Think You Know How to Listen? Think Again
Updated: Oct 22
Contrary to the clichés about psychologists, active listening is a complex and sophisticated skill that can serve us in many areas of life. First in a series on active listening
Every so often we're asked to listen to someone who is in distress or embarrassment. It might be our teenage son, our partner, a colleague or a good friend who opens a conversation that on the surface sounds like a request for help but is actually something more serious. In such cases, ideal listening helps the speaker understand themselves. Carl Rogers, the seminal American psychologist and father of the humanistic approach to therapy, laid down several critical principles for this kind of listening.
The first principle is called "the listener's orientation." It means that when we listen to a person who is trying to understand themselves, our starting point should be that the speaker has the capacity to develop insight and solve their own problems, and that they possess a potential for growth and development. In other words, the central question I as a listener should ask myself in such conversations is: "How does the person in front of me see themselves and their situation?" Note that this is very different from the questions that usually guide our listening: "What can I do for this person?" or, a variation that's no more elevated: "How do I see this person?"
The listener's orientation is the basis for empathic listening. That is, as a listener I try to understand the person speaking to me against the backdrop of their inner world and in light of their view of life. I try not to understand them on the basis of a theory I have about the specific issue they're dealing with, my own set of values, or my personal tastes and preferences. I try to stand in their shoes and see the world from their point of view.
What good does that do? After all, you might think that people who come to us asking for help would really benefit from guidance, an opinion, or having us illuminate the blind spots in their field of vision. It doesn't always work that way. But according to Rogers (and in my personal experience, though most of the time I fail at it), when a listener makes the effort to listen deeply and accurately, and doesn't let their judgmentalism cloud the listening, they give the speaker the chance to understand the meaning of what they're saying, and give them the courage, the inspiration and the safe space to embark on a deeper exploration of their problems.

Okay, so let's say you're convinced. But what's so complicated about it? Why devote a whole column (and then some) to it? The answer is that it's very hard to listen truly empathically. The urge to advise, to share our life experience, to agree or argue with things because they match or contradict our own point of view, is deeply human, and after all, we're only human.
It's hard for us to imagine that even when we express agreement with the speaker, we still, in some way, diminish their sense that we accept them unconditionally. Once you think about it, it's easier to understand why, when we argue with our conversation partner's point of view, they feel a lack of acceptance. But think about it: even agreeing with the ideas the speaker expresses communicates the existence of an underlying set of values.
The aim of this kind of listening is to help the speaker be in the least scripted state possible, because only then can they explore hidden aspects of themselves and of the situation they're in. That's why it's important to accept them unconditionally. Agreement means conditions, and we must avoid both agreeing with and objecting to what the speaker brings.
Another point Rogers sharpened is the importance of openness and honesty on our part, as listeners. When we listen to someone deeply, we bear a responsibility to be aware of our own emotional state at that moment. Am I angry? Does the subject being discussed make me anxious? If I think it's unprofessional of me to be emotionally triggered by content my client brings, and I deal with that feeling by pretending I'm not triggered, or by telling myself I'm not supposed to be triggered because I must accept my client unconditionally, then my attempt to listen will fail. Honesty in the listener elicits honesty in the speaker, and concealment by the listener leads to concealment by the speaker.
It's easy to see that the principle of unconditional acceptance can conflict with the principle of honesty. In such cases it's worth remembering that we don't really have a choice: we can't be empathic until we do our own inner work of clarification and process the points at which the subject or the speaker triggers us.
That's because active listening is judged not only by whether the listener tunes in to the speaker in the right way and listens empathically, offers unconditional sympathy, and brings themselves honestly and openly into the conversation. In the end, what counts is that the speaker feels they've received listening that has all these qualities. The proof of the pudding is in the eating, as they say, and what that means is the test of results: if by the end of the conversation the speaker has come to understand themselves better, and is aware of what they're going through, what they want and what they need, it seems you've listened to them in the deep way we've been describing.
Incidentally, real empathy is also tested by the fact that we aren't fanatical in sticking to these principles. That is, if the person talking to us truly needs advice, it wouldn't be empathic to say, "I hear that you really need advice," because obviously, sometimes the most empathic thing to do is simply to give the advice.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



