Winning Without Arguing: Lessons From a Grandfather I Never Had
Updated: Oct 22
Right before you dive into another pointless argument about politics, or with the barista — stop. A few insights from Dale Carnegie and Chris Voss on the mistakes we make in communication, and the better choice: labeling emotions
A few years ago, when I moved into a new clinic, I found myself waiting a whole day for furniture parts from Ikea. That evening, I sat my kids down for a talk. "After I'm 120," I began dramatically, "when I'm gathered to my ancestors, you might receive a file containing every customer-service call your dear mother ever made. If you choose to listen to them, I don't want you to think you never really knew your mom."
The reason for this dramatic confession was an argument I'd had that day with an Ikea customer service rep — an argument that revealed an aggressive streak in me I hadn't known existed. I'm too embarrassed to even remember what the argument was about anymore, but I remember perfectly the sentence I hurled at the poor man: "The only reason you're saying that is that you're not educated enough!"
Very Important People
I was reminded of this embarrassing episode recently while listening to the classic book by businessman and lecturer Dale Carnegie, "How to Win Friends and Influence People." Carnegie, who was born in the 1880s and wrote the book in the 1930s, was a contemporary of my great-grandfather. I wish I'd had a grandfather like him — maybe then I'd have avoided embarrassing situations like the one I described. I'd have known that the best way to win an argument is to avoid it in the first place.
Carnegie's voice echoed in my ears this week when I went to buy coffee before starting my workday. I asked the barista for an americano with steamed milk. "What?" she asked. I repeated the order. "What?" she asked again. I repeated it a third time. The barista shot me an annoyed look and snapped: "You're speaking too quietly, I can't hear what you want."
I thought to myself that what she should have said was: "Sorry, the machines here are really loud and I can't hear you — could you speak up a bit, please?" But then I heard Grandpa Carnegie whisper: "What will you gain by telling her that?"
Since I've been listening to him very closely lately, I knew the answer: if I pointed it out to her, I'd wound her pride. She wouldn't learn a thing from my remark. That's another principle Carnegie defined so well in his nearly hundred-year-old bestseller: there's never any point in criticizing a person.
These two insights — never get into an argument, and never criticize — are, of course, closely linked. Both echo through Chris Voss's book on negotiation, which I wrote about here last week, and it's clear Voss learned a great deal from Carnegie.
Carnegie's central thesis is that people need to feel important. I find a lot of value in this thesis, even though it's presented in general terms, without getting into the important nuances of the different ways people satisfy this need.
For that reason, Carnegie warns against getting drawn into arguments. Even if we "win" the argument and produce the most crushing arguments, our relationship with the other person can get hurt. People hate feeling wrong or humiliated.
If you have any doubt about that, look at Israel's leadership, and the incoming American leadership. A combative approach often breeds resentment. The way to correct the other person's mistaken perspective, according to Carnegie, is to validate their point of view as much as possible, and gently lead them to reconsider their positions.
The "I'm Right" Hashtag
Voss, too, sees arguments as an ineffective negotiating tool. The inefficiency comes from the fact that arguments make us more emotional and narrow the channels of communication between us and the other person.
Instead of trying to "win," Voss suggests using techniques like labeling emotions ("It sounds like you're set on this"). Endless labeling and untiring mirroring, to create an atmosphere of cooperation. The goal is to steer the conversation toward a resolution without making the other side feel defeated.
Why are we so argumentative? It may have to do with the fact that, cognitively, the moment a claim is presented to us, we naturally try to assess its validity. We judge: is it right? Wrong? Partly right? On top of that, because it matters to us to feel right and important, one of the criteria we use to evaluate a claim is: if it's true, what does that say about me?
For instance, this week I met a woman at my fitness trainer's who told me she does her own bookkeeping, without an accountant's help, and saves thousands of shekels a year. She explained that up-to-date software makes the process extremely simple.
The moment I took in what she was saying, I could feel my brain go on the defensive. Is that true? Is it really that simple? Am I wrong to hand my bookkeeping over to a bookkeeper? Does that make me lazy? Spoiled? Stupid?
I could watch my own mental processes unfold in slow motion. If I'd given in to them, I would have started explaining why her bookkeeping might be simple but mine is complicated, or emphasizing the cost of a mistake versus the cost of bookkeeping services — or maybe saying something unkind about how I prefer to spend my limited free time.
But since I was steeped in my Voss-and-Carnegie marinade, I remembered that it's more important to understand her intention than to judge what she said. So I took a step back, looked at it from the outside, and told her honestly that I was impressed by her courage in handling her own bookkeeping.
I noted that a lot of people are afraid to do that, and that it's an inspiring choice. If I'd acted on instinct, we'd both have walked away from that chance encounter with a bad taste in our mouths. But thanks to people wiser than me, I think we both walked away feeling good.

Shutting Down the Communication Skies
Although the situation I described wasn't a negotiation, the principle clearly applies there too, and then some. Chris Voss emphasizes the value of "tactical empathy" — a deep understanding of the other person's point of view without expressing agreement or disagreement. He explains that success in negotiation depends on uncovering the feelings and motives behind what the other person says or does.
When we rush to evaluate or judge a statement, we block the opportunity to gather essential information about what actually matters to the other person, or what frightens them.
For example, if I'm trying to close a deal and the other side says, "This deal is a disaster for us," instead of refuting what they said or explaining why they're wrong, Voss suggests mirroring their feelings: "It sounds like this deal doesn't meet your needs." This approach creates a space in which the person across from me can open up and reveal their deeper needs or goals.
Avoiding argument is connected to the human aversion to criticism. Carnegie emphasizes that people need appreciation and validation, and no matter what they say to us, the truth is they always resist criticism.
When we offer an immediate evaluation or judgment of what's said to us, even with good intentions, in most cases the person across from us will feel that we're criticizing them. That will make them defensive, and make them "shut down their communication skies."
So what do you say when someone tells you something that, in your view, contradicts all the facts (for example: "If he could, Netanyahu would bring back all the hostages")? Carnegie suggests asking questions like "What makes you believe that?" or "Can you help me understand your point of view?" Questions like these express respect for the other person, encourage them to share more, lower their defenses, and let them reveal their real concerns.
Mirror My Despair
Applying Carnegie and Voss's principles is, for me, a genuine case of "fake it till you make it." None of this advice comes naturally to me. And yet I feel that in the rolling intergalactic explosion known as life in Israel, where conflict chases conflict and friction chases friction — between customer service and the barista, between small talk and driving in the street, between a protest and a political argument — I have something to learn from the insights of a man who was, yes, white, yes, a man, yes, dead, and yet not a fool. To put these insights into practice, these days I try to:
When someone says something provocative or controversial to me, stop and think about their motive before I respond.
Use open questions like: "What makes you feel that way?" or "Can you tell me more about what's bothering you?"
Mirror and label their emotions — that is, repeat back what they said and name the feeling behind it ("It sounds like this situation is really frustrating for you").
And above all, avoid the urge to correct. Human beings are driven by emotion, not only by logic. If you run into me on the street in the near future, know that this is the period where I'm inviting you to say provocative nonsense at me. I'm doing my very best to resist the temptation to argue or correct what people say to me, and instead, to focus on the needs behind their words.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




