for a moment and scan your body before you quit your job to write the novel, confront your sister about years of grievances, start a ketogenic diet, or move to a small farming community. These might well be the right moves for you. But before you embrace the narrative your mind has woven, ask yourself what physical effect it has on you.

As you sit with it — do you feel a calming settling of the nervous system, or tension in the area between your mouth and your lower stomach? If you feel you have to act immediately just to stop feeling bad, to escape shame or guilt, you're probably listening to a catastrophizing or critical voice trying to exert a false sense of control over a world that currently feels uncontrollable.

Real insights don't arrive with a whip, they arrive with a flashlight, and if your “insight” feels like a painful lash, it's probably a symptom of the heavy stress you're carrying during this period — not an order you're required to obey.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page