Want to Sleep Well? Don't Banish the Dark
Updated: Oct 22
Many sleep problems are caused by improper exposure to light. A special Hanukkah list
Sarah (all names are pseudonyms, and the stories are published at the patients' request) can't get out of bed. When I want to let her know that an hour has opened up on the day she asked for, I know I have to text her at six in the morning, before she goes to sleep, or at six in the evening, the only hour when she's reasonably sure to be awake. Guy, by contrast, goes to bed around midnight and wakes in terror in total darkness, putting off the moment when he'll check the clock and discover that it isn't even four a.m. yet. He knows his day begins the moment he opens his eyes, and in most cases it's a very long and frustrating one.
One sleeps too much, the other too little. Do their sleep difficulties point to a problem in the same biological mechanism? Is Sarah simply a "night person"? Where did Guy go wrong?
I'm not a sleep researcher, but it's clear to me that good sleep at the right hours of the day (consider this sentence a gun hanging on the wall in the first act) is an essential part of psychological well-being, even if it's sometimes hard to tell whether it's a cause or an effect. And good sleep is also intimately tied to our relationship with darkness and light.
That relationship changes over the years. Many children are afraid of sleep itself, which simulates death, loss of control and so on. But the fear isn't only of sleep; it's of the dark as well. And on the face of it, throughout our lives most of us prefer light. In fact, we have a kind of hunger for light. I had occasion to think about the subject ahead of a conversation in the "Hard Question" segment of Shay Piron and Inbal Gazit's radio show. In preparing for it, I realized that what truly frightens us isn't the dark itself, but a situation in which we need to see and cannot.
Sight is critical to our survival. Without it, it would be hard for us to obtain food, and in the wild we'd quickly become food ourselves. So darkness frightens us in scenarios where we'll need to see and the dark will impair our vision. If so, perhaps we have no built-in fear of the dark. After all, some activities are done better in the dark. When we're naked in bed with someone we love, most of us have no need for bright lighting; quite the opposite. We have no need to control the situation through the sense of sight. We feel safe enough, and bright light might make it harder for us to connect with ourselves or our partner. It's no coincidence that one of the differences between an erotic scene and a porn scene lies in the lighting.
Women also find it easier to give birth in a space that isn't too brightly lit, and massage, various mind-body treatments, and heart-to-heart conversations tend to be experienced as more successful when they don't take place under fluorescent lights. Many different processes in our bodies need darkness. In other words, we need light, but we also need darkness.
And we need not only darkness itself but also sleep. We go haywire without light, just like Sarah, but we come off the rails without sleep, like Guy. In fact, although we still don't know exactly how sleep is a critical part of our health (there are theories about its role in repairing and restoring cells, and others focusing on its role in consolidating memory), we do know that we would cause an animal's death if we chronically deprived it of sleep.

That is, we need both light and darkness, but we also need to receive them in a very particular way, or we fall out of sync, like Sarah and Guy. The biological clock (the circadian rhythm) differs from the solar day. (A cute detail is that the name of this system reflects its imprecision: circa means "about" and dia means "day," so right in the name we learn that it's a rhythm of "about a day.") The solar day is exactly 24 hours long, but our biological day is roughly 24.2 hours. Exposure to light at the right time, and avoiding exposure to light at the right time, are essential to keep us synchronized with the solar day.
0.2 of an hour doesn't sound like much: just 12 minutes. But like a clock that is never reset, that's 12 minutes every single day. If we don't maintain the link between our bodies and the solar day, within five days a gap of an hour opens between us and our surroundings, and within a month we're living six hours apart from reality. In Sarah's case, going to sleep at six in the morning and waking at four in the afternoon, she couldn't climb out of her depression for months and was already living completely upside down relative to her surroundings.
Sarah felt it was easier to deal with the world at night and that her surroundings were less threatening to her (fewer emails, and less chance of running into stressful neighbors in the stairwell), but falling out of sync with the environment has severe effects. If we return for a moment to our basic survival, an animal that sleeps while the whole jungle is awake lowers its chances of passing its genes to the next generation, to put it delicately. And even in the modern jungle, people tend to look critically at those who sleep during the day. There are various reasons for this, but among them, I assume most of us have formed the impression that people who are awake by day and asleep by night thrive more than those whose cycle is reversed.
Incidentally, some people believe they're simply "night people," but the research on this isn't conclusive. A fascinating example is an experiment done with teenagers, who are known for struggling to fall asleep at "normal" hours and to wake up along with the rest of humanity. I heard about this study, as I did about many of the fascinating ideas presented here, in studies and interviews by the formidable chronobiologist (a researcher of cyclical phenomena) Dr. Samer Hattar. Hattar described an experiment in which teenagers were taken on a week of camping in nature, told they could go to sleep and wake up at any hour they liked, but allowed exposure to natural light only, that is, to the solar day. The vast majority of participants synchronized to the solar day within a week, and what's fascinating is that the synchronization was then maintained for a very long time.
So, returning to the question of light and dark, it seems to us that we seek and crave light. Our language supports this: we speak of "the light at the end of the tunnel," and a loved one is "the light of my life." But the emphasis on light may stem from the fact that we are naturally aware only of the conscious part of our vision, the part that produces images. In practice, our psychological and biological well-being, for all the overlap between them, rests on exposure to light and avoidance of light at the right stages of the day.
And by the way, exposure to light at the right hours isn't enough. The model considered to have the greatest effect of light on our bodies and minds stresses that we must also match our activity level and our food intake to the cycle of day and night. More and more studies suggest that people like Sarah and Guy need to time their physical activity and eating to daylight hours so they can bring body and mind to maximum balance. And even if we don't suffer from being out of sync to the degree that Sarah and Guy do, most of us would feel better physically and mentally if we dimmed the lights at home in the evening (a bit like on an airplane), went out for a quarter of an hour in natural light in the morning, and of course stayed away from screens as much as possible before bed.
When I studied anthropology, I remember the enormous impression made on me by Mary Douglas's insight: dirt is matter out of place. That is, sand at the beach is fine, but sand in the house is dirt. Food on a plate is lovely, but food in your hair is dirt. By extension, we might say that problems of emotional hygiene, that is, psychological distress, are often tied to light and darkness that are out of place.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



