top of page

Turning in My Grave: A Conversation About the Situation With Adam Baruch

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Mar 9, 2023
11 min read

Updated: Oct 22

"Even back then, this was television's threadbare patriotism. Patriotism that would eventually turn on the Israeli himself: once 'patriotic service' against the Palestinians is done, we'll get to the Israelis. Because service is a state of consciousness. First it'll be against the weakest Israeli, then against a weak Israeli, then against a half-weak Israeli, and so on. The moment you serve the system, you are a servant."

Given the state of things, I held a written séance and summoned my late father, Adam Baruch, for a special conversation.

Amalia: So your buddies in religious Zionism are making a real mess.

Adam Baruch: "'My buddies.' There's no single religious Zionism. From its beginnings, religious Zionism included laborers, merchants, Torah scholars, ordinary folk, city dwellers, kibbutzniks, realists, semi-messianists, avowed socialists, avowed property owners, security hawks, peaceniks, maximalists, and minimalists. Ask me, sweetheart, what's the common starting point for all of them."

Fine — what's the common starting point for all of them?

"Write this down: the common starting point for all of them, colon, the State of Israel, comma, coming after the Holocaust, comma, is the beginning of the Redemption. From there on, the methods and flavors diverge. Another shared starting point: the State of Israel must adopt, to the best of its ability, agreed-upon Jewish values. That, in a nutshell, was religious Zionism. By the way, it's a safe bet that Smotrich and Rotman don't actually miss that religious Zionism, because it was many-faced, self-reflective, and even had a genuine intellectual dimension.

"And I'd wager that even Rabbi Kook's own doctrine isn't fully known, even in the yeshivas where it's regularly taught. If you ask me why — and I imagine you are — I'd answer that it's because it underwent harsh, tendentious editing, one that skewed it toward the concrete nationalism of the Gush Emunim school, and toward an active messianism. But don't worry, God's own plan will stand."

And is that part of what enabled the pogrom the settlers carried out in Hawara?

"You're a smart girl, and I'd suggest you take a few steps back and recall that many settlers don't accept the state as sovereign, and present the very concept of 'the State of Israel' as open for debate, as non-binding, non-final — as merely one proposal available to a religious Jew in Israel. And they have grounds for that: there is no single, absolute, settled position in modern halacha and theology regarding 'the State of Israel.' There's recognition, in halacha and theology, that the state provides a Jew with security and a home, and so 'the state' is a value, a kind of dignified framework — and yet its crystalline religious dimension is denied, and it is not the sovereign. There is recognition that a Jew is well advised to keep the state's rules, while not truly assimilating into it."

For example?

"Take, for example, the core of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef's ruling on this, which directs obedience, the maintenance of order, because the state has protective value, secures the potential for Jewish life, guarantees solidarity — but in theological terms, 'the State of Israel' still isn't a religious essence. And on the other hand, there is recognition of 'the state' as the beginning of the Redemption, as a religious phenomenon. Allow me to give you an example from a contemporary text — well, a text from my own time, at least — a foundational text by Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik, unmatched in sharpening these points: 'If you ask me what Orthodoxy's approach to the State of Israel is, I can say without reservation: an entirely positive approach. For a state that saved so many Jews, that hanged Eichmann, is a state that God brought into being… (But) if we are faced with the choice: the State of Israel or the God of Israel — you know very well which we would choose. For all my love of the state, the God of Israel cannot bow the knee to it!' You wouldn't be wrong to say that folded inside all this is the fact that the settlers have appropriated Jewishness for themselves."

And is that what they're doing?

"Good question. The answer is 'yes, but.' Yes, but no one owns Jewishness. There is no single spiritual interpretation of the concept 'Jew.' Whoever appropriates the concept for themselves narrows it, strips it of its spirit and its strength. There is nothing in Jewish law that instructs you to be right-wing or left-wing, capitalist or socialist. And if one must choose, one could choose the view that if the Jew is an agent of divine grace in the world, then the Jew is also 'the other,' the one cast out, whoever that may be."

Okay, that was sixty seconds on the settlers and religious Zionism, as they say. What do you make of the way the police are behaving toward the protesters?

"Let me tell you about something that happened twenty years ago. The police issued an order requiring Yedioth Ahronoth to hand over photographs from right-wing demonstrations at the time, in order to identify activists at the protests. The paper refused. And I thought the paper was right. A newspaper is not an arm of the police. We're a democracy. Only when the state is altogether unable to act to prevent a crime is it right to even entertain such a demand. Only then. And that wasn't the case then. As of today, a dubious relationship between the police and the media has been deepening for thirty years now. Both sides benefit. But the very definitions — 'police' and 'media' — blur. And then what? A law of nature: the moment the relationship turns dubious, nothing is guaranteed anymore. The independence of the media is no longer guaranteed. And tomorrow some righteous-sounding, patriotic-sounding bill will be introduced, requiring the media to assist the police, in the name of the good of the people and the state."

You said "both sides benefit" — meaning the corruption doesn't only come from the government's direction. The media is complicit.

"You know, Amalia, back in my day, once a week the military correspondent would come on and tell us, say, that a senior Islamic Jihad figure had been eliminated that week in Jenin, and he, the military correspondent, would reveal to us that the man had been a ticking bomb, and so on. But even then it was clear, from where I stood, that it was entirely possible the military correspondent hadn't known a single thing about the eliminated figure until a minute before airtime. It's possible the military correspondent was, in fact, reading us a text written for him by the system. Israel's own primer. Television in service of the system.

"And if that's so, then even back then, this was television's threadbare patriotism. Patriotism that would eventually turn on the Israeli himself: once 'patriotic service' against the Palestinians is done, we'll get to the Israelis. Because service is a state of consciousness. First it'll be against the weakest Israeli, then against a weak Israeli, then against a half-weak Israeli, and so on. The moment you serve the system, you are a servant."

So what happens now?

"So let's hope that the employment contracts of news editors, in television and on news sites, don't include a cash bonus for a ratings bump. Why? Because that invites tabloid news, sloppier, more violent, more seductive. Ratings, after all, don't rise when the news is deeper, more responsible."

Turning in My Grave: A Conversation About the Situation With Adam Baruch - illustration

And what do you make of the protests?

Adam Baruch: "I'm about to disappoint you, sweetheart. The interesting thing, from where I'm standing up here, is that we have a different geography, and from up here I can see that the protests aren't only outside the government compound, and it's no accident they're on Kaplan Street. To a great extent, the protests are facing the Azrieli Towers, and facing the Ayalon Highway."

Meaning?

"Television, all the television stations, film 'Tel Aviv by night' as though the whole city were just two or three highways and the Azrieli Towers. That's how they film Seoul, too, or the new Bosnia. Highways and lit-up office towers. At night, the whole world becomes one: highways and office towers. The highways represent fast transportation, which represents energy and progress, and the towers represent power and modernism. But what's underneath the towers, above the Ayalon? What's happening in Tel Aviv one meter below the towers, next to the Ayalon?

"Poverty is happening. Unemployment, blank staring, psychological wandering, neglect. What's under the towers? Hundreds of thousands of human beings the economy has made invisible. So what are the towers, if not a false promise? If not our era's golden calf? So what are the towers, if not a black box recording Israel's true signs of the times? And sometimes, at night, reflected on the television screen, the towers, if you look closely enough, will start to look to you like giant tombstones. The protesters are demonstrating in front of the Azrieli Towers, and blocking the Ayalon, in part because the towers and the highways represent the false promise of progress and modernism."

What else is coming that we're struggling to imagine?

"A video will reach you. No one will be able to stop it anymore. A video calling for Yigal Amir's release, made professionally and tailored to local conditions and to the population here. The recording will be blunt, fully comprehensible, slanted, emotional, graphic, presented as a 'legitimate media product,' speaking in an Israeli idiom, somewhat cinematic, creating the sense that it represents many people, that it is writing history, that it 'seeks justice,' leaning on a slack collective memory and on the presumed impatience of a public whose head and heart are no longer really 'there' — meaning, with the Rabin assassination. It will argue for a 'new reading' of the circumstances, the facts, the history.

"The Oslo Accords, and Rabin's supposed disregard for those protesting the agreement, will be presented as the soil in which the assassination took root. The singer Ariel Zilber will lend the recording some of his popular credibility. Rumor has it the effort is timed for the coming Passover — the holiday of freedom. It's a safe bet that not everyone who watches this video will be repulsed by it. It won't be instinctively branded an 'abomination.' It will be accepted as part of a natural process. Because between all the spin, people here can no longer tell day from night. Especially since no one wants to come across as a conservative, or an anti-democrat, dismissing the video out of hand. Netanyahu won't manage to stop its spread.

"Some viewers will change their position on Amir and 'all of that.' Some will nonetheless discuss it, privately or in society. Concepts like 'Jewish grace,' 'remorse,' 'atonement,' 'forgiveness,' 'appeasement,' 'deterrence,' or 'national unity' will all be tossed together in these discussions. As will greasy, cunning patriotism. As will half-baked, quasi-religious ideas. And even intellectuals are likely to contribute their share of garbage to the discussion of Yigal Amir's release. And that will be quite the discussion."

Is there still such a thing as public discourse in Israel?

Adam Baruch: "You're right that no one controls Israeli public discourse anymore. There's no longer any hegemony in the realm of public discourse, culture, ethics. S. Yizhar is gone. Yitzhak Ben-Aharon is gone. Leibowitz is gone. Ben Shlomo is gone. Rabbi Shach, too, is gone. Yehoshua and Oz were already, in their time, seen as 'spokesmen for.' And it seems to me that I, too, haven't really been 'here' for more than fifteen years. The public discussion over 'Amir' may well develop into the cruelest mirror held up to our faces in recent years. What will we see in that mirror? Raw, unprocessed impulses, self-righteousness, legal ignorance, fundamentalism, crippled citizenship, incitement, cynicism, consuming nationalism. We'll see ourselves, more or less, as we actually are. The release of Palestinian prisoners will strengthen those demanding Amir's release. Will he be released under pressure from public opinion? And if so, when?"

What, for now, is blocking the idea of releasing Yigal Amir? Memory?

"Sweetheart, there's more than one kind of memory. Which memory needs to be activated to prevent Yigal Amir's release? On paper, the education system is responsible for 'Rabin's memory,' as are the government and the Knesset, whatever they are, and certainly every citizen, whoever they are. But that isn't happening. The memory is shrinking. Israeli memory is being brutally edited by a general 'appetite for life' — a purely material appetite, soulless, compulsive, physical, an appetite manufactured by the idolatry of money. An appetite that erases facts, memories, and difficulties. What gets remembered? Mainly whatever serves capital, the new economy, the appetite for life — that's what gets remembered. Israeli memory is being adapted to globalization, arranging itself into synthetic little cubes, described as material that's no longer fertile, and its own receivers dispose of anything unusual, of nuance, of 'problems.' The day is drawing near when Yigal Amir will be released under pressure from public opinion. There will be those who say, then, that this release is 'a distinctly Jewish act.'"

So the reform goes far beyond a judicial reform?

"On the one hand, it's clear that a legal coup driven mainly by political and religious motives breeds disaster: an anarchy that will end up shredding Israeli society. But that 'clear' isn't so clear to everyone. There are among us 'many good people' who think otherwise. Many good, loyal, patriotic people who hope that this judicial revolution, this big bang, will spark a new discussion about our inner essence, the essence of the army, the very hold on the territories, the return of territories, the essence of Israeli sovereignty — Torah or democracy — the political force of the militant rabbinic core. In other words, there are those who hope the legal revolution will produce a rupture; that the reform will sow processes of retreat; there are those who hope to be reborn as a nation through that very rupture. As far as they're concerned, the reform is a brave, cohesive, stirring, purifying move. As far as they're concerned, the reform is the illumination of a great, radiant awareness.

"I know people for whom that is the hope. For years I grew up among them, in religious Zionism, in the hesder yeshivas, in Bnei Akiva. I will always feel a kinship of spirit and soul with them. May they rise ever higher. But I also know the rabbinic power structures — meaning the way decisions get made, the rhetoric, and also some of the motives, which are at times somewhat hidden, and at times mostly about power. Some of these rabbis failed over the Gaza disengagement and racked up other failures along the way as well. And now, the legal revolution is, on their part, a post-traumatic act. A psychological act. Psychology. It has nothing real to do with the Torah. It has to do with the trauma of the Gaza disengagement, both as substance and as a site of memory, and with the political processes in Israel — Olmert, Barak, Bennett, Lapid.

"These rabbis are now reacting like wounded people. Not like great Torah scholars. And by inciting their own voters, they are producing a political and religious illusion, one that God forbid will end in rupture within their own camp. Already 'tomorrow' these rabbis' political powerlessness will be exposed, and, God forbid, their private and collective delusion will be revealed for what it is — as though they were the exclusive representatives of the Holy One, and the exclusive representatives of Jewish history, and as though it were within their power and wisdom to produce an alternative to the army, to the government, to democracy, to global processes. That said, it's clear that this refusal is also born from the fact that we are a distinctly sectorial society, one with more than a single source of authority. That sectorialism wasn't created only by the right and the ultra-Orthodox, but by secular Israelis too — or more precisely, by the elite of secular Zionism, which found it convenient, for decades, to treat minorities as raw material, as a bloc — the religious, the Arabs — and to isolate the right."

Okay. Thank you, Dad. I miss you.

"You miss me? Do you have any idea how much I miss you?"

All the text here is drawn from the book "Adam Baruch: Communication" and from the "Friday" column that ran in the newspaper Ma'ariv.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page