The VIP Is Me: Why Does It Matter So Much to Us to Feel Important?
Updated: Oct 22
Social importance is a hidden human drive most of us won't admit to. How can recognizing another person's need (and our own) to feel "important" pull a relationship out of a passive-aggressive spiral?
Naomi, a 29-year-old product manager (all names and identifying details in this piece have been changed), was trying to make sense of a paradox: when she let her partner, Shira, off the hook from joining her at work events, Shira was thrilled. But when she gave her a "pass" on hanging out with friends Shira didn't particularly like, Shira was deeply hurt. Why would the exact same move — excusing her from participating — get such wildly different reactions?
A similar puzzle occupied Dana, a 43-year-old event producer, regarding Itzik, her ex-husband. He struggled with managing his time with the kids and complained about it to Dana. Dana jumped in to help, walked him through solutions, and even handled some of the problems herself — but Itzik kept getting angrier anyway.
Michal, a 36-year-old HR manager, had a similar struggle accepting that her in-laws preferred helping her husband's brother care for his one child, rather than helping her with her own twins. Her frustration only grew in the face of her brother-in-law's helplessness, which pushed her into overfunctioning, and she couldn't understand why the grandparents didn't split their help more equally.
The evolution of importance
These three cases reveal a shared pattern: a large part of the frustration Naomi, Dana and Michal experienced stemmed from their blindness to the other side's — the partner's, the ex-husband's, the in-laws' — deep need to feel important.
The need to feel important is deeply rooted in our brains, which still reflect the way our distant ancestors lived. Naomi's, Dana's and Michal's ancient foremothers lived in small, tight-knit groups, where an individual's importance to the group, and the value they contributed to it, were critical to their survival. Without status as a useful, important member, a person faced an existential risk. With no currency and no portable skills, there was no option to simply go try their luck somewhere else. For that reason, we've remained sensitive to signals from the people close to us about how important we are to them — even when we don't depend on them to the same degree we once did.
The seriousness of importance
Dale Carnegie, whom I've already mentioned in previous columns, emphasizes that people's need to feel important is one of the most powerful driving forces in human behavior. In his famous book How to Win Friends and Influence People, he argues that the feeling of importance is everyone's secret craving, and that we strive to attain it in nearly every social interaction. Carnegie warns that dismissing someone else's sense of importance can lead to feelings of hurt and anger.
If we examine these three cases from that angle, the following picture emerges: in their interactions with their family members, Naomi, Dana and Michal all overlooked the other person's need to feel important — and that oversight is what caused much of the frustration and misunderstanding that followed. Let's look at the examples.
The unimportant girlfriend
In Naomi and Shira's case, Naomi thought Shira was reacting inconsistently. But if we examine things from the standpoint of Shira's sense of importance, we find there's no contradiction at all between her reactions. Shira felt content when Naomi skipped her own participation in work events, because in those moments she felt Naomi was honoring her need for personal space or time alone.
But when it came to hangouts with friends Shira didn't like, being excused was experienced differently. Instead of feeling respected, Shira felt rejected and unimportant. Shira experienced the situation as if Naomi was choosing her friends over her, which struck directly at her sense of importance.
The diminishing partner
In Dana and Itzik's case, Dana thought she was helping Itzik by taking on part of the burden of caring for the kids and explaining to him how to handle things. She believed that if he saw he was taking parenting issues far too seriously, it would ease his load. So she kept demonstrating, again and again, how he could "let go" and "move forward." But from his point of view, her behavior kept diminishing him, over and over, because it sent him the message that he was weak, childish, and overreacting.
What's more, on the occasions he did listen to her, or let her take the reins, the problem might have gotten solved — but a side effect of that solution was that Itzik felt she'd robbed him of the chance to feel like a competent parent who could handle things on his own. Itzik felt humiliated and worthless, instead of feeling that Dana was supporting him.
The scolded parents
In Michal's case with her in-laws, Michal wanted fair, equal treatment from them, but they saw the other brother as the one who needed them more, so they focused their attention on him. That support for the other brother looked excessive to Michal, because she didn't understand the hidden motivation at work: the other brother was feeding the parents' need to feel important, while Michal's constant criticism produced the opposite effect — it made them feel judged and scolded.

A circle with no magic in it
In every one of these examples, ignoring the other side's need to feel important didn't just fail to solve the problem — it made it worse. In practice, a negative loop formed, as Naomi, Dana and Michal each repeated their own behavior over and over, and instead of resolving the situation, that behavior only damaged the other side's sense of worth and deepened the conflict.
When Naomi excused Shira from hanging out with friends she didn't like, she probably thought she was doing something helpful — giving Shira a break, or sparing her some unpleasantness. But in reality, Shira felt less important to Naomi, as if Naomi's friends came before her in the order of priorities. That excusal, instead of easing things, was experienced as exclusion, or as rejection. The more sulky and resentful Shira became, the less Naomi wanted to include her when hanging out with her own friends. And there's the loop.
Dana thought her help would solve Itzik's problems. She kept explaining to him, again and again, how to manage his time and the challenges tied to the kids, and even took on tasks in his place. But in doing so, she was actually signaling to him that he wasn't good enough, or wasn't capable of coping on his own.
The more Dana kept "solving" his problems for him, the less important Itzik felt as a parent and as an independent person — and as a result, his complaints about the kids grew, and his tendency to dramatize the challenges and present them as unsolvable got worse. The more helplessness and displeasure he showed, the more omnipotence Dana displayed in return, along with a growing feeling that she was being taken advantage of — and that was their own negative loop.
Michal, hurt by the preference her in-laws showed her husband's brother, kept expressing her disappointment over their behavior, and expected them to act more equally. But the more she emphasized her frustration and the inequality she felt, the more she was actually undermining their own sense of importance. The parents, in response, felt attacked or misunderstood, and doubled down on their involvement with the other brother in order to feel more significant.
In each of these cases, trying to solve the problem without understanding the other side's need to feel important only made things worse. Every action taken with good intentions — excusing Shira, helping Itzik, or criticizing the in-laws — actually sent the opposite message: "you're not important enough." And so each side sank deeper into a pattern of mutual hurt and misunderstanding.
Once Naomi, Dana and Michal began to deeply understand the other side's need to feel important, they started changing the way they acted. Naomi began reminding Shira how important she was to her, even in moments when she chose to spend time without her rather than skip a hangout with friends Shira didn't like. She could tell her something more like, "I'd love it if you came and had fun with us, but I know you're not crazy about [this or that], so I figured you'd have more fun doing something else during that time."
Dana stopped meeting Itzik's difficulties with "diminishing positivity," and started giving more weight to how heavy his feelings around the challenges with the kids really were (without, of course, validating his reality-testing or his particular way of intervening). Where before she might have joked when he spoke with dread about their approaching adolescence, she started responding more seriously, saying things like, "Of course you're worried — we have strong-willed kids, and we're going to need both luck and good sense to get through this stage."
Once Michal recognized the sense of importance her in-laws drew from helping the other brother, she started expressing her own need in a way that reinforced their importance in her eyes: "I understand how much you support him, and that's really impressive. I need your help too, and I appreciate anything, even small, that you're able to do." She also started consulting her father-in-law and mother-in-law on matters where they had relevant expertise — a move that ended up strengthening the relationship.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




