"And If Everyone Jumped Off the Roof": Why Smart People Got Close to Jeffrey Epstein
Updated: Oct 22
How cognitive biases, herd effect and our need to belong led genuinely smart people to ignore so many moral red flags — and what that can teach us about our own blind spots.
When I was a kid, the standard way to talk to children about the dangers of peer pressure was to ask them, "And if everyone jumped off the roof, would you jump too?" The question was supposed to be rhetorical, meant to spark an insight into the limits of the idea that it's okay to do something wrong just because everyone else is doing it.
Lately, though, it doesn't seem so rhetorical. A fresh release of the Epstein files confronts us with the fact that a lot of smart, sophisticated, experienced people were seriously considering jumping off that metaphorical roof, just because others had jumped before them. And as it turns out, they did.
For me personally, the relationship that came to light between Dr. Peter Attia, the longevity guru, and that nauseating criminal, was the most triggering. To each their own idols, but I'm used to hearing Attia, sometimes for hours a week, talk in terms of "health," "reason," "long-term thinking," "common sense," and so on — so it was especially jarring to realize he'd managed not to apply a single one of those concepts to decisions and actions that could have a critical effect on the longevity of his own career.
Sure enough, within days of the media catching on to the friendship between the charismatic doctor and the New York villain — and even though there's currently no suspicion that Attia was involved in any criminal activity himself — he lost some of his key status symbols and published a long apology that reeked, unpleasantly, of guilt.
So how can this be? How is it that people with so many resources — Bill Gates, the Clintons, Nobel laureates, true movers of the world — manage to ignore red flags, or simply don't feel a wave of nausea when they come into contact with someone as rotten as Jeffrey Epstein? It clearly isn't a matter of intelligence. What these cases seem to reveal are blind spots in our field of vision — blind spots that Epstein himself identified, and knew exactly how to exploit.
"Me too" in the herd
The halo effect, or "social proof." As human beings we have heuristics — shortcut keys on the computer we call our brain — through which we make all sorts of decisions. In social psychology there are plenty of examples of women, say, judging a man's attractiveness by the attractiveness of the woman he's with, and many of us know that if one child enjoys a food, there's a good chance a sibling will want to eat the same dish too.
These are examples tied to how we decide who's trustworthy. If you meet someone surrounded by famous scientists and presidents, it's only logical that your lazy brain makes the next move: "If Bill Gates and Clinton's Treasury secretary think this guy is fine, then he's probably fine." The result is a feedback loop that reinforces itself. The more people involved in a situation, the more each individual feels that their own name is, personally, at lower risk.
Americans have an expression for it: safety in numbers, and maybe it fits here. It's the sense of security a gazelle feels inside a herd. What are the odds the tiger will pounce on her specifically? What are the odds the media tiger will pounce specifically on Sarah Ferguson, Elon Musk, Richard Branson, Steve Bannon, Steve Tisch, Sergey Brin, Ehud Barak?
This same cognitive bias is also related to the concept of "too big to fail" — the economic theory that certain financial institutions are so large and so interconnected that their collapse would be catastrophic for the broader economy, and will therefore always be cushioned by government intervention meant to avert disaster.
A theory that has largely turned out to be a rationalization. In this case too, the thinking seems to have gone something like: sure, the food at this metaphorical buffet looks suspicious, but if it were actually spoiled, everyone here would be getting food poisoning, not just me — so it can't really be spoiled.

Narcissists compartmentalize more
The other mechanism at work here has to do with an ability that seems to be more common among men — and more common still among ambitious men — to compartmentalize. That is, to mentally create a kind of "silverware drawer," in which things that are actually, substantively connected to one another get stored, seemingly, in separate compartments. When they meet someone who can help advance their goals, they separate the traits that are useful to them — money, connections, intellect (Epstein wasn't stupid) — from that person's psychopathic personality structure and rock-bottom morals.
Even though a more thoughtful look would have led them to realize this is an artificial separation, akin to storing a pair of socks in two different drawers. What makes them think they can separate the right sock from the left? It's probably a form of intellectual arrogance.
People with narcissistic defenses — certainly those among them who've reached a certain level of achievement and the high status that comes with it — tend to believe they occupy a superior moral position that exempts them from catching the moral panic of the masses, whom they sometimes describe as pitchfork-wielding villagers running a witch hunt.
Alongside that, they may also believe they're sophisticated enough to get close to complicated or damaged people without being tainted themselves. And of course, the thinking is usually that they're doing all this for some higher purpose — like advancing science or philanthropy ("I'm here to raise money for my important, life-saving research, and I'm not responsible for what this guy does in his private life").
A seat at the grown-ups' table
Twenty-five years ago in New York, my then-husband and I were trying to raise money for his first film. I remember being introduced to a partner at Goldman Sachs, whose personal fortune was estimated at the time at around a hundred million dollars. He was married, but it was common knowledge that he had a young girlfriend, whose downtown apartment he paid for, and whom he'd bring with him to gallery openings.
I tried to lie to myself about it and sit down with him for dinner, because we wanted the money for the film so badly. At the end of the meal, before we said our goodbyes, he put both hands on my waist and asked how old I was. I told him I was 28. He replied, "You don't look a day over 18."
How is it that people aren't disgusted? Our brains run several systems at once, and apparently when someone offers you a seat at the grown-ups' table, and the chance to feel like one of the Illuminati, the amount of dopamine flooding your brain in that moment drowns out any physiological reaction that might otherwise arise from the moral revulsion you may be feeling.
Not to mention that people were never shown the whole picture all at once. First there was a dinner, then a flight on the private jet, then a conference, and only later a "party." It's fair to assume that by the point some people actually took part in criminal activity, they were already deeply invested in the relationship with Epstein, and it was psychologically that much harder to pull back — once you've flown on his private jet, it gets harder and harder to admit he's a monster.
Beyond that, Epstein's network was also woven so that it offered something specific to whoever the spider wanted to catch. Ten years ago, Peter Attia was only at the start of his career as a media star. Epstein opened up an Ali Baba's cave of social and professional connections in front of him — one only the host knew the password to.
To the Clintons, who live about as cushioned a life as can be imagined, Epstein offered a world with zero friction with reality. The fantasy was custom-fitted to the narcissistic sensitivities of whichever object Epstein wanted to add to his collection.
One of the most seductive things, probably, at any level of power, is the feeling that you're part of an exclusive group of people who really know what's going on, while the world of all the "regular people" carries on beyond the wall, moving through it in naivety and stupidity. When someone feeds your starving ego exactly the food it craves most, you're probably a lot less bothered by the question of whether he washed his hands.
And of course there's also the normalization effect — pretty much our word of the year here in Israel too. The human brain adapts to anything. After a few days at an estate where your every wish is granted as if by a genie, while you're having wonderful conversations with dazzling, influential, impressive people, the strange phenomena connected to your host start fading into the background.
You can think of it in terms of how a scientific paradigm forms. As long as one broad framework dominates the field, the scientists operating within it assume that anomalies the paradigm can't explain don't actually undermine its core assumptions ("all this talk about trafficking women is just malicious rumor").
Only once the anomalies pile up does a crisis emerge that leads to a paradigm shift and the replacement of the old worldview ("I regret ever having known him"). Bottom line: when we really want something to be true — and specifically when someone offers us one of the most tempting things for human beings since the dawn of humanity, a shortcut to power and knowledge — our brains mobilize to blur out any piece of information that might remind us we're in the room with a predator.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




