Why Do We Need a Stage So Badly?
Updated: Oct 22
The need to express ourselves and feel understood isn't narcissistic caprice — it's an ancient survival mechanism that social media has turned into a psychological trap
Not long ago, a relatively new patient sat down on the couch, smiled, and said, "So, I just talk about myself? That's actually kind of nice." The natural, endearing way he said it got me thinking that maybe we're biologically built to talk about ourselves far more than we actually get to.
The human groups our biological prototype lived in usually numbered fewer than a hundred people, operating in small bands for the tribe's survival. In that way of life — as you can also see in documentaries about tribes that, up through the 1960s, still managed to stay cut off from the outside world — people talked. A lot.
If you think about it, what did they even have to talk about? None of them had seen anything the others hadn't — no television, no trips abroad, no encounters with people from elsewhere — so it's fair to assume that, at bottom, human beings talked a great deal about themselves.
Alongside this anecdote, I've noticed that over the past two and a half difficult years, more and more of my patients have been turning to creative outlets simply to get through it — a phenomenon all of humanity took part in during Covid as well. It's possible these two observations are connected. We tend to think of creative — that is, artistic — self-expression, like writing, painting, or composing, as a modern phenomenon that floats somewhere above ordinary life.
At the same time, we often think of psychotherapy as a process built from a series of complex clinical interventions. But what if the psychological forces driving both of these — artistic expression and psychotherapy — are really echoing the same instinctive need that serves our survival? I'm talking about the need to express ourselves and to feel understood.
Freedom of Expression
Our basic human needs aren't only ice cream that costs less than a hundred shekels a kilo, a school where the teachers actually show up, medical care with a waitlist, and a state that protects us. We also need to express ourselves, to understand and feel understood, and to contribute to the group. Our earliest mothers lived in small nomadic bands, for whom survival was a collective effort. Social cohesion wasn't — and biologically, still isn't — a luxury. It was the ultimate life-insurance policy.
Conversation, the mutual act of expressing oneself, the ability and willingness to understand, the boldness and capacity to speak up — these were among the ways our foremothers secured that cohesion. Even though in any human group it's obvious that some people can draw the deer better than others, at the root of human society, the artist and the audience weren't separated the way they are in ours.
Like a high-school art elective, one person paints on the cave wall, another makes the drum, a third checks where the acoustics are best in the cave, a fourth knows how to tell a story, and so on. The production, in the end, is a group effort, and everyone in it gets to express themselves creatively.
If you think about it, even a simple act of self-expression carries enormous weight — and it's not for nothing that project-based learning remains one of the most impressive educational models around. When we express ourselves in front of an audience, we're doing three things at once: conveying complex ideas, building a shared cultural identity, and signaling our worth to others along multiple dimensions — talented, intelligent, committed, and so on.
In return, when we express something and the group understands the message, accepts it, and even appreciates it, that's a huge boost to our sense of security. We feel useful, and therefore we feel we belong. That validation strengthens social bonds and generates trust — the very ground our survival as a group stands on. So the urge to express ourselves and be understood isn't some random whim of narcissists or impractical dreamers; it's a mechanism with a great deal of evolutionary logic behind it, whose job is to secure our place in the group.

On History's Stage
This primary need for an experience in which we both express ourselves and feel understood is, in my view, the reason psychotherapy so often works — above and beyond whatever specific technique a given therapist uses. Therapists may work from different approaches, whether cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) or psychodynamic techniques, but in the end, many of them report that the strongest predictor of a treatment's success is the trust and collaboration built between therapist and patient.
Beyond the ways therapists simulate a parental environment and let patients project onto them the lessons they carried out of their childhood homes, in order to set aside whatever excess baggage those lessons left behind, the couch is also a miniature stage: a place where patients "take the stage" (sitting down) and express themselves before an audience of one — an audience standing in for an early human environment that is as safe and supportive as possible.
If we truly accept the idea that self-expression, actively contributing to a group, and the sense of being understood that comes from both are basic needs, we can also understand how dangerous the passive consumption of online content is to the human psyche. Whether we're scrolling social media, binge-watching a favorite show, or listening to a podcast, we're the ones doing all the active work of understanding: we're the ones who get the plot, the joke, the creator's life. The communication runs in one direction only.
One-Way Communication
Seen this way, it's easier to understand why scrolling is linked to rising anxiety, depression, and loneliness. We feel we have no agency, that we're not contributing anything, while we watch other people supposedly succeeding at meeting their own need for self-expression. Of course their display is carefully curated, which only makes us feel worse.
The result of this so-called communication is the exact opposite of what genuine two-way communication produces. It's the precise inverse of what we get in therapy, where we express ourselves and are understood, and of what we get when we express ourselves artistically, bringing our own insights and feelings to center stage and being understood by an audience.
The exhaust fumes of this difficult experience come out, in my view, as the aggressive, hostile comments we see online (see the comments under this very column, presumably). Even take the piece you're reading right now as an example: there's no real conversation happening here. I can't validate you, and you don't get to express yourselves back to me, right now, face to face.
If you don't have other places where you express yourself and get attention and understanding, that can build up into a reservoir of helplessness and resentment. When someone in that state finally finds an anonymous channel to express themselves in — the comments section — the pent-up frustration comes out as raw, aggressive expression.
The hostility gets aimed at whoever symbolizes a person who managed to meet that need — the speaker, the writer, the singer, the actor — because they represent the very thing denied to the person commenting: a voice that's valued. If we were still in the caves, someone would have already reined in that kind of aggression, and it would have carried social consequences. It might also have been softened by attention: it would have been clear that whoever is attacking also needs to hold the metaphorical microphone for a moment.
We're surrounded by unprecedented platforms for connection, yet as long as we stay passive, we're liable to feel deeply alienated. The need to create, to contribute, and to be understood is critical, and we silence it in an enormous number of ways, including the lure of effortless, passive consumption. But that state is a sick one. Healing it requires that we find a way — through painting, through emotional therapy, through relationships, through writing, or even through learning circus arts — to actively express our own complexity, to contribute our unique point of view, and to cultivate social circles or intimate connections in which we feel truly understood.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




