top of page

Why People Love to Say "No," and How to Use It to Our Advantage

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 23, 2021
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Carefully phrasing a question can move us toward our goals, as long as we remember the human tendency to answer in the negative. The method takes advance preparation and practice, but it may pay off

A few years ago (B.C., Before Corona) I wrote several columns inspired by Never Split the Difference, the masterful guide to negotiation by Chris Voss, who specialized in negotiating with terrorists. In one of them I expanded on situations in which we try to persuade the other side to agree to something whose advantages they don't yet see for themselves, and on how one technique that can bring us closer to our goal is acknowledging that people love to say "no." Refusing is an act that gives us a sense of security. Better safe than sorry, says our brain, and passes up the opportunity it's being offered. In that column I stressed that understanding this mechanism can help us when we're trying to help people agree with us.

For lack of space, I didn't give enough examples in that column, and the popular protest in the comments section seemed to me entirely justified. Today I want to settle that debt and illustrate the idea in a variety of ways. I'll begin with an example from Voss's book. When a salesman calls you and wants to tell you about a great new offer, he can ask, "Is now a good time to talk?" or he can ask, "Am I disturbing you?"

On the face of it, the two questions are parallel. In ordinary interactions we might use one wording or the other without giving it much thought. But when what's at stake matters to us, and given our fondness for the word "no," it's worth noticing that each of these two questions raises the chances of getting the opposite answer. If I ask someone, "Is now a good time to talk?" and he answers "No," I haven't gotten what I wanted. But if I ask him, "Am I disturbing you?" and his answer is "No," then I have.

Now let's move on to more everyday examples. Say I've scheduled a get-together with a friend for Monday at seven in the evening and I need to push it back by a week. I can ask her: "Is it okay with you if we postpone to next Monday?" But I can also write to her: "I need to push our meeting back a week, is that a problem?" In the first example I don't want a negative answer, and in the second I do. Because that negative answer is negative only on the surface, only technically. In substance, this negative answer is actually a positive response to my request: to move the meeting back a week.

Say my child has to read a few chapters of a novel over the vacation. I can ask him every day whether he feels like reading a chapter now, or I can ask him on the very first day whether he feels like reading all the chapters in one go today. Assuming he's a regular kid who loves saying "no," the first phrasing will serve as a platform for his procrastination, because he'll tell me he doesn't feel like reading a chapter right now. But the second phrasing is a kind of win-win. If he answers yes and sits down to read all the chapters in one go, great. And if he prefers to answer no, as the theory presented here predicts, then fine: from his answer that reading all the chapters today doesn't suit him, it's easier for me to lead him to the conclusion that he's actually choosing to read (only) some of the chapters today.

Not all the examples are shallow and technical. This method of summoning the other side's "no" can also help us show the partner we're negotiating with that it's worth reconsidering their position, because it carries significant costs. Say I'm trying to persuade someone to collaborate with me on a big project, but every time we're supposed to move forward, she drags her feet. Meetings get canceled or postponed, she doesn't do her part, and I feel more and more bitter and frustrated. I have two options. I can confront her and ask: "Are you even interested in continuing to work with me on this project?" But I can also ask her: "Would you prefer to stop here, give up on the partnership in this project, and release me to look for a new partner?"

Again, given the human pull toward the answer "no," questions that seem similar actually have opposite potential. If she answers "no" to the first phrasing, I lose the partnership with her. But if she answers "no" to the second, I gain her renewed commitment to the process. I chose this example to show that the same technique has a shallow use and a deep use. The shallow use is the salesman's, whose only request is six minutes of your time. Once you've told him he isn't disturbing you, you're already fairly cornered and now have to hear all the details of the offer he wants to sell you.

But in the case of the discussion with the ambivalent partner, this is a deep use. When I ask her whether she wants to give up on the project, I'm not trying to catch her out. That wouldn't really help me. If she doesn't want to take part in this project, I'd rather know sooner than later. Posing the question this way forces the partner to weigh the downsides of giving up on working with me, and in that sense it enlists, for my benefit, the human aversion to loss, instead of encouraging her to imagine the advantages of getting me off her back.

Why People Love to Say "No," and How to Use It to Our Advantage - illustration

In other words, in the deep version of this technique, striving for "no" can also serve as a sophisticated platform for bringing our own point of view to the surface: Do you want our company to be remembered as a company that discriminated against people with disabilities? Do you want all your pocket money for the year to be blown before summer vacation? Do you want to bail tonight too, and risk that they'll stop inviting you? No, no and no.

Using this method isn't intuitive, and it takes a little preparation in advance. But with a bit of practice, you can crack it. In most cases when we're trying to persuade someone of something, most of the picture is known to us in advance, which lets us prepare for the negotiation and word our questions beforehand so that "no" is the answer we want. Another advantage that emerges while using this method is an energetic one. Precisely because most of us feel more comfortable saying "no," and begin to relax within a dialogue once it becomes clear that the other side respects our "no," it's also easier to enter a conversation when we're trying to get to a "no" rather than a "yes."

Amalia Rosenblum's Recommendations:

Documentary: Man on Wire (2008)

In the summer of 1974, an unconventional young Frenchman with a fairly high adrenaline threshold, Philippe Petit, enlisted a very daring group of friends to string a steel cable between the Twin Towers and walk across it. The crew, who had a well-developed historical consciousness, documented the clandestine operation, which required overcoming security obstacles in buildings that were then nearing completion. The result is James Marsh's riveting film about courage and imagination, beneath which another film peeks out, one whose subject is actually friendship and its unraveling.

Book: "Let the Great World Spin" (Am Oved, 2013)

Against the backdrop of that same day in 1974 when Philippe Petit walked the wire, Colum McCann delivers one of the peaks of the last 20 years of literature. On that historic day the lives of the characters cross and change, Corrigan the frayed monk, Tillie the prostitute and others, and New York in the 1970s comes to life unforgettably. The book has been translated into more than 30 languages and has won a sea of awards, but I can tell you my own criterion for success: it's one of the books I will never lend to anyone. Let them buy their own copy.

Family activity: Making a board game

I was born in New York in 1974, right when Petit walked the wire, and grew up in Jaffa in the 1980s. In my childhood there wasn't much to do on rainy winter days. So my brother and I started making board games for ourselves out of our imaginations. Together we would decide on the track, the stations, the goals, the rules and the various action cards, and then we would devote many hours to preparing the game. In many ways, making the game was the truly exciting part, even more than the game itself.

I remembered this one Saturday recently, and the result was great joy. My younger son came up with a game based on a car-racing track, which let us give expression to his expertise in cars and to our shared urge to get away from screens for a few hours. The only supplies required are plain cardboard, markers, scissors, and a die you can borrow from another game and try to remember to return afterward. The preparation was a great deal of fun, but his pride when we later played the game with other family members was also heartwarming and joyful.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page