top of page

Caring With Limited Liability: When Empathy Vanishes With the Breakup

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jan 15
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Three levels of caring explain how a partner can invest years in children who aren't biologically his — and then vanish without explanation, and without remorse.

Nurit (a pseudonym), in her late 40s, is recovering from a difficult, drawn-out breakup with a partner who wasn't the father of her twins. They were together for more than a decade, during which, at least on the surface, he seemed like a devoted man who took countless actions in service of the new family unit they'd built together.

In the relationship's final years, it became clear this was a man operating out of severe, at times extreme, narcissistic defenses: someone who struggles to tolerate any hit to his self-worth, tends to interpret situations entirely through himself, and responds with emotional withdrawal or numbness the moment a relationship stops serving his sense of worth and control. Eventually, they separated. Throughout it all, Nurit was convinced the difficulty was “just between the two of them,” and that even if the relationship with the girls changed after the breakup, her ex would remain a loving parental figure in their lives. I was less convinced.

Recently, about two years after the breakup, it turned out that her ex is completely out of touch — not with Nurit, and not with the girls, whom he helped raise and toward whom he showed warmth and care for roughly a decade. Nurit is struggling to process this.

In one of our conversations, she asks whether this means that all the positive behaviors he displayed over the years were manipulation designed to secure himself a range of benefits (and he did, in fact, benefit from the relationship in more than one sense) — meaning behaviors with no real feeling behind them from the start. Or maybe it's the opposite: that his very ability to display warmth and caring proves he doesn't actually suffer from severe narcissistic defenses the way she thinks, and that the harsh end of the relationship, and the cold, alienated nature of the breakup, are, to a much greater degree, “her fault” than she's willing to admit.

My Happiness Depends on Yours

I told her that although I understand how she's framing the question, I see things differently. In my experience, within a couple's relationship, at least three levels of empathy can exist. I call the first one: happy wife, happy life — meaning empathy a person gives their partner out of a utilitarian view: if my happiness depends on someone else's happiness, that other person had better be satisfied.

Utilitarian empathy like this rests on seeing the other person as a “helper object,” whose role is to preserve the narcissistic person's emotional equilibrium. You can think of it as bartering: empathy is a currency you spend to trade. When the partner shows attentiveness or generosity, he isn't meeting the other person's pain as such — he's identifying noise in the system that could disturb his own comfort.

So if Nurit was sad, her partner might have displayed “caring” mainly to avoid a conflict or a gloomy mood that would darken the atmosphere at home. This is “maintenance empathy” — essential to a relationship's day-to-day functioning, but lacking any subjective emotional depth. The moment the relationship ends and the “contract” is broken, the person has no further interest in investing in that resource.

This suggests that the displayed coldness after a breakup doesn't necessarily mean the earlier behavior was “fake” in any simple sense — only that it was functional. The engine that powered it, the narcissist's industrial calm, simply switched off.

Caring With Limited Liability: When Empathy Vanishes With the Breakup - illustration

Psychic Acrobatics

The second level of empathy can be described through a metaphor: “Ela Valley is on the way to Jerusalem.” A person with a narcissistic structure often needs the feeling that he's doing something for himself. So he may experience obligation, suffocation, boredom, or even resistance when asked to do something “just” for someone else. When the relationship is close and good, he's capable of psychic acrobatics: going out of his way for the other person, provided he manages to place the other's need onto the path that leads toward fulfilling his own.

Metaphorically, the narcissistically organized person wants to get to Jerusalem. His partner wants to get to the Ela Valley. When the relationship is strong, he's able to convince himself, and sometimes her and the people around them too, not only that the Ela Valley happens to be on the way to Jerusalem, but that it's also the best, the most moral, and the most beautiful way to get there.

You can think of parallel examples: someone who's strict about health and willing to go along with his partner's intermittent fasting because he frames it as “healthier”; someone willing to make an effort for one of his children's needs because it matches his self-image as a “total” parent; someone willing to allocate certain sums of money toward his partner's need because he justifies it as a smart investment.

At this level, the empathy is more sophisticated, and it's tied to the structure of the “ideal self.” Here, the narcissist isn't acting merely to preserve comfort; he's acting to feed his self-image as an admired, moral, or successful figure. In Heinz Kohut's terms, the other person functions as a “self-object” — a component meant to affirm his own sense of grandiosity.

The example of caring for children who aren't his biological daughters is especially relevant here: as long as he's seen, by himself and by the people around him, as the “perfect father,” as the family's “savior,” he may invest a great deal of warmth and care — because the girls are his “way” to feel moral superiority or meaning (his own arrival in Jerusalem). The empathy here is genuine on an experiential level, but it's entirely dependent on the narrative.

The moment the investment in the girls stops serving his self-image, or the breakup turns it into “a road that doesn't lead to Jerusalem,” the empathy may simply vanish. This helps explain why the disconnection is so total: without any gain for the self-image, acting for the other becomes a burden emptied of content.

I Actually Care

Both these types of empathy differ from the third kind, the highest level a relationship can aspire to. This is empathy that lets a person do something for someone else not because it benefits himself — meaning, not by force of the happy-wife-happy-life principle — and not because he needs to convince himself, or work hard to convince others, that the Ela Valley is the shortest route to Jerusalem. At this level, the person is willing to step outside the boundaries of the self for the other simply because the other person wants something, say, to visit the Ela Valley.

Intersubjective empathy, seeing the other as a subject, rests on the ability to recognize the other person's separate, independent existence. Unlike the two previous levels, it needs no excuse, no secondary gain, and no fit with a personal narrative. It comes from the ability to carry the other person's pain within you, even when that's uncomfortable, and even when it isn't “profitable.”

In Martin Buber's words, this is the shift from an “I-It” relation to an “I-Thou” relation. Someone capable of this will keep caring about the wellbeing of children he raised even after a painful breakup, because he understands they're living beings with feelings and needs, regardless of whether he's still inside the romantic relationship or outside it.

The absence of this level in Nurit's ex lets him erase a decade of relationship. From his perspective, the moment the framework dissolved, the people involved stopped being relevant, because they were never seen as separate subjects in his world to begin with — only as characters in his own personal drama. Seen this way, you can understand how a person is capable of displaying the first two levels of empathy for as long as the relationship holds: these behaviors aren't necessarily “fake” or “exploitative.” They're simply a particular kind of empathy.

I also told Nurit that, in many cases, people have enough good components within a relationship to sustain it over time, even if one side never reaches the third level. Something may remain missing, but the relationship can still be satisfying. That said, this analysis also explains why, when their particular relationship ended, the ending was cold, alienated, and at times cruel: it held almost no compassion at all — to the point where Nurit began to doubt the authenticity of the entire relationship.

The first two types of empathy exist, by their very nature, only within the framework of an active relationship. They have no real capacity to survive outside it. The third type, by contrast, can survive even after a breakup — and it's perhaps precisely then that its presence is truly tested.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page