top of page

They're Not Just Boring You. Your Brain Is Telling You to Move On

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Aug 20
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

We're used to thinking that people bore us because they lack interest in us or personal charisma. But sometimes boredom is a signal that actually helps us navigate the social world

I want to remind you of three types of people you may have run into this past month. The first sat across from you at a friend's place — or, if you're a psychologist, maybe he sat across from you on the couch in your clinic. Every time you said something, you got back a weak, flat response. He isn't ignoring you, and he isn't arrogant either — he's not even on his phone. He just seems psychologically lifeless, as if he only comes alive when someone blows air into him, like a balloon. Within twenty minutes you feel a strange, draining exhaustion.

The second type never stops talking. He walks you through every detail of his commute, the exact sequence of events in his office renovation, and everything his second cousin once said about the foreign-currency fees his bank charges on credit-card purchases abroad. And even though this flood of words is supposedly an attempt to get closer to you, the more he talks, the further away he seems to drift. His talking doesn't bridge the gap between your mind and his — it fogs you over, puts up a smokescreen between the two of you.

The third, a woman, is different from the first two. She is completely sincere. She doesn't withdraw and go slack like the first, and she doesn't repeatedly take verbal "scenic detours" like the second. She looks at you, she's engaged, eager to discuss life, dilemmas, philosophies. She genuinely wants to be helpful and to learn from you — and yet, as she talks, you can tell that the picture of reality she's painting is fairly warped, and that there's an enormous blind spot in her field of vision.

These three types use speech in completely different ways, and each of them does it for different psychological reasons. What all three have in common is that they trigger the exact same subjective reaction in us: crushing boredom.

Navigating the Social Map

We tend to treat boredom as a trivial nuisance, or as the result of someone's lack of personal charisma, and to assume there's nothing to be done about it. But I want to put forward the idea that human speech isn't merely decorative entertainment. In our most intimate relationships, talk serves countless purposes, so I'm setting those aside for this analysis — but in every other context, conversation is, at its core, an adaptive navigation tool. We talk to each other in order to sharpen, fill in, and expand our picture of reality.

In every conversation, to some degree, we compare coordinates, test our perceptions against reality, and update the mental models we've built of the social and physical world. The more detailed, comprehensive, and accurate our maps are, the better our odds of surviving and thriving. So while we're talking with someone, our cognitive machinery is running an unconscious cost-benefit analysis: is this person helping me calibrate my map?

For the answer to be yes, three basic criteria have to be met. First, there has to actually be a signal. This sounds trivial, but it's true: the amount of information present has to clear a certain bar to register as valuable (except in cases where the one word spoken is: fire!). Second, the verbal signal has to "reach for contact" — meaning it has to engage with actual reality, with things that matter, rather than functioning as a distraction. And finally, the signal has to be calibrated — meaning the speaker's own reality-testing has to be reliable.

Boring on Purpose (Defensively)

When someone's psychological defenses corrupt one of these criteria, the brain understands that it can't get any usable "navigation data" about the world from the person in front of it, and that it's better off paying less attention to them. It flags this with a clear message: I'm bored!!!

That's what I mean when I say these three types are boring us defensively. The first type withdraws into a kind of brain death, a defensive emptiness. It may be the result of emotional neglect in early childhood, or experiences that chronically instilled shame and taught him that occupying psychological space is dangerous.

He's the kind of person you ask, after the weekend, how his grandmother's ninetieth birthday went, and he'll mutter "fine." You check whether his sister managed to make it in from abroad despite all the delays, and he'll answer "yeah." You push a little and ask what it was like seeing her again after so many months, and he'll say "really nice."

Every question is a ball you're passing him, and he just drops it on the floor. No follow-up, no building anything together, not even the faintest seasoning of a funny observation. In practice, you're interviewing a statue. It's clear, then, that he's violating the first requirement we listed — existence. The conversation bores us because he isn't contributing any coordinates of his own to the map, or any other information at all.

The second type uses over-elaboration as an avoidance tactic. Genuine emotional depth raises the stakes of vulnerability and allows for less control over the situation. For historical reasons, he isn't willing to take those risks. To keep you from "seeing him," language serves him as camouflage netting — he fills the air with bureaucratic or gossipy details at the shallowest possible level (gossip about people you don't know, or gossip that's already been reported everywhere), in order to prevent any intimacy from developing between you.

If, for instance, you ask him how he feels about the wave of layoffs that just started at his company, he might respond without pausing for breath — but ten minutes later you'll realize you know less about his inner state than you did before he started answering. He's violating the second requirement: relevance and focus.

Signals in the Fog

We get bored because the avalanche of words tumbling over us isn't leading anywhere. Our brain quickly understands that trying to track these words is genuinely like wandering through fog. The boredom you feel represents a healthy message from your brain: please stop straining to decode noise that carries no real signal.

The woman in the third example is earnest, expressive, and eager to connect with you. She doesn't withdraw like a ghost, and she doesn't spin like a top. The problem is that her internal compass is broken, which means her self-narrative is completely disconnected from the reality the rest of us are living in.

In practice, this might be the friend who sits you down for coffee to discuss her ongoing conflicts at work. She speaks with complete sincerity, and her body language is open and believable — and then she starts explaining that the real problem is that she's too gentle and too patient, that people constantly mistake her modesty for weakness, and that in the end she's the one absorbing everyone's hostility because she's too empathetic to tolerate conflict.

You can see where I'm going with this, right? I'm talking about a situation where you, and everyone else who knows her, can see that she's actually combative, that she's quick to react, and that she constantly makes other people feel judged. And the thing is, she isn't lying in order to manipulate you — she genuinely believes this self-portrait. In doing so, she's violating the third requirement: accuracy. And it bores us because her map was printed with the directions reversed.

Because her narrative is disconnected from reality, she isn't where she thinks she is. So none of your advice can help her, and none of her insights will help you. And starting to correct her faulty reality-testing is not a fun thing to do — even if you happen to be her psychologist. On the other hand, validating that mistaken reality-testing is stifling, because cooperating with this fantasy is an experience that leaves us feeling, at best, inauthentic. The boredom we feel marks our own surrender to the fact that the conversation is useless in an existential, psychological sense.

When we say of someone that they're boring, we sometimes feel a pang of guilt. That judgment can make us worry that we're being cruel or condescending. But if we think of boredom as a response to the fact that the person in front of us is communicating defensively, we understand that boredom is the body's — the brain's — way of resisting the other person's demand that we spend precious psychological energy.

By our nature, every conversation is part of a shared march, one step along a path running parallel toward building a more accurate map of the world. When, instead, the conversation turns into an obstacle course in which we end up carrying the other person on our back, playing blind man's bluff with them, or pretending our mind is bored, that boredom is its own way of signaling to us that the person in front of us isn't, right now, a fit partner for the journey.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page