top of page

Why Is It So Hard for Us to Talk About Money?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 18, 2018
4 min read

We're embarrassed by how we handle our finances, even though no one ever actually taught us how. The only real solution is to start talking — with our partners, our friends, and the professionals we trust.

It won't surprise you to learn that couples who tell each other what feels good in bed have more sex. It's just as obvious that people who plan meals together eat better. In exactly the same way, couples who talk about how they handle money end up earning more of it. So why are we still so afraid to talk about it?

1. Because we don't know what's normal.

If we want to know how healthy we are, we get a blood test, and once the results come in, we know exactly where we stand relative to the norm. But we have no equivalent gauge for our financial health. For instance, we're embarrassed that we haven't saved enough, but we have no real idea how much our friends have saved either (and we won't ask them — see point 7).

2. Because no one teaches us how to manage money.

At school we're taught to mind our hygiene and brush our teeth, and we're taught about the menstrual cycle, how to cross the street, and how to deal with online bullying. What we're not taught is practical, applied economics — how to budget correctly, the difference between being salaried and self-employed, how to read a bank statement. No one taught us, and yet we're afraid to ask "stupid" questions. But if we never ask them, we'll never get the knowledge we actually need.

3. Because Jews carry an especially complicated legacy around money.

Whether it's the European history in which antisemitic laws barred Jews from owning land and pushed them into finance, or the persecutions in various parts of the world that left many families with stories of people whose lives were saved thanks to money, I believe these collective traumas have left Jews especially "wired strangely" when it comes to talking openly about money. The result is that many of us don't actually know what we think about money: Is it something dirty? Is it the most important thing in the world? It's hard to talk to others about a subject this sensitive when we don't even know what will come out of our own mouths.

4. Because we're afraid of fighting with our partners.

Which makes a lot of sense, because they don't know how to talk about money either. They're anxious, confused, and ashamed too. And because of all that, experience tells us that a conversation about money is likely to turn into an especially bitter fight. Money fights are among the toughest couples face, and not by chance: study after study and survey after survey find that fighting about money predicts separation and divorce.

5. Because not having money triggers existential anxiety (more than sex does).

Money isn't just in our heads. At the end of the day, we need a certain amount of it just to live. Unlike sex, money isn't something we can go without, or hide the lack of from others for very long.

Why Is It So Hard for Us to Talk About Money? - illustration

6. Because financial privilege fills us with guilt.

There really is such a thing as rich people's problems — we simply don't take them seriously. But it's worth knowing that privileged couples are often no less complicated than couples without money, and sometimes even more so.

7. Because we were taught it's rude to ask others about money.

Most of us would rather talk to friends about death, about sex, and here in Israel, even about politics — anything but money. From a young age we were taught, often in subtle ways we can't even recall, not to reveal our own financial details and not to embarrass others by asking about theirs.

8. Because as adults, for the first time, we're free to handle our money however we want — and we're not willing to let that freedom be compromised.

When we were kids, our parents controlled us through money. As adults, financial independence represents our independence, period. That's why it scares us to reveal details that might let other people judge us or try to influence our choices. And we definitely don't have the patience for eye-rolls, or for being told we got played (a very real risk here in Israel).

9. Because we believe there's no need to talk about it.

The way we relate to money feels, to us, like the only way. Or alternatively: there's nothing to talk about, we just need to earn more money. But let's think about this for a second: if a man has an erection problem, I can understand why he'd go to a doctor and ask for Cialis. But if the desire between him and his wife has simply faded, does it still make sense to go to a doctor? In the same way, if we have trouble choosing a pension fund, we go to a financial advisor — but will that advisor help you talk to your partner about money in a way that doesn't turn into a fight?

10. Because we think it's shameful to mismanage money.

And that's the biggest paradox of all: we'll never learn to manage money well if we don't ask, but we can't ask if we're afraid to talk about it. Which reminds me of a joke my father loved:

A Bedouin and his son are walking through the desert. The son asks: "Father, why is the desert hot during the day but cold at night?"

"Wallah," the father says, "I don't know."

After another day of walking, the son asks: "Father, how does an oasis form?" His father thinks for a moment and says: "I swear, my son, I don't know."

After yet another day of walking, the son asks: "Father, why are sunsets prettier in autumn?" And the father answers, "I don't know."

Finally the son tries to understand: "Father, does it annoy you that I ask so many questions?" "No, my son," says the father, "heaven forbid. If you don't ask, how will you ever know?"


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page