Watch "Lupin" With Your (Older) Kids: It's Good for Their Brains
Updated: Oct 22
Watching the new season of Netflix's thriller series is also a chance to practice skills like mentalization with your kids, sharpen their sense of what subjectivity is, and help them examine how things look from different points of view
I probably wouldn't have enjoyed the second season of the thriller series "Lupin" very much if I had tried to watch it alone. But a viewing marathon that stretched over several days with my youngest son turned it into an enjoyable experience for me and a developmental one for him. The very same screenwriting element that would make it frustrating for an adult viewer is what gives it its potential for the young viewer (accompanied by a parent), and that element is the reversal of perspectives on the same event.
Over the series' five episodes, the creators repeatedly use one of the most beloved tricks in heist movies, replaying the plot move the viewers have just been made to watch, but from a slightly different perspective. The goal, of course, is to produce an astonishing twist in the episode's plot, and presumably, for the average viewer, by the 51,000th time this mechanism is triggered, the amazement wears a little thin.
But for a younger, less experienced viewer, not only does the mechanism still work the 51,000th time, but each time the shift of perspective occurs, he gets to practice and develop his ability to understand another person's mental world. And as a bonus, he also gets to cuddle with Mom on the couch under a blanket in the air conditioning and go to bed late.
Of course, watching Lupin this way has to be tailored to the specific age and temperament of the kids, because of the content. Although it isn't depicted explicitly or shockingly by the standards of television, it can be experienced as very hard for children at certain ages, while remaining abstract in other respects. In addition, it is not passive viewing for the parent. It involves many pauses, meant to make sure the young viewer has really grasped the shift in perspective, and the game in the move from the illusion of objectivity to the revelation of the subjectivity of points of view. Viewing like this suits a parent with one child better, because any other combination could be frustrating for the more sophisticated adult viewers.
The ability to grasp another person's inner world, and to understand how things look from their point of view, given their beliefs, perceptions, feelings, and the information they've been exposed to, is of the utmost importance in our psychological development. Without the ability to understand that two different people can perceive the same "reality" in different ways, our capacity to cooperate, which is the foundation of our physical and mental survival as adults, remains very limited.
Without this ability we can't anticipate how others will react to us if we take their property without permission or hurt them physically; we won't know whether the person we live with is angry at us personally or upset about a personal crisis at work; we won't manage to negotiate fruitfully. And without close guidance and intensive nurturing, there's a chance we'll end our lives lying on the sidewalk with our head in a puddle, after absorbing a blow to the skull from a blunt object.
In the professional literature, the subject is also known as the ability to develop a theory of mind, and it also relates to the development of a person's personal epistemology (that is, the theories we form about the nature of knowledge and knowing itself). This development passes through several stages, starting from the absolutist stage, in which the human mind operates on the assumption that knowledge is entirely objective, and maturing into the stage in which knowledge is seen, on the one hand, as subjective and, on the other, as something to which objective tools (like arguments and evidence) can be applied in order to evaluate it.

There are many psychological tests that try to assess the quality of theory of mind. In simplified form, in one of the best known, the examiner shows the subject two dolls: Doll A has a basket and Doll B has a box. The examiner shows the subject that Doll A places a bead in her basket, leaves the basket in the room, and goes out. Then the examiner shows the subject that Doll B takes the bead out of the basket and puts it in her own box. At this point, Doll A comes back into the room. The examiner then asks the child: "Where will Doll A look for her bead?" Children whose cognitive development is typical, and who manage to develop a theory about the mind of the other, answer correctly that Doll A will look for the bead in her basket, because that's where she put it before she left, and because from her point of view, nothing has happened since she put the bead in the basket that could have affected its location.
By contrast, children with an impairment in cognitive development that makes it hard for the grasp of the other's mind to mature, such as on the autism spectrum, assume that Doll A knows what they know, and have difficulty grasping that from Doll A's point of view things look different. Such subjects will answer that Doll A will look for the bead in Doll B's box.
It is understandable, then, why a series like Lupin, in which the suspenseful twist in every single episode relies on the viewer's ability to enjoy seeing the same events from different points of view, will be especially enjoyable for children at ages when they are still honing their theory-of-mind muscles.
Even after this ability matures, it keeps developing. In more fundamental terms, entertaining practice in adopting points of view, like the kind provided by season 2 of Lupin, strengthens the foundation for mentalization in the broadest and most essential sense. Our ability to draw conclusions about another person's thoughts, feelings, and beliefs from their behavior is critical for us in childhood, but it is also vital once we become parents.
How will we understand why a child suddenly refuses to do simple homework on their own, if we can't put ourselves in their shoes and discover that this is actually how they get pleasant, rare attention from one of their always-busy parents? How will we understand why our daughter objects so strongly to the idea of moving to a larger apartment in another part of town, if we don't know how to draw a mental map of her world, and realize that she was waiting for next year to finally join the scout troop near her home?
The claim about the psychological benefits of watching Lupin for children is connected, at least by association, to the argument of the American thinker Martha Nussbaum, who in her book "Poetic Justice" developed the argument that all of us (and especially lawyers, who were the main audience she had in mind at the time) should read more novels (that is, fiction), because such reading inherently develops the reader's moral sensitivity and empathic abilities. Even if you weren't around when Nussbaum's book came out, it's easy to imagine the criticism it took. The basic headline of that criticism was "The Nazis read fine literature too." And that's true. Though it's not certain that this criticism totally demolishes Nussbaum's claim, because one can still argue that the Nazis understood very well how the human psyche works, and how things look from different points of view, of victims, of civilians, of soldiers, and so on. The problem was not a lack of understanding of the subject, but rather the way it was applied.
And if Nussbaum took flak for recommending that people read Dickens, it's clear that recommending watching Lupin with kids can also stir controversy. So it's worth adding an asterisk that this is not a sweeping, unequivocal recommendation. If you had meant instead to take them to see sharks at the Hadera power station, to visit the archaeology wing of the Israel Museum, or simply to have a family evening of screen-free board games, go for it. That's far better than watching Lupin together.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




