top of page

"If I Stop Being a People-Pleaser, I Have to Get Used to People Around Me Being Less Pleased"

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 16, 2025
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

People-pleasing is a pattern formed in childhood as a defense against anger and disappointment, but in adulthood it can become a source of chronic anxiety and a lost connection to our own wants — because when you're constantly tracking everyone else's feelings, it's hard to know what you actually want.

“It just clicked for me,” a patient told me, “if I'm actually going to become less of a people-pleaser, I need to get used to the people around me being less pleased.” We both laughed, because even though what she'd said sounded almost obvious, there was, even at the level of the wordplay itself, a deep insight in it.

Many of us know we need to stop people-pleasing, but we can't manage to actually do it. The reason is that pleasing people solves a problem for us. It solves our fear of the other person, and of their reaction, real or imagined. Because when someone stops pleasing others, somebody else loses the comfort they'd grown used to.

In a similar vein, a few days ago I spoke with a close friend who'd been badly hurt by people in her inner circle. She said she was angry at them, and added that it had taken her a long time to realize that, because she hadn't wanted to feel her own anger.

I told her that her anger wasn't her problem — it was theirs. They were the ones who hurt her, so they're the ones who should be afraid of it, not her. I added that, in my view, most people who come to therapy struggle just like her with the difficulty of getting angry at others, and with the fear of how people will react if they dare to.

As a psychologist, I keep becoming more convinced that one of the most common, and perhaps also the quietest, problems occupying patients is excessive attention to other people. Worrying about what others think, fearing you'll disappoint them, and other agonizing variations on that theme. Even though it can seem like we're living in a jungle, inside psychologists' offices, most people are busy trying to read every emotional cue around them, regulate everyone else's mood, and make sure no one gets angry at them or disappointed in them.

The Other Person's Wishes

Many of the people who come to therapy are conscientious, empathic people who grew up in families where love, or at least some of its critical expressions, as far as they could perceive them, was actually conditional, or felt that way. Even when they grew up with well-meaning parents, life's realities were often such that the emotional blanket was simply too short to cover everyone. And they, meaning we, developed an extraordinary skill for reading microscopic shifts in facial expressions, predicting other people's expectations, and self-regulating to avoid disappointment or anger.

From the outside, this can look like kindness, an ability to be “good with people.” But psychologically, it's often a form of hypervigilance, a nervous system constantly scanning for danger. In adulthood, this pattern can show up as chronic anxiety, depression, avoidance, self-sacrifice, and a real loss of contact with one's own wants.

This excess of worry didn't grow out of nowhere. For many people, it was once a survival strategy — a way to stay safe, loved, or worthy. And the critical point I never get tired of repeating is that the strategy worked. They learned to read other people's needs because doing so genuinely protected them from danger, at least emotionally, if not worse.

Except that what served them in childhood exacts a heavy price in adulthood: they push down their own needs, confuse being loved with being safe, and lose the ability to distinguish between what they actually want and their own wish to please others.

As many readers of this column already know, when all your attention is directed outward, toward figuring out whether the other person is pleased or disappointed, it's hard to know what you actually want. Many people in this state feel exhausted, frustrated, and fake — like spies or actors who've spent their lives playing the role of a good child instead of living their own lives.

The internal noise created by other people's expectations in the past is extremely powerful, and it creates an automatic amplification of other people's expectations in the present. A significant part of therapeutic work is turning down that noise, so it becomes possible to relocate one's own internal center of gravity.

Since a person who stops people-pleasing leaves behind them a trail of displeased people — often including their partner, their parents, and their teenage children — those people can act like a Greek chorus telling them that the moment they start pleasing less, they're actually becoming a cold, selfish person. This question reaches therapy too, and the answer, of course, is that being less occupied with meeting other people's expectations doesn't mean you care about them less.

It only means you want to stay in touch with both their needs and your own at the same time, and to make decisions out of genuine choice rather than a pleasing reflex. It means you're not willing to let other people hold the remote control that determines your own peace of mind. In the end, the people who manage to find their footing against the boundaries you set will enjoy a more genuine connection with you, because the bond between you will no longer be maintained by quiet submission, but by free choice.

"If I Stop Being a People-Pleaser, I Have to Get Used to People Around Me Being Less Pleased" - illustration

Other People's Problems

The irony, of course, is that while people who overvalue others' needs tend to seek therapy quite often, people who care too little about others reach therapy far less frequently, and usually not of their own free will. The first reason for this is that they experience far less internal distress than the first group does.

Even though narcissistic adults are, at their core, lonely children whom the people around them once treated as objects, in practice, people who are less sensitive to the expectations of others tend to be less anxious about rejection or dissatisfaction, and so they don't experience the same tension when conflicts arise. They may generate tension around them, but within themselves, they tend to feel fairly calm.

Unfortunately, therapy usually happens when a person is themselves in pain — not when the people around them are suffering. What's more, unlike people who suffer inwardly, people who care too little tend to offload the damage they cause onto others. Partners, friends, or colleagues may get hurt, but the person themselves doesn't always feel that anything is wrong. Since the distress gets “exported” rather than experienced from within, they have little motivation to seek therapy, and when they do arrive, it's often only after intense pressure from those around them, in the form of an ultimatum from a partner, a conflict at work, or a legal intervention. Their therapeutic journey tends to begin later, and is often accompanied by resistance.

On top of that, their defense mechanisms feel healthy to them, like part of who they are. While the people-pleaser might feel their pleasing tendency nagging at them like a sore throat, the maladaptive coping patterns of those indifferent to others' suffering go down smoothly, matching their own sense of self. They don't experience their emotional disconnection or self-focus as a problem — quite the opposite, they may see it as strength or independence. And when a defense mechanism “feels good,” there's no reason to question it. People like this also tend to frame problems as other people's problems.

Hard Not to Disappoint You

But before you secretly congratulate yourself on being the one who goes to therapy, thinking that means you're the “healthy” one in the family or the relationship — the one going instead of the people in your life who “really need it” — think again. All our suffering is real (okay, not all of ours, but most of ours), but the way we handle it also affects the people around us. Hypersensitivity isn't a trait that comes without costs.

I don't know exactly how the people around you “subsidize” your own distress, but chances are they do. Sometimes the wish to appease and preserve harmony puts a hidden pressure on the people around you to meet your standard, to pay you back, not to disappoint you — or to be satisfied with everything you do, simply because you do so much.

In other cases, avoiding confrontation can make other people feel like they're walking on eggshells around you, while you have no idea that's the case. What's more, your habit of saying “yes” when you mean “no” can turn you passive-aggressive, and can spark cycles of resentment and confusion. In short, our own personal pain doesn't protect us from responsibility for the patterns we create.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page