"What's Wrong With Me?": When Therapy's Central Question Is the Wrong One
Updated: Oct 22
What happens when an obsessive search, in therapy, for the precise clinical label for a problem, is actually a distraction from the real question — one that, faced head-on, might expose the pain it's hiding.
Talia, Nurit, and Amira are very different from one another. Talia is a single businesswoman in her 40s. Nurit runs a fairly successful private business with her second husband, has a grown son, and is in her mid-fifties. Amira is a retired lecturer, seventy years old, married for what feels like forever, mother to two grown daughters, and a grandmother. What the three of them share, from my vantage point as their therapist, is something unusual: each of them is unusually preoccupied with the question “what's wrong with me?” and each of them, in her own way, is remarkably creative at steering session after session back around to that same question.
Talia, for instance, has told me more than once that she fantasizes about some kind of machine, an MRI of sorts, that scans the brain in a way that isn't yet scientifically possible, and produces a report explaining exactly what's “wrong” with us. Amira spends hours, with me and with other counselors, on the question of how her various emotional symptoms developed (and she does suffer). And Nurit has already stormed out of two previous courses of therapy, convinced her therapists knew what was wrong with her but refused to tell her — an experience she describes in dramatic terms, as a kind of abuse.
A Therapeutic Mirage
Of course, some people who come to therapy do want to know “what they have,” though I want to stress that this is by no means everyone. It's probably also worth clarifying that I don't mean understanding the therapeutic process itself. In the schools I work in, it matters that patients understand, at least in broad strokes, how we see the connection between the symptoms they're suffering from and what we're doing in our sessions, and why that's supposed to help.
We're also not talking about a question asked from a “vulnerable place.” Of course, any of us can sometimes feel despairing about life and frustrated with ourselves, feel that all our efforts to feel better aren't helping, and have that feeling spiral into some kind of anguished cry of “what's wrong with me????” And to be as clear as I can, we're also not talking about a situation where a person genuinely has some condition that was never diagnosed, like a spectrum disorder, say, and is asking the question as part of a diagnostic process that would genuinely let them live better.
In the case of these three women, we're talking about a “what's wrong with me” that, after the first, second, and third round of examination, turns out to be a kind of trap — the sort of question that, if you let yourself get pulled into it, sends you down a rabbit hole. A question that, no matter how many answers you find and give it, is never satisfied, but keeps receding, a kind of therapeutic mirage.
In all three cases, the attachment to searching for an answer to this question is so intense that it genuinely threatens to derail the therapy, because the patient prefers to dwell on and discuss this question rather than roll up her sleeves and go deeper into the therapeutic work itself — work that, for each of them, requires getting close to difficult subjects.
Talia needs to make a dramatic decision about motherhood, all while she can't manage to hold onto a single friendship, personal relationship, or professional connection without getting into grandiose fights with the other person (her parents are the only people she doesn't fight with). Nurit has a full plate of complicated things that need unpacking: her son was the victim of a crime as a child, and the trial of the man who hurt him has just opened.
This stirs up painful feelings in her son, and in Nurit herself, who was negligent in protecting him, partly because she herself was hurt in her own childhood and never dealt with her own trauma. The fact that she's married to a narcissistic man doesn't help. And at 70, Amira needs to begin mourning opportunities that were missed and will never come again, while her depression keeps getting worse.
After no small number of sessions devoted to investigating the question “what's wrong with me?” with each of them, and the investigation and the answers bring no relief, a moment arrives when I start asking myself: what's actually going on here? Why does it seem like each of these patients almost enjoys occupying herself with this meta-question, while nothing meaningful happens inside her (or outside, meaning in the various arenas where she needs to cope in more effective ways)?

A Search Engine
From the perspective of emotion-focused therapy, Talia, for instance, knows that her tantrums and outbursts of rage probably don't express her deepest feelings, but are covering something up. But instead of going deeper into that “something,” which is likely one of several things — a deep fear of being emotionally incapable of motherhood, and what it would mean to give that up; impostor syndrome around her business successes; feelings of inferiority next to her twin brother; and sadness and loneliness toward parents who, from a young age, had no patience for her — she stops just short of touching it.
Any one of these slides, if Talia chose to go down it, would bring her into contact with painful feelings, and so, to a large degree, it's no wonder she prefers the “what's wrong with me” slide instead, which brings with it a momentary burst of energy carrying the illusion that we'll locate the problem and then simply fix it, the way you'd swap out a part in a dishwasher.
When you think about it, you can see that in Nurit's case, the preoccupation with “what's wrong with me” actually interrupts the work of facing the terror and grief bound up in processing her own trauma and her son's. Her husband's narcissism provides plenty of relief, since she can complain about him (justifiably) quite a bit, but in the end, dwelling on the big question may itself be a kind of fog — almost an anesthetic gas she sprays to avoid feeling the shame that floods her whenever she gets close to the possibility that she failed to protect her son, and the bottomless — but healthy and important — sadness that sits so close to the surface.
And with Amira, the charming, witty, elegant one, her personal charm has become a kind of soothing mannerism that has almost fossilized into armor. I think that from a young age she learned that if she “performs,” she can get a certain kind of response to her needs. Relatives, teachers, neighbors — they all responded to her with far more warmth and affection than her parents did, but to get it, she usually had to “work her charm” on them, one way or another.
So it seems to me that in her case, “what's wrong with me” is almost a kind of lure — something she thinks she might need or be able to use to charm me, or hopes will get me to marvel together with her at her “mysterious problem,” instead of being at her side as she dares to open her eyes underwater and look squarely at the things that frighten her — perhaps the existential loneliness of the child she once was, echoing again in the particular loneliness that approaching old age threatens to bring, or is already bringing.
Different therapeutic approaches might frame this reformulation somewhat differently, but many therapists would agree on the need to resist the temptation to give any of these patients “the answer,” or to let the search for an answer take up too much room in the therapy, even when it seems like that's exactly what would ease their anxiety.
These three cases (fictional, a collage of different cases) are examples of a situation where the therapist has to point out that the search for the answer is itself part of what's keeping the patient stuck. Every therapist chooses, according to their own approach, how to invite the patient to step outside the matrix for a moment and observe what's happening — with the shared move being a shift from the question “what's wrong with me” to “what's happening right now that makes you feel you have to find the right label?”
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




