top of page

Want to Enjoy Things More? Start Enjoying Them Less

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jan 13, 2022
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

If we understand what dopamine is and what behavioral changes it can bring about, we can improve our motivation and our enjoyment. The problem is that we usually do exactly the opposite of what we need to do

Dopamine is one of the substances that most affect our emotional and mental state. And yet most of us don't know enough about it. That's a shame, because a deeper understanding of dopamine's role and how it works in the brain can help us live better lives, and in particular keep our motivation and our enjoyment up over the long run.

Dopamine functions in our bodies as both a hormone and a neurotransmitter. These technical terms matter less. What's important to understand is that dopamine is like the highlighter the brain uses to mark experiences with a signal that says: I want to do this again. Dopamine is involved in creating a sense of motivation, in sparking curiosity, in learning, in the desire to explore our surroundings, and in many other functions. These are all aspects tied to the evolutionary value that a healthy dopamine level provides: increasing our chances of reproducing, both in raising offspring and in accumulating resources.

It's easier to picture if we travel back in time. Let's imagine we're prehistoric people in a cave. Without dopamine, when we ran out of food we wouldn't leave the cave. Are we crazy? Out there, snakes, scorpions and fires are waiting for us, and we could get hurt and lost. In other words, without dopamine, once the food runs out, life runs out. But that isn't how it goes. We don't give up on life easily. Dopamine is the substance that lets us survive this scenario. It is the organic compound in our brains that makes us come up with a plan for a successful exit from the cave. We remember where we saw a deer, try to work out the safest time, weather-wise, to set out on the journey, and grow curious about what awaits us beyond that mountain. Thanks to dopamine, we get excited about the plan and head out.

And dopamine's job doesn't end there. Suppose our plan worked out, we found a strawberry bush and even caught a deer. At this stage, we'll feel a waterfall of dopamine washing over our brains. A big, powerful pleasure, like the cascade of coins pouring out of a casino slot machine. It's wonderful, but as we all know, it ends quickly. Why, in fact, can't a high dopamine level last long? From an evolutionary standpoint, it makes sense. If dopamine kept us blissed out for a long time, we wouldn't have the motivation to keep looking after our future, and we wouldn't manage to reproduce. In other words, there is a survival logic that explains the rise-and-fall mechanism of dopamine. And indeed, dopamine falls. Not only that, it falls below the baseline we had before we set out on the search.

Beyond its survival advantage, this drop is a biological function. Essentially, dopamine is produced and stored at the tips of neurons, inside synaptic vesicles, and is released into the synapses in response to a nerve impulse. Making dopamine is a multi-step process, and once the brain has released its dopamine stores, it takes the body time to produce dopamine again and refill those little sacs where it is kept. We experience this biological mechanism every time we feel the down after the high. Because biologically that's how it works: the higher the high, meaning the more dopamine released, the deeper the down.

And what do we do when we experience a down? We try to get more dopamine, of course. And the way we go about it is usually mistaken and gets us the opposite of the results we want. That's because, in our chase after dopamine, we naturally assume that the more dopamine-releasing activities we combine, the more fun we'll have. It's natural: on the face of it, coffee with a teaspoon of sugar is sweeter than coffee with no sugar, and coffee with two teaspoons is sweeter than coffee with one.

But the truth is more complicated. The dopamine-based experience of pleasure in our brains is not just a direct product of the absolute amount of dopamine released; it is also a result of the relative change in the amount of dopamine. Imagine a pleasure scale from 1 to 10, and place on it an activity that gives us pleasure at a level of 8. The point is that this activity will not give us pleasure at a level of 8 out of 10 every time it happens, because our enjoyment of it depends on the dopamine context. If a pleasure at level 8 was preceded by a pleasure at level 6, the activity will be enjoyable, because the brain will register a rise in dopamine following it. But if it comes after an experience we registered as a 10, we won't enjoy it, because the brain will experience a drop in dopamine. And if it comes after an activity whose pleasure was identical to it, that is, at a level of 8, we won't be thrilled by it either, because the brain won't experience any change in dopamine level.

This point is critical. You are probably beginning to understand why dopamine is involved in addiction. After all, in addiction the first uses bring a large rise in pleasure, but later uses bring more modest pleasure. On top of that, if the brain experiences a drop below baseline each time, then the dopamine released by the substance not only fails to produce the same relative rise as in the first few times, but gradually more and more of it is needed just to get back to baseline at all.

We know this problem even without being addicted to hard drugs. In fact, we bring this negative effect on ourselves, and damage our basic enjoyment of life, every time we spoil ourselves with what I call "dopamine sandwiches." Dopamine sandwiches are combinations of different activities, each of which releases dopamine on its own. Snacking while watching television is an example of a dopamine sandwich. After all, watching television releases dopamine by itself, and so does eating snacks. Combining the two makes a dopamine sandwich, so that if we later try to go back to one of the two activities without the other, we experience a relative drop in dopamine, and the activity that was originally enjoyable in its own right feels less exciting.

Want to Enjoy Things More? Start Enjoying Them Less - illustration

Similarly, eating a meal while scrolling on your phone is a dopamine sandwich (in every sense of the word), after which eating without the dopamine from the phone feels less enjoyable. Using a stimulant during a workout: a dopamine sandwich, after which working out without the stimulant isn't as enjoyable as it originally was. Soaking in a bath with a book and a glass of wine: a dopamine sandwich. Masturbating while watching porn: one of the common, problematic dopamine sandwiches of our time. Spending time with the kids while using your phone or while high on weed: also among the common sandwiches.

So what can we do? Take the sandwich apart. It's fine to let loose once in a while. A bath with a glass of wine never killed anyone, but our lives don't need to look like a hip-hop video, with a pool, women in bikinis, and Courvoisier cognac. And I say this as a big fan of Courvoisier. So if we want to enjoy our lives more consistently, it's worth examining where in our lives we're stacking too many dopamine-releasing activities on top of one another, and starting to ease off there.

Amalia Rosenblum's Recommendations

Book: The Teachings of Don Juan (new edition)

How could we do without a few mushrooms? In keeping with the spirit of the times, a new edition is being published of the first book in the series by the writer and anthropologist Carlos Castaneda, describing his first encounter with the Mexican-Indian sorcerer Don Juan and his experiences with mind-altering plants. Although it is the first book in the series, it is one for the seasoned reader, hungry for details about the different ways hallucinogenic plants affect consciousness.

Lecture: Everything You Need to Know About the Rainforest

Dr. Mark Plotkin is an ethnobotanist who has devoted his life to studying the rainforests, their tribes, and their enormous medical knowledge. His lecture is enjoyable and enlightening, and a great introduction to his rich and fascinating body of research. Once you hear about the shaman who pulled out a machete to treat Plotkin's aching leg, you won't be able to stop listening.

Activity With the Kids: Making Music

I'm especially fond of activities with kids in which the adults are at a disadvantage. One of these is creating a song or a piece of music in the long-standing music-making app GarageBand. You can use the app in all kinds of ways, depending on the kids' ages and musical tastes. When my son was very young, he made songs by singing the words on one track and the melody on another. Today he can already create a song with several tracks representing different instruments. But the most fun (to my mind) is still making music tracks by combining a huge trove of ready-made musical loops. And as my son taught me, you can even make the basic loops yourself.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page