top of page

They've Already Succeeded. The Podcasts Convince Them It's Not Enough

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 30
6 min read

Entrepreneurs, executives, and tech workers listen to billionaires to learn how to succeed even more. But when they keep comparing themselves to a tiny, exceptional minority, even a thriving career can start to look like failure.

In recent years I've been seeing more and more of a new kind of despair. It isn't the despair of young people who can't understand how they'll ever afford an apartment, or of parents who don't know how to guide their kids through a changing world. It's the despair of the entrepreneur whose startup is doing relatively well, who has raised money again and again, who keeps landing bigger clients — or of the tech employee who earns a very good salary and is doing just fine climbing the ladder at the giant tech company where he works.

To the rest of us, they might look like successful people. But among themselves, they're frustrated. They feel stuck, unaware that one of the things they're doing to get unstuck is exactly what might be weakening them, or even paralyzing them.

The seemingly innocent activity I'm talking about is listening to technology podcasts, where entrepreneurs, investors, or other businesspeople who've had legendary success are interviewed and share their worldview with the host — who might be one of them too — and with the listeners. The list of podcasts is long, and includes The All-In Podcast, Lenny's Podcast, Acquired, The Tim Ferriss Show, and many more.

Some episodes of these podcasts have more than a million listens, and many others get hundreds of thousands. I don't have data on this, but I do have a hypothesis: the more young men listen to these podcasts, the more likely they are to start thinking that their real achievements are just a promising first draft of the work they're supposed to write, and that the window to write it is closing — which, naturally, sends them into a panic.

Career Dysmorphia

We're social animals, and we determine our self-worth by comparing ourselves to the people around us. The trouble is that this mechanism evolved in a prehistoric world, where the people around us were members of our own tribe, or at most a neighboring tribe living in conditions similar to ours. In today's world, by contrast, we can end up populating our reference group with people who represent 0.01 percent of the world's population.

If, instead of comparing ourselves to the people we grew up with in our neighborhood or went to school with, we start comparing ourselves to the people behind the biggest exits, to serial entrepreneurs or investors with extraordinary business instincts, we can end up dismissing our own achievements — even if we earn a $350,000 salary, or have grown the business we once dreamed up in our living room into $15 million a year in revenue.

Suddenly those numbers no longer look like success to us. Quite the opposite — we feel stuck. You could maybe think of this as ‘scale dysmorphia’: dissatisfaction with our shape — in this case, our career — that comes from a distorted scale.

This phenomenon reminds me of the despair I increasingly see among healthy women who are well versed in wellness principles, and yet experience their own health routine as lacking, because they compare themselves to wellness influencers or movie stars — people for whom wellness isn't just a side interest as it is for them, but a full-time occupation, and about whom, moreover, there's no way to know whether the information they share is even reliable.

In both cases, the fish — meaning the audience — gets hooked by the content creator using the same bait: the illusion of closeness to critical information. In both cases, we're talking about fetishistic content, in the sense that it hides or blurs the fact that the achievement being flaunted — physical or financial — also rests on a considerable amount of luck, or on disavowed privilege, whether socioeconomic or genetic.

Instead, success is presented as the result of cracking a complex intellectual or physical puzzle, with the implicit promise that the listener is just one step away from the solution. Beyond simply not being true, consuming this kind of content carries other costs. Just as a woman might start to believe she isn't drinking enough water, an entrepreneur might start to believe that normal, ordinary human friction inside his company is proof of some failure of his leadership.

They've Already Succeeded. The Podcasts Convince Them It's Not Enough - illustration

Giants Talking to Dwarves

It's hard to spot this problem, because the technology podcasts that top the listening charts aren't necessarily low quality. They're well produced, well edited — and yet toxic all the same. Like a yogurt cup with a gentle sweetness that turns out to contain nine teaspoons of sugar, the toxicity of these podcasts is hidden inside their moralizing approach to optimization. They grow and thrive to the extent that they convince listeners that even impressive achievements, if you feel any contentment about them, mean you're being lazy at best.

Instagram and TikTok sell women an illusion of aesthetic perfection, and technology podcasts sell men an illusion of professional optimization. Both ecosystems take talented, disciplined, highly capable people and trap them in an endless loop of consumption.

There's a notable difference between how men consume hyper-optimization media and how women consume it, and that difference has to do with how aware each group is of the game being played. The large majority of women who are conscious about their health already know that the beauty, wellness, and anti-aging industries are trying to exploit their purchasing power, and that the algorithm thrives on its ability to make them feel insecure. The male listener consuming business and technology content is still fairly naive about how he's being played.

When a moderately successful entrepreneur, by global standards, listens to a podcast where billionaires sit around and ‘talk,’ he still doesn't understand that he is the product. He feels invited. He believes he's been granted rare, authentic access to join a private conversation between giants — one taking place in a room he hasn't physically reached yet, but that he feels he's already very close to.

Unlike the Instagram consumer, he's more naive about the engineering behind the content he consumes. Though, in fairness to the people making this content, it's possible that they, too, aren't operating out of pure cynicism, but are simply playing their role in this system, without realizing that even as they pull the listener in with the promise of insider knowledge, they're also preserving the vast, mysterious distance between the ‘giant’ who talks and the ‘dwarf’ who listens.

A Recipe Without Luck

The advice given on these shows is presented as practical science, like a recipe anyone can follow at home and come out with more or less the same apple cake. In most cases, they don't know, aren't interested, or aren't able to talk about the single most decisive variable in any giant venture: luck. That's natural, of course, and you don't have to be malicious to fall into this particular blind spot.

An accurate assessment of the role randomness plays in our successes runs against human nature — and perhaps runs especially against the nature of highly ambitious, highly intelligent people who've succeeded at the very highest levels. And yet, when a star entrepreneur attributes his enormous exit to this or that factor, one he tries to conceptualize or even brand, a large part of that explanation is classic after-the-fact rationalization.

Hindsight tends to downplay the tailwind of macroeconomic processes that helped him break records, of regulatory loopholes that happened to stay open at exactly the right time and exactly for his company, of his social capital, or of the fact that his startup sold right before the AI revolution — when, had it sold a moment later, it might have fetched a tenth of the price.

Obviously, at the level of language, both the host and the guest on these podcasts know how to formally acknowledge the importance of luck. But rarely will they acknowledge that without luck as a load-bearing pillar, the whole structure would have collapsed. Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman wrote about this long ago, and as I said, it's a very human thing. They're psychologically wired to resist acknowledging luck for all sorts of understandable reasons, one of which, at least, is that acknowledging luck might diminish the genius attributed to them.

The trap for the audience — made up of smart, ambitious, moderately successful entrepreneurs — is taking the content literally. At the gym, on the commute, or on flights, successful men consume huge quantities of this content searching for the secret ingredient they're missing, without realizing that the participants themselves often admit that the advice probably can't be replicated, because the conditions under which it worked no longer exist. The content manages to keep them captivated, in a constant feeling that they're just one more episode away from the key that will unlock the door to their own big breakthrough.

More than 20 years ago, a successful art dealer told me that ‘all rich people made their money by accident, but they forgot that.’ Maybe because women recognized the performative nature of the beauty industry and the ‘wellness’ empire long before men did, it's easier for them to see that, when it comes to financial and business success, quite a few men are running a game — on others, and on themselves too.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page