top of page

Be the Change You Want to See in Your Partner

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 11, 2021
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Encouraging or threatening your partner into changing won't work. What you can do is identify what's blocking the change and make clear what the natural consequences of the current situation are. Instead of complaining, show how happy you are with the change you made yourself.

One of the questions I'm asked most often by email is how to get a partner to do something they have no desire to do. Usually the question is how to convince them to go to therapy, but sometimes someone is trying to get their partner to quit smoking weed, stop drinking, start exercising or meditating, or finally deal with their debts to the government. Most of the people who write to me describe their failed attempts in the past, and in the way they describe them you can hear a familiar mix of worry and despair.

That mix of despair and worry is why the two leading tactics people use when trying to persuade someone close to them to change are encouragement (that is, focusing on the benefits of the change) and threats (what will happen if the person doesn't change). But these tactics don't work, and from where I sit, the failure is a foregone conclusion.

What's wrong with encouragement? It rests on the mistaken assumption that what keeps a person from changing is that they aren't pressing hard enough on the metaphorical gas pedal. Both sides, the persuader and the person being persuaded, can share this error, and it can lead to an unwanted outcome, such as a grandiose decision to change everything starting tomorrow. That outcome is unwanted because very few people can really make big changes this way and have them last. I've written about this before, but the road to big changes begins with setting achievable goals, because a growing sense of self-efficacy is a cornerstone of building motivation.

But that's the secondary problem. What I want to sharpen this time is that in most cases where it looks as though the obstacle to change is a lack of motivation, the truth is that the person already has plenty of motivation. So why aren't they moving forward? The real reason they're stuck is that while one foot is pressing the gas pedal, the other foot is pressing the brake pedal with all its might. In other words, there's nothing to encourage. What needs to be done is to understand what the block is and soften it.

Sometimes the block is simple to undo. Some people just need help getting started ("Can you just find the relevant emails from the accountant for me? I go dark in front of my inbox"), and some need someone alongside them ("I'd love it if once a week you checked in with me on whether I've meditated yet"). Others need someone to make the introduction for them ("Can you write to the yoga teacher and tell him I'll call?"). But sometimes the block that makes it hard for a person to change their life is deeper and more emotional. Whether it's fear of failure (in recovery, or in sticking with something), searing shame (about the addiction, say, or the depth of the debts, or the extra weight), or despair, you can always offer empathy.

Be the Change You Want to See in Your Partner - illustration

And what's the mistake in threatening? Threats usually strengthen resistance, but the deeper flaw is that reality doesn't need a spokesperson. Instead of threatening ("This is the last time I'm reminding you to talk to the bank"), it makes sense to check just once (and even that is unnecessary) that the person isn't missing information. In my experience it's never a problem of missing information, but I'll indulge you in nagging your partner one more time about why they need to go to therapy, quit drinking, get back to exercising, get a medical checkup, talk to the boss, or have The Talk with their parents. After that, you're the ones who need to start thinking, on your own: if my partner doesn't take my advice, what does that mean for me? And how am I going to deal with it?

For example, take a partner who drinks too much (a common phenomenon during Covid). If he doesn't make a significant change, he'll simply keep drinking, in a way that will (again) leave him falling apart emotionally in front of the kids, say. In that case, what it may mean for you is that the parenting your children are getting isn't the best. In this scenario you might cope by turning to a child psychologist, who can help you explain your partner's, their dad's, behavior to your kids, even if your partner is very much against bringing in an outsider.

And if it's a partner who has no intention of making the change needed to deal with the debts he's responsible for, it may mean that you won't be able to meet your own payments. In that case, one way to cope might be to bring your partner's parents into the picture, even if he doesn't want that. The main point is that you are laying the natural consequences out before your partner. I stress that these are natural consequences, not punishment. That is, turning to the child psychologist or to a relative in the two examples above are consequences that flow naturally from reality, from your partner's own choice. And if those consequences are unwelcome to them, they still have a way to prevent them: take themselves in hand and make the change.

More specifically, I'm often asked how to encourage someone to go to therapy, and I'd like to offer a few small tips. Talk about it matter-of-factly. Don't assume in advance that talking about therapy shames the person. Emphasize that it's about support they need in light of the many fronts they're dealing with (and not a process meant to fix some essential flaw in their personality). That's probably true, because if you were with them right now in Thailand, sipping coconut shakes while getting a foot massage, there's a good chance your partner's general state would be a lot better.

But my most significant piece of advice is (to paraphrase the famous line): be the change you want to see in your partner. Want him to exercise more? Instead of preaching, focus on exercising and enjoying it. Want him to smoke less? Smoke less yourself, and even if you don't smoke at all, change course: instead of being bitter, show him how good your mood is, how easily you get up in the morning, how steady your mood is. Want him to go to therapy? Don't show him that someone who goes to therapy turns into a nagging, moralizing pest. Quite the opposite: demonstrate through your behavior that therapy helps you be far more satisfied with your life. Act in a way that makes your partner admit to himself that he, too, wants to feel as good as you do, and that will already encourage him to follow your lead. Like the famous fake-orgasm scene in "When Harry Met Sally," get them to say, "I'll have what she's having."


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page