top of page

A Vault for the Psyche: Why Sometimes Someone Else Needs to Remember for Us

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 7
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

In moments of crisis, we don't lose our memories — we lose access to them. One of therapy's hidden functions is to hold on to the memories that get suppressed, retrieve them at the right moment, and put the pieces of the puzzle back together.

Ronen sits across from me, leaning forward, breathing fast and broken. ‘She's about to leave me,’ he says, his voice cracking. ‘Everything is ruined. If she goes now, after this blowup, I don't know how I'll go on.’ Ronen is married — but not to the woman he's talking about.

He's a very successful man, generally speaking — just not in this stormy, damaging relationship, the one that brought him into therapy in the first place. Right now he looks like someone caught in a storm that threatens to wipe out everything he's built.

The woman he's having an affair with — the one he himself has repeatedly described as childish and hurtful, and in any case completely wrong for him, the one he's already broken up with a good few times — is threatening to leave him again.

And once again I find myself unable to believe that, instead of helping him make a little voodoo doll of her so we can stick pins in it together, I have to sit through another round of him being furious at himself over this or that mistake, insisting he's the only one responsible for the relationship, and ready to do anything to stop her from leaving.

Living in the Absolute Present

In those moments in the clinic, while his inner critic lashes him, Ronen is in what I call the ‘absolute present.’ You remember how it felt as a kid when you couldn't draw well, couldn't make sense of a fractions or percentages problem, or didn't get the part you wanted in the class play? How you sat in that dark pit, certain you'd feel that way forever? That pit is still there once we've grown up, and sometimes we slip back into it.

Like Ronen right now. For him, reality has narrowed down to only this moment, and the only thing he feels is the dread of her leaving him. He's forgotten the sleepless nights he described to me only two weeks ago; he's forgotten the feeling of smallness and humiliation he felt when she screamed at him; he's forgotten the original reason he came to me in the first place — a desperate wish to break free of this relationship and get back to himself.

This forgetting isn't accidental; it's a survival defense mechanism. Ronen is trapped inside an early emotional schema of fear of abandonment. When that schema is activated, it takes over the entire space of his awareness and produces a ‘self-state’ in which the old pain, and the wrongs he's suffered at his lover's hands — the knowledge, the facts, everything I sometimes want to grab him by the shoulders and shout — simply aren't accessible. The present emotion is so powerful that it colors the past and the future in the same shade, or more precisely, in the same single color: black, black upon black.

If we think about this in terms of ‘modes,’ or self-states, in moments of crisis the patient shifts into the mode of the ‘vulnerable child’ — or, in Ronen's case, the ‘abandoned child.’ In this state, the healthy adult part of him is sent on forced leave. That's the rational part that remembers the damage the relationship causes, the part that keeps trying to end it, the part that also understands this affair isn't a solution to his problems in his marriage, and that in that sense too, he's playing with fire. It's also the part that brought him into therapy in the first place.

What's happening here is a functional dissociation: in order to survive the terror of losing this woman, his psyche ‘disconnects’ his access to the memories of the pain she's caused him. He isn't simply forgetting; he's splitting off from the part of himself that knows how to set boundaries.

Depositing in the Psyche's Vault

This is where my role as the guardian of memory comes in. When I lay the ‘transcripts’ of our previous sessions in front of him, I'm not just reminding him of facts — I'm calling back into the room that same ‘healthy adult’ whom Ronen has metaphorically gagged and locked in a back room of his own mind. I release that healthy adult and represent him until he recovers, surface the knowledge that was deposited with me for safekeeping, and help Ronen re-integrate the parts of himself that have split apart.

We're used to thinking of therapy as a place for processing emotions or solving problems, but alongside that, always, therapists are also archivists of their patients' inner lives. One of the great problems of the human psyche is its tendency toward ‘emotional amnesia’ in times of crisis. When we're flooded with adrenaline or panic, we lose touch with other parts of ourselves. We dissociate from anything that doesn't serve our immediate survival.

Because Ronen has, over these past months, deposited with me memories of his pain, insights about how toxic the relationship is, and moments of clarity in which he understood he had to leave — now, when he's drowning in the emotion of the present, my job is to go to the vault, or the archive, take out those pieces of information, and lay them out in front of him.

I don't argue with his pain, of course. I sometimes think of the well-known Holocaust survivor K. Tzetnik's (Yehiel De-Nur's) LSD-assisted therapy sessions, in which, for moments at a time, his psychoanalyst appeared to him as a Nazi officer. To some degree, something like that is always happening in therapy, and that isn't a problem — quite the opposite, it's the whole point. That's exactly what we stir up, and what we work with. I simply remind him that there's another person in the room: his own self from last week.

‘I hear your panic right now, and I can feel it. There's nothing more painful than a breakup, and that's what you're feeling right now. But I'm also holding, in my heart and in my mind, the man who sat in this very chair a month ago, begging to find a way out, because he felt he was losing his soul in this relationship. The same man who also told me he'd rather leave his wife when he isn't in the middle of an affair.’

A Vault for the Psyche: Why Sometimes Someone Else Needs to Remember for Us - illustration

Stitching the Tears Together

The therapist's role as chief memory officer isn't only useful for stitching together these moment-to-moment tears. In fact, even in the far less dramatic moments of therapy, it's one of the central tools therapists use to decode the hidden architecture of the psyche. Sticking with the same example: when a patient is fighting to hold on to a relationship that's hurting him, an obvious question arises — what is it, about being left, that makes him feel he has to chase after her and convince her to love him?

Here too, the memory library I keep lets me cross-reference the data. I pull out a ‘puzzle piece’ that was deposited with me over the course of the process — in this case, an ambivalent mother who sent the patient to be raised by his grandmother from a young age, every time she felt motherhood was too much for her.

I remember this, and now I remind him of it too — or check with him whether he can remember it himself — because we both know his defectiveness schema, the one that makes him feel instantly guilty whenever he's left, and pushes him into the position of a beggar at the door. When this woman leaves him, his whole brain shifts into a state of high alert and panic — the past comes flooding back.

Like someone with PTSD for whom fireworks bring back the battlefield, or the way a passing motorcycle can remind us of an air-raid siren and make us practically jump out of our chairs in fear that it's starting again, the drama of the breakup throws him back into the past, or brings the past back to life — however you want to look at it.

As the archivist, I'm able to check with him whether the way he describes this current breakup closely resembles the way he once described his mother's repeated abandonments. That insight can give rise to a moment of clarity. There's a real chance the patient will understand that he isn't actually fighting for this particular woman, but is trying, again and again, to solve an old puzzle with pieces that were never going to fit.

My job is to lay these pieces side by side: the childhood memory, the accounts from last year, and this morning's drama. That's how the memory library turns into a map. Suddenly he doesn't just ‘feel’ the pain — he starts to understand it. He discovers that the toxic lover isn't the real destination, only a reflection of a need that was never met. At that moment, our shared memory becomes the key that unlocks the door out of the infinite loop.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page