Two Words Worth Leaving Behind in 2025
Updated: Oct 22
A new year is a chance to leave behind the words that block our emotional progress. Why it's worth giving up "why" — and it's really not a shame to let go of "a shame"
A new year is always a chance to make ourselves new promises. In the self-improvement department, this year I'm setting myself the following goal: to cut back, as much as I can, on asking "why?" in conversation with other people, and on using the word "a shame" — both when I'm talking to myself, and even more so when I'm talking to others.
I'm a little embarrassed to admit that it's only recently that I understood just how problematic the question "why?" really is. I imagine that, like all of us, it felt natural to ask "why" whenever I wanted to understand what was driving the person I was talking to.
Most of the time I use that word, it seems to me that I'm simply being direct, matter-of-fact, and well-intentioned. But even though "why" looks harmless enough on the surface, in practice it often puts people on the defensive.
Language as an Interrogation Room
Psychologically, when we ask someone "why," we're often setting up a power dynamic that can make them feel like they're being interrogated. Under the surface, it's a question that demands justification and leaves the person answering feeling they have to defend their choices, or prove something.
"Why" demands that people lay out the rationale behind their behavior, and in doing so it tends to provoke resistance rather than cooperation. In many situations, the question "why" carries a built-in assumption that something went wrong or needs fixing. "Why did you agree to pay that price?", for example, is a question that implies the choice needs justifying — because it might have been the wrong one.
When I ask "why," I may end up challenging the identity or the values of the person in front of me. If I ask, say, "why do you believe Bibi won't be re-elected?", the question can imply that the other person's read on reality, or their worldview, seems questionable or mistaken to me — even if that isn't my intention at all. The demand for justification stirs discomfort, especially when the subject of the conversation is sensitive or emotionally charged.
If what I actually want is for the other person to reconsider their reasons, then asking them "why" does the opposite — it pushes them to defend those reasons instead. If they don't have a clear reason for what they did or believe, the question "why" can expose that gap (and maybe I'm even aiming for that), but exposing the cognitive dissonance tends to trigger defensiveness rather than reflection.
Part of this effect is built in. The person asking "why" is, in effect, sliding into the role of interrogator, and placing the person answering in an inferior position. The question itself can make the person being asked feel judged, rather than feeling like an equal partner in the conversation. There may even be an echo, in the question, of a tone of discipline or of childhood authority ("why didn't you do your homework?") — associations that can stir up unconscious feelings of guilt or worthlessness in the person being asked.
On top of that, the question can disrupt the emotional flow of the conversation, because it often interrupts the narrative the other person was trying to tell, or had just started building. "Why" forces them to stop and start analyzing or justifying feelings that may not be fully formed yet, or that aren't easy to explain.
Even if my goal was to understand them better, the question can achieve exactly the opposite effect, leaving them feeling misunderstood. Even though "why" is seeking information, it can come across as an intellectual or distant question, rather than one asked out of empathy. That sense of emotional disconnection can push the other person further away.
And if all that weren't enough, this question also frequently just doesn't help. "Why" can be too broad and too overwhelming to actually move a conversation forward. If I ask someone "why did you choose to get back together with him?", I leave them with too many possible ways to understand what I'm asking, or what kind of answer I'm expecting.
The question can stir up anxiety or frustration in them. In the context of cooperation — and what conversation with someone important isn't, in one way or another, bound up with cooperation? — "why" pulls the discussion toward blame instead of solutions. For example, when I ask someone "why didn't you finish writing this chapter on time?", the question centers on blame, instead of starting to understand how we solve the problem in front of us.

When a Small Word Is a Story of Disaster
The second word I'm hoping to use less is "a shame." In everyday speech, the word "a shame" often shows up as a seemingly innocent expression of regret, disappointment, or a missed opportunity. We use it almost automatically: "it's a shame you didn't come," or simply, "what a shame." But underneath that everyday use lies a deeper emotional charge, one that reflects the pain we create for ourselves through our own inner dialogue.
The trouble with the word "a shame" becomes clearer if we think about it through the lens of Leslie Greenberg's emotion-focused therapy, which identifies two inner voices that often dominate our emotional landscape: the critical voice (directed at ourselves) and the catastrophizing voice (in the sense of one that stirs up anxiety).
The inner critic is the part of us that judges, evaluates, and often condemns our actions, decisions, or reactions. The inner critic loves the word "a shame." It uses it to say: "It's a shame I didn't work harder," meaning: I should have tried harder — whether because I wasn't good enough, or because I made the wrong choices — it's my fault that I failed. "A shame" bridges disappointment and self-reproach, amplifying the voice of the inner critic while reinforcing feelings of worthlessness or guilt.
Our catastrophizing voice loves this word too. It thrives on turning one small disappointment into a sweeping story of disaster. "A shame" is fertile ground for this process, because it encourages us to focus on what could have been, and to imagine the worst-case scenarios that follow from what didn't happen. When the catastrophizing voice says "it's a shame I didn't get that job," what it really means is "I'll never find a good job, it's a shame I didn't say something because now I've ruined my chances forever."
From the perspective of emotion-focused therapy, catastrophizing isn't just a thought pattern — it's an emotional experience that deepens feelings of helplessness, sadness, and anxiety. By repeating the word "a shame," the catastrophizing voice tightens its grip on our emotional state.
The Past Is Still Ahead of Us!
What's interesting is that, at bottom, "why" and "a shame" share a conceptual bond in that they often lead to, and intensify, emotional states of regret, self-blame, and being stuck — between us and others, and between us and ourselves. Even though these words can serve meaningful purposes in certain contexts, they actually tend to stir up similar psychological dynamics that suppress growth, cooperation, and emotional resilience.
Both "why" and "a shame" direct our attention to the past, fixing us on what has already happened. "Why" forces people to justify past actions or decisions, at times creating a sense that what happened was a mistake or a failure.
For example, asking "why didn't you prepare more for the interview?" invites a critical review of what already happened, instead of focusing on solutions. Similarly, "a shame" places the emphasis on what was missed or lost, framing it as something irreversible. When I say, "it's a shame we didn't take the opportunity," I'm mourning what could have been, instead of checking what's still possible.
Both words amplify our inner critic. The question "why didn't you get to the airport earlier?" can land like "you should have managed your time better." And in the same way, "it's a shame you didn't say anything" can land like "you should have spoken up, and now it's your fault."
On top of that, both words feed a tendency toward catastrophizing — turning a small event into a sweeping narrative of failure or loss. "Why did you choose that piece for the audition?" can spiral, inside the head of the person being asked, into "I probably did everything wrong, and now everything is ruined." Similarly, "a shame" amplifies regret into a sense of despair, implying that the missed opportunity or the mistake made has closed the door on future possibilities. A remark like "it's a shame it didn't work out," for instance, can lead the person hearing it to thoughts like "I'll never succeed again."
Both words can also leave the people we're talking to feeling that their feelings aren't being fully acknowledged. I once had a friend (he's not my friend anymore, partly because of this) who, every time I told him about something dramatic that had happened to me and had stirred up uncomfortable feelings in me, would ask me "why."
Maybe he was somewhere on the spectrum, maybe he was raised by wolves, or maybe he was simply not a very nice person. Either way, his response left me feeling, again and again, dismissed and as though my emotional state was being ignored. He may have meant it as a critical observation, but experientially, the focus was on justification — or, at best, on his own need to understand — rather than on my need for empathy.
A new year is a chance to think ahead. "Why?" and "a shame" tend to hold back forward movement. What they share is a pull toward the irreversible past, an amplification of critical or catastrophic thinking, and a creation of emotional distance instead of connection — which is why I'm hoping to use them less in 2025.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




