top of page

Which Comes First, Emotion or Reason? Only the Right Answer Leads to Successful Therapy

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 27, 2021
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The chicken-and-egg question of the therapy world is whether we first react emotionally to an event or first interpret it. Emotion-focused schools hold that emotional responses are faster than intellectual interpretation

What comes first, the emotion or the interpretation? This question is therapy's version of the chicken and the egg. Respectable schools of therapy, such as cognitive behavioral therapy, hold that interpretation creates emotion. Emotion-focused schools, on the other hand, are certain that emotional responses are far faster than interpretation, so there is no question that emotion determines interpretation. The latter are, of course, right (go ahead, light the torches), but why does it matter?

After all, many patients can't say exactly which approach their therapist works in. CBT or EFT, who cares which three letters are printed on the framed certificate at the clinic entrance? You could say this not-knowing is fine, because one of the recurring findings in psychotherapy outcome research is that the quality of the relationship between therapist and patient is the single most significant predictor of whether treatment succeeds.

And yet the differences between emotion-focused approaches and approaches like cognitive behavioral therapy are not just a theoretical game; they carry enormous clinical significance. If you have a leak at home, the question of whether the right move is to seal the roof or to open up the pipes and reseal them is no game. The answer determines whether next winter you'll again be walking around the house among pots with towels in them.

Let's look for a moment at the fundamental differences between the two worldviews, to understand why this question is decisive. The CBT worldview sometimes relies on something called the "ABCD model" (in the Hebrew, "Apar't"). The more I learn about the brain, the more this model puts me off, and not only because its Hebrew name sounds like an organization that campaigns against abortion. The acronym stands for the four components of our emotional experience of the world, supposedly in the order in which it is built: event, interpretation, emotion, response.

What is an event? An event is a moment in which our senses encounter new information. An event in a relationship could be, for example, the moment we walk into the house and feel a pang of disappointment when we see our partner, who doesn't lift his head to look at us. The sense at work here, in other words, is sight. Interpretation is the explanation we give to the information that has reached our senses. While sensory information comes from outside and is therefore objective, interpretation takes place inside the brain and is therefore a cognitive, subjective process. Our interpretation of the fact that our partner is busy on his phone might be, for example: "It means nothing to him that I came home." But it might also be: "He must be wrapping up some urgent matter at work."

According to this model, interpretation is critical because it determines which emotion develops next. If I came home and found my husband deep in his phone and I interpret that as a sign that he doesn't care about me, a negative emotion such as sadness or anger will most likely develop in my heart. But if, faced with the same trigger, I conclude that something at work is bothering him so much that he can't make himself available to me when I walk in, the emotions I can expect to feel are entirely different, say, worry or compassion.

Which Comes First, Emotion or Reason? Only the Right Answer Leads to Successful Therapy - illustration

In the final stage of the model, my emotion determines how I respond to the heart of the event. If my interpretation of the situation made me feel angry or sad, I might respond one way, and if I'm worried about him or feel compassion for him, I might respond in an entirely different way. My response will of course become an event from his point of view, which sets off a cycle of interpretation, emotion and response for him, and it takes only one of us misinterpreting for us to land in a negative loop.

So if I were a therapist working with a model like this one, the area on which I would focus my interventions is interpretation. Assuming we have no control over the triggers, the events that set us off, logic dictates that we start influencing a person at the first point that is within his control, which in this case is interpretation.

One technique for intervening at the interpretation stage is called the "Socratic method," which will be familiar to anyone who loved the TV series "The Paper Chase" thirty years ago. It involves questions that encourage the patient to look more critically at his most basic assumptions and beliefs. The therapist guides the patient to identify distortions in his thinking and challenge them, with the goal of correcting the patient's reality testing.

In our example, it may be that the interpretation is shaped by a cognitive tendency toward negative filtering of information. Negative filtering is an extremely common thinking distortion that makes us attend only to the negative information in the situation in front of us and ignore the positive information embedded in it. That is, when I walked in and saw my husband absorbed in his phone, I focused on that one negative detail and ignored the smell of food cooking on the stove, the fact that the kids were bathed, and the fact that usually, when I come home from work, he isn't on his phone but comes over to me and gives me a kiss. Confronting this thinking distortion can change my interpretation, and accordingly influence the emotions that arise in me in the face of the trigger, and of course influence how I respond to my husband.

All of this is so nice that it's a real shame it isn't true. Or rather, it's a little bit true, of course. The thing is that it's more like bringing down a fever with Tylenol than like treating the bacterium that caused the fever with antibiotics. In that sense, this way of working suits short-term triggers, like dealing with your mother at the Rosh Hashanah dinner.

At least, that's how things look according to emotion-focused therapy. In this kind of therapy, we believe that the most critical factor in how we relate to our environment is our immediate emotional responses. Emotions such as anger, sadness, fear and disgust form the foundation of how we exist in the world and connect with people. Our emotions fundamentally shape our perception, our cognition and of course our behavior, and not the other way around. That is, the right road map for changing a person's emotional state is this:

In other words, the "reason" that impresses us so much is really just a kind of PR man working in the service of our emotions, telling us what we want to hear. You can think of emotion and reason as Fidel Castro and Che Guevara. Every revolutionary, it seems, needs an ideologue. Likewise, our emotions give birth to thoughts and interpretations that justify them.

We can corroborate this model through our bodily knowledge. When we're walking down the street and suddenly, from a distance, we hear a motorcycle tearing down the road, we may flinch in panic, thinking it's a siren. The siren arouses fear in us first, and only afterward does interpretation arise. In wartime, a siren will lead to fear, which will lead to the interpretation that missiles have been fired at Israel. That interpretation will lead to behavior: going into the safe room. In the period between wars, a sound that for a moment resembles a siren will lead to fear, and once it passes the interpretation will develop: it was just a motorcycle going by. That will lead to behavior: going online and buying plane tickets.

Now let's apply this to our original example of the woman who walks into the house and feels let down when her husband doesn't acknowledge her. In emotion-focused therapy, the basic assumption would be that if the patient can't respond effectively to the trigger, then something in the situation is probably touching an old emotional wound. The therapist will try to help the woman identify exactly which moment within the interaction is the one where she starts to feel pain, develop awareness of that pain, and begin connecting it to older pains that need attention. The patient might discover that she is very sensitive to her husband's disappearing into his own affairs, perhaps because her parents were never available when she came home from school, and she spent nearly every afternoon alone at home with corn schnitzel and a microwaved pita.

The therapeutic work will focus on healing that childhood wound. The assumption is that as the wound begins to close, and the patient comes to acknowledge its existence, it will hurt less when her husband accidentally steps on the sore spot. And when it does hurt, the pain can be handled differently, because the patient will be able to offer herself the self-compassion she needs on this subject, and even let her husband know that she has a wound there.

There is some overlap in the behavioral component of these two models. Both approaches recognize that the brain learns through experiences and the labeling of them, and in that sense both models aim to create new emotional experiences that will correct earlier learning. And if you ask EFT therapists how it is that the other approach has so many successes, some of us will tell you that, without knowing it, whenever they truly help their clients, they are simply doing emotion-focused therapy; they just don't realize it. In fairness, I should note that if you ask CBT therapists a similar question about emotion-focused therapists, they too will tell you it's a bunch of broken clocks that show the right time twice a day.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page