Champagne Problems? What Happens to the Psyche When You Don't Have to Earn a Living?
We tend to assume that freedom from financial worry is the key to a better life. But the need to work, to make an effort, and to be needed by others is also one of the mechanisms through which we build a sense of self-worth.
Oren, thirty, comes to see me for family counseling along with his very wealthy parents. He's good-looking, quick-witted, and his intelligence is obvious within the first few minutes of conversation. I can't help thinking he'd make a wonderful partner for whoever ends up with him — I even have a few candidates in mind. And yet, when he talks about himself, it's hard to recognize who he's describing.
What emerges from what he says is that he sees himself as weak, spoiled, and foolish. He works in the family business, his parents trust him, he carries a great deal of responsibility, and the business is, on the whole, doing well. But no matter what happens, Oren only seems to feel worse about himself. “I know I'm smart,” he tells me, “but I don't feel like I'm worth anything.” His parents don't understand it: they gave him everything they never had, and yet, of all their friends' children, Oren seems to be the most lost.
When There's No Sense of Worth
David and Romi spend a good part of their couples therapy sessions discussing their daughter. They, too, are an extremely wealthy couple, and they're frustrated that their daughter insists on attending a demanding pre-military prep program, followed by a punishing career-track military service.
I ask questions, and their answers reveal a girl who is determined, level-headed, and functioning wonderfully — there's no sign of psychological distress. That's precisely what confuses her parents. “It's lovely that she wants to contribute,” Romi says, “but the whole world is open to her. She could study medicine, start a business, travel — why waste years on something so hard and so unnecessary?”
Michael and Racheli are a young, well-off couple who are set to become very wealthy in the future. Although they agree on a great many things, one dispute keeps resurfacing between them, about their five-year-old son. Racheli is an actress whose career never quite took off, and she signs the boy up for every acting class she can find, constantly telling him about “his talent.”
When Michael tries to point out that it's too early, or that acting isn't really a profession, or that the boy should be exposed to other things, Racheli takes offense and pushes back. Her own parents mocked her dream of being an actress, and because of them, she says, she never fully realized it. “Our son, thank God, doesn't have the problem I had — he doesn't need to worry about earning a living, so there's no reason he shouldn't give it everything he's got.”
These three cases are very different from one another, but they all touch on the same point: what happens to a child's sense of self-worth when the need to earn a living is taken away. One of the most basic components of mental health is the feeling that we bring value to others. Psychologists sometimes call this a “sense of competence.”

The Market's Reality Check
Most people acquire this feeling almost as a byproduct of needing to earn a living, and payment is the most widely accepted social way of expressing appreciation. Someone pays us, which means someone believes what we do is worth something. It's a daily, almost automatic feedback mechanism that most of us benefit from without ever thinking about it.
There is, of course, a minority of people who live with such a profound sense of calling or mission that it supplies meaning on its own, almost regardless of outside feedback. David and Romi's daughter, for instance, found — on her own, without her parents' help — a framework that demands something real of her, and through it she is building the sense of competence that is harder for her to come by the way it comes to her peers, since she doesn't need to earn her allowance or her trip to Berlin.
The problem is that, statistically, the odds of a child finding such an outlet on their own are low — and Oren, for all his talent, genuinely never did. Here lies the mistake many wealthy parents make: they assume that if they simply give their children enough freedom and resources, the children will flourish.
But the more complicated truth is that freedom is a necessary condition for happiness only in the context of a sense of relevance. Those with a genuine calling — to be researchers, artists, or activists, say — will likely be overjoyed by the freedom and the financial backing their parents give them, precisely because that's what allows them to fully realize their purpose. But most of us aren't like that, and we don't have a prior sense of calling. In most cases, freedom becomes a burden: nothing pushes you forward, nothing proves anything, nothing says, ‘you matter.’
I'm not saying it's preferable to grow up in poverty, or that earning a living from work is essential to mental health. Rather, children in ordinary families, where making a living is a necessity, get their sense of competence almost for free, as a byproduct of reality. Wealthy children, by contrast, don't receive this gift naturally, which means their parents need to create it for them deliberately.
And this is exactly where Racheli, despite her good intentions, goes wrong: in their case, money doesn't just make earning a living unnecessary — it also removes the reality check that the free market usually provides. A situation in which her son actually had to make a living from acting would, in this sense, serve him better, because he'd get some kind of feedback on the value he brings.
We Have a Place in the World
Many of us assume that if we had enough money, we'd never work another day in our lives. It's such a common fantasy that almost no one ever puts it to the test. But the reality is that people who keep working or contributing even when they have no financial need to do so tend to preserve their mental sharpness, social engagement, and sense of meaning far better than those who retire completely and suddenly find themselves with nothing that demands anything of them.
We are social animals. Our need to feel we belong to a group is one of our most basic needs. Work and contributing to a community give us daily proof that we're needed by the group, which strengthens our sense of security. When you remove the need for that proof, you also remove the mechanism through which we keep confirming, again and again, that we have a place in the world.
What we see in the examples of these wealthy families highlights another difficulty we all struggle with: the crisis of convenience. It has become so easy and so comfortable to be entertained at any given moment that our capacity to stick with any one thing simply erodes, and we suffer from a great many attention and concentration problems. And the easier and more convenient it becomes to obtain food and to get from place to place without any physical effort, the sicker we become.
The recurring pattern is the same: everything human needs resistance in order to flourish. A muscle needs resistance, but so does the psyche — which is why unlimited freedom, freedom that carries no demand and no need to make an effort, is fundamentally problematic. Even when it arrives wrapped in love and the best of intentions.
The practical question facing wealthy parents is how to create that same resistance deliberately, once economic reality no longer imposes it on its own. There are all sorts of ways to do this, but the underlying principle is the same: expose the child to a variety of ways of bringing value, and to a variety of possible callings. Perhaps also observe and see which conditions truly make the child flourish — the ones in which he doesn't have to do anything, and whatever he does won't move the family needle one way or the other; or the ones in which he provides real benefit, connects to a meaningful purpose, and gets feedback from the world around him. Because money can buy a child almost everything — except the feeling that he, and not someone else, built the life he's living.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




