When the Survival Mechanism Falls Out of Balance
Updated: Oct 22
Since our days as early humans, our brains have been wired to notice changes in our environment. That ability helps us survive, but it can sometimes go awry. Our personal history can heighten our sensitivity to change well beyond what survival actually requires, and in doing so, hurt our day-to-day and emotional functioning
When I lift weights, my trainer knows it's important to raise the weight gradually. If she jumped straight from a warm-up weight to my working weight, I'd complain that it's too heavy and that there's no way I could lift it. But if she raises the weight slowly, I manage to get to my working weight almost without a hitch. I'm also someone who sleeps with earplugs and an eye mask, because every sound and every shift in light and shadow wakes me up. Is there a connection between these two things?
My good friend A. jumps at every noise on the street, even sitting alone at home. If we're talking and I go quiet for a moment because I'm thinking about something, he immediately asks, worried, whether he's boring me, whether I'm tired, or whether I need to end the conversation. Is there a connection between these two things in him? Is there a connection between what I've described in my own case and in his?
I believe all of these are examples of a brain that is highly attuned to changes in its environment — that is, sensitive to differences, rather than to absolute levels or quantities. A. and I aren't unusual in that. Since our days as early humans, our brains have been wired to notice changes in the environment. That ability contributes to our survival. We're wired to notice a change in movement, because a sudden rustle in the bushes might signal the presence of a predator — since sometimes we're the prey — or of potential prey, since sometimes we're the hunters too.
Changes in sound can also signal danger. Some predators sync their breathing to that of their prey as part of their hunting strategy, which shows just how acutely sensitive both hunter and hunted are to changes in sound.
We're sensitive to differences in light levels, given how existentially important sunlight is to us. And our brain is also able to quickly detect changes in familiar patterns and arrangements. Most of us easily notice when our favorite restaurant has moved the host stand, or redesigned the menu. And one of the phenomena I find most interesting, as a psychologist and couples therapist, is how alert our brains are to changes in the emotions of the people around us.
The underlying neurobiological mechanism is fascinating, because in some cases the brain seems to devote dedicated resources to detecting differences, while in others it heightens attention to change by tuning out the details that stay the same. Either way, the brain is wired to detect change quickly, so as to give us a chance to respond to it and improve our odds of survival. In other words, whoever notices a change faster stands a better chance of escaping and finding shelter in the event of an attack, and of securing food when an opportunity arises.
Ironically, precisely because this sensitivity is so essential to our survival, it can sometimes go wrong. My case and A.'s illustrate two different kinds of malfunction. I've described here before, and again in this column, how I sleep like a vampire, with earplugs and an eye mask (and there are more details I'll share soon). I didn't always suffer from such light sleep. Before my children were born I slept like a rock. But like many of us, the moment I became a parent, my brain changed. My offspring's survival shot to the top of my priority list, and my brain's ability to detect the sound of my babies crying, and respond to it, grew accordingly.
This process is called (per a rough translation) "perceptual narrowing," or "experience-dependent plasticity," and it describes the state in which the brain reshuffles its priorities, marking certain new stimuli — say, my baby's crying — as newly, especially important, worthy of attention and demanding a response (namely, getting out of bed).
In my case, the "rubber band" of sensitivity to sound signals during sleep stretched out when my children were born, and it never snapped back. I've remained in a state of heightened alertness and sensitivity to sound even at night ever since, and I haven't been able to sleep as deeply as I did before becoming a mother.
And what about A.'s case? The connection between his brain's ability to detect differences and his tendency toward anxiety is complex and multifaceted, but I do think a connection can be drawn. A. grew up in an emotionally unsafe environment. His parents' emotional storms often translated into dangerous events that affected him directly. His personal history made him highly attuned to changes in his environment, which developed into a chronic state of heightened alertness and a tendency to startle easily.
Like A.'s post-traumatic state, there are other mental health conditions characterized by heightened sensitivity to change. These include most anxiety disorders and obsessive-compulsive disorder — think of the person with OCD who needs to line up the fork at a precise angle to the napkin, and you'll understand just how sensitive they actually need to be to changes in their environment.
But schizophrenia, too, is a condition in which changes in the environment can become the basis for hallucinations and delusions. Depression is also a state in which there's a tendency to interpret every environmental change negatively. And when we look through the lens of heightened sensitivity to environmental change, attention deficit disorder seems relevant to the discussion as well — whether because heightened attention to environmental change makes it harder to concentrate, or the reverse, that difficulty focusing on a task leads to heightened sensitivity to environmental change.
On the flip side of this phenomenon are emotional disorders marked by a decreased ability to notice changes in the environment. I mentioned schizophrenia, depression, and attention deficit disorder earlier as conditions that sometimes involve heightened sensitivity to change. But in all three of those conditions, there can also sometimes be a decrease in attention to environmental change. Likewise, people on the spectrum can struggle to notice changes in their surroundings, certainly emotional changes centered on nonverbal cues. And it's clear that someone with dementia experiences a dramatic impairment in their ability to notice environmental change.
What I find interesting here is that this is an explanation that manages, through a single mechanism, to account for some of the impairment in physiological functioning and some of the impairment in social functioning that characterizes serious emotional problems. I opened this column with four seemingly trivial examples: sensitivity to an increase in physical exertion, sensitivity to sounds during sleep, sensitivity to sudden noises, and sensitivity to emotional changes in others. My point is that all of these sensitivities are, in fact, different manifestations of the very same phenomenon.
We might intuitively understand why someone suffering from anxiety could also struggle with sleep and easily fight with the people close to them, but heightened sensitivity to environmental change explains both of these phenomena through a single mechanism. Similarly, we can understand that someone with depression both sleeps during the day and is relatively indifferent to positive events in the lives of people around them. But again, reduced sensitivity to environmental change explains both of these phenomena through that same mechanism.
And if we zoom out from these specific examples, we could say that disruptions in sensitivity to environmental change may be the missing link between emotional disorders and impaired functioning in general. In other words, it's possible that depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, post-traumatic stress, and other serious conditions don't impair functioning only directly, but also through the way they impair the accuracy with which an individual perceives changes in their environment.

Recommendations
Book: Like There Are No Words in the World, by Sapir Paz
I read Sapir Paz's book of poems (Pegasus Publishing) through a screen of tears. Paz wrote the book after her mother, who suffered from mental illness, took her own life.
Exercise: just eight songs
This whole business of exercising is exhausting, which is why all sorts of self-deception are required to actually make it happen. One of the new tricks working for me lately is built on the realization that a decent cardio workout lasts just eight songs, give or take some skipping between songs I start to hear and then realize I have no patience for. Once you think about it that way, you realize that after two songs, a quarter of the workout is already behind you. And by the fourth song, you already know there are only four songs left. And what's four songs, really? Nothing at all, right?
Health: water against fructose
Continuing my new theme, that not all sugars are created equal, I want to keep sharing the dangers of fructose with you. It turns out there's more and more research pointing to the fact that a high salt intake increases our bodies' own internal production of fructose.
In an interview Peter Attia did with Rick Johnson, whom I've written about here before, Johnson explains that this specific fructose-production process is influenced by sodium levels in the blood, and that we can rein it in by making sure to drink plenty of water whenever we eat sodium-heavy foods, which lowers the sodium level in our blood.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




