top of page

When We Can't Bring Ourselves to Touch Our Parent

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Mar 31, 2022
8 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Sometimes we feel disgust toward certain people and try to keep our distance. The reason is that disgust signals to us that those people are emotionally dangerous

"I just can't hug her," Oren tells me (all names have been changed) about his mother, who abandoned him to the systematic psychological abuse of his narcissistic father. "I'm not comfortable saying this, but she disgusts me." Zohar can't help her narcissistic father rub ointment on an insect bite on his back, because he disgusts her. Lihi, too, can't hug her mother, even though her relationship with her borderline mother has stabilized over the past year. "She disgusts me," Lihi says. When I ask her to explain what kind of disgust this is, she replies: "Like finding a moldy cucumber in the vegetable drawer."

What is psychological disgust? Lihi's answer holds the first clue. Formally, in emotion-focused therapy we tend to think of emotions as a set of cognitive and bodily responses that drive a particular action, one that has survival logic. Fear, for example, is characterized by specific physical sensations (the heart beats faster, the mouth goes dry, the stomach turns, blood flows to the arms and legs) and by certain thoughts, and leads the person experiencing it either to confront the trigger that caused the fear or to flee from it. In some cases, where there's no way to get rid of the threatening factor, fear will lead to a freeze response. In each of these cases, the fear disappears only when the threat disappears. In this way, fear contributes to our chances of survival.

Sadness is characterized by a set of typical thoughts and physical responses (such as crying). When we experience real sadness following a loss, our action tendency is to reach out for help or to mourn in a way that lets us let go. Anger leads us to rearrange our boundaries, to remove from them something that was put in without our consent, or to fight to take back something that was taken from us without permission, and so on.

As an aside, I'll explain that I wrote "real sadness" here because in the past I've devoted several columns to expressions of "unreal," that is, defensive, emotions. Let me briefly recall that every emotion has two forms: the first is a connected form, which drives us to action that improves our ability to survive. The second is a defensive form, which momentarily improves our ability to bear the trigger by shielding us from the bodily sensations and burdensome thoughts that are the hallmark of the connected emotion. It does this through an alternative set of the same feelings and thoughts that characterize the emotion in its defensive form.

A common example in couples therapy is a situation in which a woman expresses rage but is in fact sad. The rage, being defensive, fails to move the woman to adaptive action that fits the circumstances and improves the situation. This rage is a stress response that only sets off the other side's alarms even more strongly. Working in emotion-focused therapy will help this patient feel that beneath her rage at her partner lies sadness. Now, once she connects with her primary emotion, the chances rise that she will complete the sadness's action tendency and turn to the other side to ask for help.

Now let's use this explanation of real emotions and their critical contribution to our survival to return to the original question: what is disgust? In light of the markers I've presented so far, it makes sense to answer this question by characterizing the set of thoughts and physical responses that mark disgust, and the action tendency that flows from them. As I understand it, disgust shows up physically as a certain contraction in the face, especially around the mouth and chin. And unlike anger and fear, it is actually accompanied by a certain drop in heart rate.

But for the purposes of our psychological discussion here, I'll focus on the action tendency, because in my view it's the most significant part of how disgust shows up in relationships between people. As we saw in the examples I opened with, the action tendency of disgust is to keep physical distance. It isn't physical distance for the sake of taking cover, of the kind that characterizes fear, but "touching distance," if you will. Keeping a safe distance, the kind that raises the chances that the person who disgusts me won't touch me and will find it hard to get me to touch him. Social distancing, as we've learned to call it.

By the way, in my experience, like other emotions, disgust exists on a spectrum. At its high end it looks like loathing, but at its low end, I think disgust looks like boredom. People can bore us for a host of reasons, and we aren't disgusted by everyone who bores us, but it may be that boredom is the first sign that we feel closeness to a particular person is emotionally dangerous for us. In a sense, in these cases boredom is evidence that we're sealing ourselves off from this person's words, closing ourselves so that he and his inner world won't mix with ours.

It's easy to understand the evolutionary advantage of fear that makes you flee from a tiger, but what is the survival benefit of keeping distance from a person who disgusts us? The answer, in my view, has to do with understanding the importance of disgust in the physical aspects of life.

As Lihi said, the disgust she feels toward her mother reminds her of her recoil from touching rotten food in the fridge. Others compare this recoil from touching a certain person (usually a parent, and we'll shortly try to understand why) to the physical reluctance they feel about touching a dead fish, or to what they imagine they'd feel if asked to touch a corpse. One young man, whose father is an unusual example of a man with borderline personality organization, told me that when his father displays extremely dysregulated emotional behavior, he feels as though his father is handing him a diaper full of poop.

What do rotten food, a dead fish, a corpse and a soiled diaper have in common? They are all things that can poison us if we touch them carelessly. Biologically, there is a theory that the sense of disgust originally evolved in humans as a response to food that could harm us. And indeed, disgust usually arises in us in relation to objects and people in situations that could make us sick, such as bodily excretions, spoiled food, certain animals (lice, worms), certain kinds of filth, and specific signs of infection and disease. Our body tries to avoid unnecessary exposure to toxins, and it does so through a feeling of disgust that gets us to protect ourselves.

When We Can't Bring Ourselves to Touch Our Parent - illustration

Although it's important to expand on the complex meaning of disgust in the sociological, political and economic arenas (the way one group is made to feel disgust toward another, and how that disgust forms the basis of racism and discrimination), we'll stay within the bounds of this discussion of what disgust means in interpersonal relationships. And I think the picture is beginning to clear up: disgust is a subtype of fear. But it isn't fear of a threatening agent that could hurt us physically; it's recoil from people whom excessive closeness is likely to hurt emotionally, making us feel psychologically sick, or more precisely, poisoned.

Let me put it simply: in all the examples I gave above, and they are typical, the people involved were adult children who feel disgust toward their toxic parents. This feeling of disgust steers them to keep their distance from the toxic parent. In none of these cases was the parent someone who had physically harmed the child. Such parents usually arouse the kind of fear that leads to attack, flight or freeze. Psychologically toxic parents more often cause a feeling of disgust. It seems to me that the adult child's physical distance from the parent who disgusts him also makes it possible to block the unwanted emotional approach of the dangerous, boundaryless parent. Perhaps because such people more easily do psychological harm in intimate situations.

A discussion of emotional disgust is also connected to a discussion of creepiness. In this column in the past I tried to sketch the profile of the creep, and in my view "the creep" is a subcategory within the category of "the disgusting." The difference between them lies, I think, in the sense of a secret that the creep carries. The repellent figures in the examples I mentioned earlier have no idea that they provoke repulsion in these people; they don't behave as though hiding a dark secret, and so they don't try to pretend that they're fine. The feeling that someone is creeping us out therefore sharpens, and turns out to be what stirs in us when facing a person who is trying, unsuccessfully, to hide the fact that he is toxic to us.

Understanding what disgust is gets sharper when we ask ourselves which emotion is the opposite of disgust. I think the answer is trust. The possibility that trust, rather than attraction, is the opposite of disgust and rejection has to do, in my view, with the fact that disgust arises in us in response to a sense that we're in danger of being poisoned, while trust arises in response to a sense that closeness to a person is safe. The trustworthy person is the opposite of the disgusting person, just as a high-quality, clean restaurant is the opposite of a repulsive one. We let this person come close to us and are willing to mix his mental contents with ours, just as we're willing to eat at a restaurant whose hygiene meets our standards.

Recommendations

Book: Three Men in a Boat

Jerome K. Jerome's classic was written more than 130 years ago, but it makes me laugh out loud in a way that embarrasses my kids. The passage in which Jerome discovers he has every disease in the medical literature except a syndrome known as "housemaid's knee," and struggles to come to terms with the insult of its having passed him by, brought tears of laughter to my eyes, and so, of course, did the classic passage about fishermen's lies and exaggerations about the size of the fish they caught.

The world of the three friends, who are hopeless at boating and try to vacation by cruising English waterways, fills me with deep calm. It also takes me in my imagination to a safe place where every day looks like the one before, and all the days come with laughter, friendship and quiet. The book has been translated into Hebrew many times.

Nutrition: Water With Salt and Lemon

Salt is an ingredient of supreme importance for our nervous system, and it plays a critical role in our ability to function well physically, "net." Of course some people need to be careful about overconsumption, and obviously salt in processed food isn't recommended. But after being exposed to the wonders of salt on one of Andrew Huberman's shows (but of course), I discovered that many times when I think I'm hungry, my body simply needs salt, and that drinking a glass of water with half a teaspoon of salt and a few drops of lemon to improve the taste restores all my vitality, with far fewer calories or fuss.

Character: Kevin Kelly

Kevin Kelly is one of the most fascinating characters active today. The American Kelly, who turns 70 this year, is the founder of Wired magazine, and is also a writer, photographer, cultural preservationist, and a prolific scholar of Asian culture and digital culture. Kelly has published many books, and I've heard many interviews with him on various podcasts. Two good places to start are his interview with Tim Ferriss and his website, which can keep you busy for years (no exaggeration).


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page