top of page

The Wealth Trap: Why Unlimited Options Aren't Good for the Psyche

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jun 1, 2023
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

If every time one door closes, an invisible hand opens another one for us, we struggle to develop the resilience needed to face the kinds of failure money can't prevent. It's no wonder rich kids often struggle to find their way, drifting between careers and partners and disappointing everyone. What can we learn from this?

I recently finished watching the second season of "The White Lotus," and like a good viewer, by the end I found myself thanking God that I'm not very rich. Shows like "The White Lotus" and "Succession," which just wrapped its fourth and final season, offer a striking illustration of the fact that, for human beings, too many options are not psychologically optimal.

This becomes even more apparent when we look at the wealthy, the children of the wealthy, and certainly the wealthy children of the wealthy — people who often have access to a wide range of opportunities and resources thanks to their family's financial means.

As these prominent works of popular culture demonstrate, the idea of endless possibilities is deeply appealing, but in practice it can lead to negative outcomes such as a lack of psychological resilience, difficulty making decisions, a sense of entitlement (which causes suffering for the people around them too), a lack of purpose, pressure, and unrealistic expectations.

When the options in front of us are unlimited, we miss out on the chance to experience failure. That might sound wonderful, but it has consequences. If every time one door closes, an invisible hand opens another one for us, we struggle to develop the resilience needed to cope with the kinds of failure that money can't prevent (because all of us, at some point, will struggle with something, get hurt by something, or simply grow old). On top of that, an abundance of options can encourage indecisiveness and a tendency toward procrastination, both of which can delay a person's growth and personal development.

And as I mentioned, unlimited options can foster a sense of entitlement. Children who grow up surrounded by great privilege may come to believe they have a birthright to endless opportunities, without needing to work for them or prove they deserve them. This can affect their work ethic and their relationships with others. That's why it's not uncommon to find children of wealthy families living without a sense of purpose or direction, hopping between different activities and pursuits without ever truly committing to any of them.

The paradox, of course, is that this hopping around sounds fun — but it happens against a backdrop of internal, family, and social expectation to squeeze the maximum out of every opportunity and possibility. That tension can create enormous pressure and can also show up as mental health problems. After all, no one can truly excel in many fields at once, and precisely when it seems like you've been given every condition needed to realize your full potential, that very fact can end up lowering your self-image.

The notion that you can endlessly optimize yourself and your choices dovetails with the era's general FOMO, reinforcing the belief that there's always something better than what you currently have: a better party to be at, a more desirable partner to date, a better city to live in, a more prestigious profession to pursue, and so on.

Why needing to earn a living contributes to our well-being

Children of the wealthy are admittedly a very small subpopulation, but I'm writing about them because they let us see clearly why our need to work for a living — a need that supposedly limits us — actually contributes to our psychological well-being.

When we need to support ourselves, we make decisions that directly affect our survival and well-being, which strengthens our sense of autonomy and competence. The need to earn a living helps us focus our needs and organize our priorities, which reduces the number of choices we have to make and simplifies our decision-making process.

When we earn our own money and manage the resources available to us, we're able to properly appreciate the experiences we create for ourselves, which leads to a greater sense of satisfaction and gratitude (this brings to mind a singer I know, who always points out how an audience that paid for its own tickets enjoys the show more easily than an audience that received tickets as a gift from an employer).

And in general, the need to earn a living often leads to setting clear financial and personal goals: paying off a mortgage, traveling abroad, enrolling a child in a private preschool, saving for retirement, replacing a car — or getting promoted at work, moving to a better job, or pursuing another academic degree. On top of that, the need to support ourselves often forces us to acquire new skills — whether it's sticking to a budget, cooking skills, or skills specific to a particular job.

The Wealth Trap: Why Unlimited Options Aren't Good for the Psyche - illustration

The paradox of choice

So far I've been talking about money, but the broader point is that having or lacking money is simply one illustration of having many options or having few. And although it runs a bit counter to intuition, too many options — in almost every area of life — are actually a drawback rather than an advantage.

The American psychologist Barry Schwartz wrote extensively about the idea of the "paradox of choice": when people face too many options, that abundance actually makes it harder for them to decide. The need to weigh the pros and cons of every potential option can lead to delay, to procrastination, and ultimately to phenomena known as "decision paralysis" and "decision fatigue."

A famous experiment conducted in 2000 by two researchers from Columbia and Stanford Universities demonstrated this using jam: on one day, they set up a table at a local supermarket with 24 kinds of jam, and on another day, with only six kinds. The experiment showed that customers asked to choose from six kinds of jam tended to buy one, while customers asked to choose from 24 kinds tended to get confused, give up, and not buy any jam at all.

Between the rich kids in shows like "Succession" and "The White Lotus" and the woman in the supermarket choosing a jar of jam, there's a wide spectrum of different choices at different budgets, but one point in common: the more alternatives we face, the greater the chance we'll end up feeling regret and dissatisfaction.

The ability to second-guess a decision we've made and keep wondering whether we chose correctly works against us. An abundance of choices can create the illusion that a perfect option exists somewhere, and accordingly can produce a sense of disappointment with any choice that turns out to be less than perfect.

The power of limitations

By contrast, a certain degree of constraints that limit the number of options available to us can actually encourage us to think more deeply and creatively about how we want to use the resources available to us in order to achieve our goals.

Sometimes it seems to me that artists understand better than anyone that imposing limitations on themselves — ones that force them out of their comfort zone — can awaken their ability to think in new ways and arrive at innovative solutions.

A few classic examples: Ernest Hemingway, who according to legend made a bet with friends that he could write the shortest short story in the world, and produced "For sale: baby shoes, never worn"; Pablo Picasso and his Blue Period, during which he painted only in shades of blue and blue-green; and the bet between Dr. Seuss and his publisher over whether he could write an entire book using only 50 words, which produced "Green Eggs and Ham." And there are plenty more examples of budget, technology, and expressive constraints that artists were required to, or chose to, work within — and which led them to great achievements.

Of course, I won't end this piece without stressing that I'm not glorifying poverty, servitude, or a lack of political freedom. Quite the opposite. We clearly all need a sense of control over our lives — it's a basic psychological need. All the more so, restricting educational, employment, health, consumer, and of course political opportunities for certain groups of people but not for others is an unfair and inequitable move that can, and should, lead to political tension and conflict.

But once we've secured basic human and civil rights, further up the hierarchy of needs, more options aren't necessarily better for us.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page