top of page

Want to Enjoy Life More? Learn to Give Yourself a Proper Pat on the Back

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jan 27, 2022
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Our brains release dopamine in response to positive experiences, but also in response to more sophisticated acts like positive thinking. These acts can help us cope with challenges and reduce our dependence on outside sources

In my previous column I recommended avoiding "dopamine sandwiches": situations in which we stack too many activities together, each of which, on its own, triggers a release of dopamine in the brain. I explained that when we do this, it feels as though we're boosting our motivation and our enjoyment of life, when in fact we're undermining our ability to enjoy, and to feel motivated by, the things that already give us pleasure and that we're basically inclined to do anyway. But quitting is not easy, as treatment centers and welfare agencies, prisons, fast-food manufacturers, the diet industry and video game developers can all attest — in other words, everyone whose business is either producing dopamine sandwiches or dealing with the damage they cause.

That's why I want to stress that there is something we can do to help ourselves cope with the relative drop in dopamine we experience as we start changing our behavior patterns. It has to do with the fact that the brain's dopamine system sits both in the primitive part of the brain and in the most highly evolved part. That is, the brain releases dopamine in response to basic, intense experiences: chocolate, sex, drugs. But there is also a system of dopaminergic neurons in the prefrontal cortex, which means, among other things, that the brain releases dopamine in response to more sophisticated activities, such as conscious thought and the creation of meaning.

From this follows a fundamental principle: we can improve how we feel through the power of thought alone. This is an especially powerful tool in situations like the ones we're discussing here, where our dopamine dips because we're "detoxing" from dopamine sandwiches and refraining from putting outside substances into our bodies or engaging in activities that involve the outside world, such as sex, food or gambling. The key point is that while we deliberately impose a drop in dopamine on ourselves (in order to raise our baseline enjoyment, of course), we can soften the fall by adding dopamine from an internal source, if we give ourselves a proper pat on the back. That is, if we remind ourselves that what we're doing is meaningful to us, in line with our values, and good in our own eyes.

Say, for example, that I'm trying to stick to an eating pattern that limits the hours in which I eat (intermittent fasting, or 16:8). And during the fasting hours, late at night before bed, I really feel like having a small glass of cognac. The more I think about it, the more clearly I feel my brain craving its squirt of dopamine. But I can produce a light spray of dopamine in my own head without pouring myself a drink. I can do it by reminding myself that right now my body is entering a fasting state, my cells are beginning to repair themselves, and I'm contributing to my body's ability to handle sugar, and so on.

This is the right way to cheer ourselves on, and I want to sharpen the picture by focusing on two common mistakes. The first is faking positive thoughts, and the second is using the carrot-and-stick method. Faking positive thoughts means, for instance, trying to convince myself that I love a certain food when in fact I don't, or that I enjoy fasting when in fact I'm suffering through it. Well, that's not what this is about. It's very hard for the brain to lie to itself directly. We can tell ourselves anything, of course, but if we don't truly believe it, the fakery may do something, but it won't deliver the benefit we're talking about here.

What we're talking about is attaching the new activity to an action or thought that is positive and that we truly believe in, meaning one that really does generate dopamine for us. Pairing an activity that produces no dopamine with one that does is yet another expression of our ability to engineer our own brains, so that we come to prefer activities we didn't used to like, whether it's fasting, exercise, quitting smoking or eating vegetables.

For instance, if I add vegetables I don't like to the main meal of the day, which consists of foods I consider healthy, good and tasty (a vegan burger meal, say), the brain will gradually generalize, and I'll come to associate the vegetables I used not to like with the cascade of dopamine that accompanies a meal I enjoy. This will spontaneously help me start preferring those vegetables. But the pairing won't work if I try to connect the new, dopamine-free activity to another activity that is itself dopamine-free, such as pretending that something is tasty, interesting or enjoyable when it isn't.

The second mistake involves handing out rewards after the activity, meant to compensate me for my suffering. For example, if I'm fasting and I try to calm myself by fantasizing about what I'll eat when the fast ends, I'm actually making my suffering worse. It's a serious mistake, and just as common, so it's very important to understand. A reward that isn't a natural result of the activity I'm engaged in, but comes from an outside source, makes the activity itself seem less enjoyable and makes the time I spend on it crawl.

One arena in which we tend to make this mistake over and over is raising children. If I want my child to take part in household chores, to clear the dishes from the table and load the dishwasher, it's best not to attach rewards to the task, such as a small bonus on his allowance, more screen time, or an extra dessert. Rewards of this kind undermine the child's basic motivation to do the task. The right way to strengthen his motivation is to praise him while he's doing it, that is, to join his intrinsic motivation. You can do that with (genuine) statements like "It makes me so happy that you're already so grown-up and independent and can help out the rest of the family," or "Thank you so much for tidying up, the house will feel so much nicer tonight."

Want to Enjoy Life More? Learn to Give Yourself a Proper Pat on the Back - illustration

The formula here is simple: dopamine equals motivation. Where there is intrinsic motivation, meaning it's possible to generate dopamine on our own by giving the activity positive meaning, an external reward just creates another version of the same dopamine sandwich we're trying to avoid, and it erodes my baseline ability to enjoy the activity.

Amalia Rosenblum's Recommendations

Book: The Wisdom of Insecurity: A Message for an Age of Anxiety (Alan Watts)

Alan, Alan, Alan. As my father's wife likes to say, "what is there to say when there's nothing to say." This new Hebrew translation of Watts's 1951 book suits our times perfectly, and of course would have suited any year in which it came out. Read the following passage and you'll see for yourself: "When belief in the eternal becomes impossible and all that's left is the wretched substitute of believing in believing, people look for happiness in the pleasures of time. And although they try to bury it deep in their consciousness, they remain fully aware that these pleasures pass. This has two consequences. On the one hand, there is the anxiety that they may be missing something, so the mind flits nervously and greedily from one pleasure to the next, finding no peace or satisfaction in any of them. On the other hand, the frustration of always having to chase some future good, in a tomorrow that never arrives, in a world where everything is bound to crumble, leads a person to wonder, 'what's the point?'" (and that's only on page 25).

It's a book that works equally well for beginners and longtime fans, and for anyone who needs a reminder that since we're chasing our own tails, the least we can do is try a little less hard to catch them.

Meditation: Ruth King

Ruth King is an American community leader who works to spread the use of mindfulness as a way of combating racism. This particular meditation has nothing to do with racism; it's a classic body scan meant to bring the mind to a less tense, more present state. It's one of the most accessible and effective meditations I've come across on YouTube, or anywhere, and I use it before important, "familyological" events like the Passover seder (don't get smug, it's just around the corner).

App: Reveri

Dr. David Spiegel has been researching self-hypnosis at Stanford University for some 45 years. This practical, effective app grew out of his research, and it teaches you how to use your brain's own abilities to sharpen your concentration, reduce anxiety, and make fundamental changes in your life more easily. The app isn't perfect, but it's one of the best I've come across. Spiegel is a deeply serious man, and the exercises may be a little embarrassing, but they're quick and strangely powerful.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 

Related Posts

bottom of page