Why I Married My Father, and Is Netflix the Same as Meditation? Answers to Your Questions
Updated: Oct 22
Every week I receive questions on all sorts of topics. You're especially curious about sleep, depression, and relationships, and I'm happy to take the opportunity to answer a few of your puzzlers. A note to reader D., who is arguing with her mother-in-law
Dear Amalia, why do you write so much about sleep? Besides, I drink coffee and it doesn't bother my sleep at all. S.
Hello S.,
I assume you haven't turned 40 yet, and so haven't yet become intimately acquainted with the fact that sleep is one of the three foundations of our physical health, alongside nutrition and movement. It may even come first, in the sense that sleep is the base on which the pillar of nutrition and the pillar of movement stand.
Sadly (and it really does sadden me), caffeine damages this foundation in various ways. Many people have trouble falling asleep when there's caffeine in their blood. You don't belong to that group. For now. In addition, there are those who manage to fall asleep with caffeine in their blood but struggle to stay asleep because of it, and find themselves waking up often. Happily, that isn't you either.
But my dear S., the fact that you don't belong to either of these crowded groups doesn't mean caffeine isn't harming your sleep. The third way caffeine harms sleep is by reducing the amount of deep, dreamless sleep, a stage that is vital for restoring our brains during the night's rest.
So, S., even if you fall asleep easily, if you drink coffee late in the day there's a good chance you don't wake up as refreshed as you would if you stopped drinking caffeine after noon, or 2:00 p.m. at the very latest.
Why do I name such an early hour? Not (only) because I'm climbing the hill of middle age and succumbing to health hysteria, but because the half-life of caffeine is five to six hours. That means that about five or six hours after I've had a whole cup of coffee, I still have half a cup of coffee in my body. Which means that ten to twelve hours after my last coffee, I still have a quarter of a cup in my system. And not just me, but you too.
Warmly,
Amalia
A nightcap helps me sleep, but when I drink alcohol before bed I have bizarre dreams in the morning. Why? A., loyal reader
Dear A.,
A drink before bed may lower the anxiety that makes it hard for you and me to sleep, but it doesn't really help us sleep. Its effect on us is closer to being hit over the head with a club than to sleep. We're certainly not moving, but that's not exactly what our brains need in order to clear out and renew themselves.
In addition, alcohol can activate our sympathetic nervous system during sleep, the system that operates under stress, which is not something that helps sleep, as you can imagine. And the third negative effect, and here we get to your dreams, is that alcohol blocks our natural dream sleep and keeps it from taking place during the hours when it's supposed to.
The thing is, the brain has a kind of hunger for dream sleep, and it's rather petty about it. So as soon as the alcohol starts clearing from the blood, the brain tries to "make up" as much dream sleep as it can. But that effort happens in the last hours of our sleep, right before waking. The hastily grabbed dream sleep can't match proper dream sleep, and the result is that after an evening of drinking, we often experience wild dreams.
I heard that omega-3 is good against depression. Is that true? N.
Hi N., if we set aside for a moment the effect of omega-3 on the fish's mood, there are certainly many (!) new, serious, and very interesting studies raising the possibility that consuming large amounts of omega-3 reduces symptoms of depression and allows people who take antidepressants to lower their dosage.
The mechanism isn't fully understood yet. It may be that omega-3 fatty acids can cross the blood-brain barrier and affect, inside the brain, molecules involved in our emotional state. It may also be that omega-3 has an anti-inflammatory effect that eases depression. Either way, I remind you that I'm not a doctor, but really just a woman who knows English well and whose fridge holds equal amounts of food and jars, and before you make a decision you should check the matter with your doctor.
As far as I'm concerned, watching Netflix is like meditation. Honestly, that's true, isn't it? After all, the whole point is to stop the churning stream of thoughts. G.
Hmmmm... I don't think so. I'm not a Buddhist and not an expert in meditation, so I can only share how I see it: our suffering comes from the fact that our minds generate thoughts and images that frighten us terribly, since their main business is chasing after things we want, trying to get rid of things we don't want, and grieving over what we lack. We can picture ourselves sitting in a movie theater watching a marathon of short horror films. The moment one ends, a new one is screened.
We want to stop the suffering this viewing causes us. And we have (at least) two solutions. The one you're talking about is essentially to stay in the theater but avert your eyes from the film, take out your phone, and watch something other than the main horror feature. This solution has many advantages. To a large extent it's the basis of self-hypnosis. It relies on the ability to split our attention and, instead of being with what's happening in front of us, to find somewhere else to direct it. Sometimes this is called dissociation, and depending on the context, it's an important ability.
But meditation offers a different way to stop being afraid of the film, and in this metaphor it goes like this: feel the worn-out seat, feel the sticky floor under our shoes, and in effect watch ourselves watching the movie. If we succeed, the experience becomes less like watching a horror film in a dark, deserted theater and more like watching a screen set up on a patch of lawn on an afternoon, while we sit on a blanket smelling the grass.
That is, meditation offers us a way to reduce our suffering not by disconnecting from one screen and getting hooked on another that shows the content we prefer, but by waking up to the fact (the possibility?) that the movie on the screen is what frightens us, and that we can turn on the lights in the theater and find rest in the present and in the universe. And if you want a more comprehensible text on the subject than this one, see the recommendations below.
Amaliaaaaah, like in the awful clichés, after ten years of marriage I discovered that I married someone who is the spitting image of my father. How does this actually happen? Does the unconscious choose someone who triggers all our problematic parts? T.
Dear Tttttt.,
According to Emotion-Focused Therapy, from the school of the South African-Canadian psychologist Les Greenberg, there's no need to invoke invisible structures to explain the fact that you married your father.
According to this approach, people fall in love with each other for all kinds of reasons, perfectly arbitrary and ordinary ones. They fall in love because of a pleasant scent, or because they went through an intense experience together, or because no one else was around.
So let's say you nevertheless find yourself stuck in a loop with a person who withdraws into himself and sulks for days, exactly as your father did when he was offended. The explanation probably lies in the fact that as a girl you developed a mechanism that helped you cope with the emotional pain your father's defenses caused you, and that mechanism helped you obtain some kind of emotional response from your father.
The problem, probably, is that this mechanism doesn't work well in adulthood. In fact, with your husband, it widens the gap between you. Say that when your father withdrew, you would make a scene until he broke and climbed down from the tree. If this dynamic repeated enough times, it taught you that bringing your pain in a vulnerable, straightforward way doesn't work, and that you'd better throw a tantrum if you want anyone around here to pay attention to you.
But when you act like an enraged teenager toward your partner, it only makes him dig deeper into his burrow. You get tangled up at this point because what you're probably supposed to do is dare to be more vulnerable with him, to show your pain instead of raging. But as a result of your personal history, that's exactly what you're most afraid of doing when the man you love and need retreats into his shell.
Bottom line: you didn't fall in love with your husband because he's like your father, but you two get stuck at the points where he behaves like your father, because those are the points that trigger you most and with which it's hardest for you to cope without getting defensive.
I give my kid 20 shekels for every book he reads, and my mother-in-law turns up her nose. Who's right? D.
Your mother-in-law.

Recommendations
Book: Full Openness and Doubt: Conversations on Psychotherapy and Religion
"Full Openness and Doubt" (Petichut Mele'a Vesafek) is the new and highly recommended book by Esther Peled, based on recent lectures by the author, therapist, and wonderful Buddhism teacher (I don't know whether she would agree with that description, of course).
The book has two central themes: that our fear of religion and of becoming religious makes us treat meditation as a technique, and that belief in wholeness and harmony is not the solution but the root of the problem. But never mind all that; Peled's writing is the real thing, of course. I read the book in two evenings, laughing out loud and demolishing a bag of gummy candies.
Series: WeCrashed
Some people were chilled by just a few minutes of this series. But I think it simply reminds them of characters from their own lives. In any case, I haven't seen such a deep study of narcissism on television in years, and the series is simply wonderfully made. Apple TV.
Family: The Blindfold Tasting Game
Another game that all family members can play on equal footing, except perhaps the fussy eaters among them, who might be better off going for a long walk with the dog. In the game, each family member in turn moves away so they can't hear what's going on. The remaining family members prepare a plate for them with an assortment of tastes of foods and sauces, the kind you don't normally eat on their own like that.
Once the plate is ready, you cover the absent player's eyes (an airplane sleep mask does the job), lead them (carefully) to the dining table, and burst out laughing while they try to work out what the bizarre thing they're tasting is (butter).
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




