top of page

The Undercover Agent: The Famous Narcissist's Lesser-Known Sibling

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
May 9, 2024
9 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Most of us have heard of narcissistic personality disorder, and we enjoy spotting the type in people around us, public or private. But there's another kind of narcissist — one that's much harder to recognize

Dor (names in this piece have been changed), 41, is a successful startup founder who cashed out on an exit and then launched an investment fund whose stated mission is to reduce suffering in the world. Oron, 52, is a successful, beloved cardiologist who serves as the go-to guru for everyone he knows, for anything from the smallest decision to their medical problems. Mikey, 34, is a volunteer who devotes much of his time to helping animals and children from families in need.

Dor, Oron, and Mikey are men who give a great deal to their communities, and plenty of people would sing their praises. What's less well known about them is that each one has left behind a trail of hurt partners who feel these men deceived them and caused them profound harm — emotionally, at times financially, and in some sense physically as well.

What's more, although each of them has a devoted following of admirers, none of them has close friends or meaningful intimate relationships in which he isn't cast as the savior or the boss. As I understand it, all three suffer from a form of moralistic narcissism — which we might think of as covert narcissism.

The narcissist you don't recognize

The concept of covert or hidden narcissism is used in the professional literature and refers to a subtype of narcissistic personality disorder that is entirely different from the classic, overt presentation of narcissism associated with politicians like Netanyahu or Trump.

Where the overt narcissist is characterized by grandiosity, an inflated sense of self-importance, a sense of entitlement, and a clearly controlling or aggressive approach, the covert narcissist is more in touch with his own low self-esteem, and doesn't get to enjoy the classic narcissistic defense that grants a naive faith in his own superiority.

Covert narcissists tend to be more introverted, and may even come across as shy or withdrawn. They are exquisitely sensitive to how others perceive them, they have an intense need for recognition and appreciation, but they're also quick to feel rejected or hurt. At the same time, even though their sense of entitlement is less visible, covert narcissists are just as convinced that they deserve special treatment — they simply tend to express that belief indirectly and less bluntly.

Where an overt narcissist will openly belittle other people's worth, covert narcissists don't necessarily reveal those feelings, but instead tend to harbor resentment and envy toward others who are getting the attention or success they themselves crave. Where overt narcissists display direct aggression, covert ones use passive aggression to express their dissatisfaction or anger, and they're also more prone to symptoms of depression and anxiety.

The hallmark: a belief in moral superiority

Dor, Oron, and Mikey represent, to my mind, a subtype of covert narcissism — somewhat distinct from the one described in the literature. Its distinguishing feature, as noted, is the moralistic emphasis, and even though it has no formal definition, I think it's worth discussing.

At the heart of it lies an inflated sense of moral superiority, paired with a hidden strategy for obtaining admiration and validation that will compensate for a basic sense of inferiority. Their belief in their own superior moral standing shows up as a conviction that they are simply better than other people, and it surfaces both in their interactions with others and in their decision-making.

They tend to spend a lot of time morally judging other people's behavior, and frequently present themselves as models of correct, upright conduct (if you suspect you're in a relationship with someone like this, all you need to do is watch how he reacts when you accuse him of behaving badly).

Unlike overt narcissists, who typically demand admiration openly, moralistic narcissists quietly seek validation for their moral superiority and their good deeds. They're highly sensitive to how others perceive them and may go to great lengths to appear kind or to seem driven by altruistic motives. This dependence on external validation is a crucial part of their narcissism, because it feeds directly into their sense of self-worth.

Paradoxically, their self-image comes paired with a tendency toward deception and dishonesty. To maintain their moral facade and secure ongoing admiration, moralistic narcissists may lie or scatter promises that don't line up with their actual wishes or abilities.

Damage to the psyche and to relationships

Mikey, for example, carried on an intense, long-running affair with a woman he apparently fell in love with. But because he wanted validation for being both morally superior and a charming guy — validation he sought from both the mistress and his official partner — he found himself making contradictory promises to each of them, which drove him deeper and deeper into betrayal.

The more Mikey tried to navigate the dilemmas he'd created for himself, the further his actions strayed from his own stated values. In the end, one day he declared to his lover that he would always be there for her — and two hours later went back to his official partner, telling her he'd fallen prey to an obsessive admirer he'd taken pity on, and asking for her forgiveness and understanding.

To reduce the cognitive dissonance between their self-image and their actual conduct, moralistic narcissists like Mikey may rationalize their behavior or minimize its effects on others, thereby preserving their sense of moral integrity. Still, this internal struggle can produce real psychological distress, showing up as anxiety, guilt, or depression — especially when circumstances threaten to expose their true behavior.

It's easy to understand why a pattern like this does so much damage to interpersonal relationships. When relationships are run according to a utilitarian calculation of the sense of moral superiority or the reputation they confer, and are paired with dishonesty and a lack of genuine empathy, relationships with others become unstable and shallow, and can cause emotional harm to both parties.

The Undercover Agent: The Famous Narcissist's Lesser-Known Sibling - illustration

External validation and manipulating circumstances

Like their fellow narcissists, moralistic narcissists too often feel invisible, alone, and unappreciated. Their inflated sense of moral superiority, and their ongoing drive to be seen by others as kind and wonderful, serve as a shield against the painful feelings they carry inside. By positioning themselves as morally superior and constantly seeking outside validation for it, they build a narrative in which they are not only seen (as opposed to invisible), but also essential (as opposed to insignificant), and exemplary (as opposed to flawed).

Where overt narcissists rely on grandiosity — money, power, status — to display their superiority, and are therefore also at greater risk of ethical (and even legal) exposure, moralistic narcissists keep a safe distance from criticism and judgment. They go to great lengths to avoid ever being seen as morally unfit, which makes it much harder for their victims to question their motives or actions without appearing immoral themselves.

External validation of their superiority isn't just a wish for them — it's a necessity. But because it's moral superiority we're talking about, the mechanism by which they demand these reinforcements is less aggressive, and they tend instead to rely on manipulative charm and performed kindness to fill that need.

Dor, for instance, would never be bluntly condescending or openly dismiss his partner's feelings or needs. But in practice, he has spent years shamelessly wasting her fertile years while ostensibly devoting himself to searching for a diagnosis, treatment, or cure for her emotional problems — which, in his telling, are the central issue in the relationship. In other words, like other moralists, Dor manipulates the circumstances to ensure he continues to be seen as morally praiseworthy.

Covert distance

The focus on preserving an image of moral superiority and likability also damages relationships because it prevents the moral narcissist from showing the genuine vulnerability that's essential to deep connection. Oron, for instance, has plenty of friends — supposedly. In practice, they all either work for him or are financially supported by him.

Many people sense his covert distance, and in hindsight report that they never felt they truly knew him. But of course, the real trouble starts once the lies come to light: when Oron's wife discovered that he had drained the family's finances to fund his friends' outings and their failing business ventures, the sense of betrayal she felt led — justifiably — to a crisis in the marriage.

Dor, Oron, and Mikey tend to avoid conflict more than overt narcissists do. All three often maintain a facade of humility, moral superiority, or victimhood. That's because open confrontation risks exposing their less flattering traits and behaviors — manipulativeness, deception, or a need for control.

After Mikey told his official girlfriend that he'd slept with the woman he'd had the affair with ("just twice," "with a condom," he falsely emphasized to his girlfriend), he gave his girlfriend the ex-lover's phone number and arranged things so that she would be the one to text her, effectively ending the relationship on his behalf. A direct confrontation with his lover might have exposed Mikey's real agenda and undermined the carefully curated image he presents to the world.

Dor, too, tends toward "cowardly" behaviors and passive aggression, which let him avoid direct confrontation and preserve his self-image as a victim, a righteous man who's been wronged. Every time his ex tried to confront him about his avoidance of commitment, Dor would cut the conversation short, leave town, go off to be alone, or bury himself in work. Avoiding direct conflict allows people like Dor and Oron to keep manipulating the circumstances over time.

When your partner is a covert narcissist

It's easy to start understanding why it's so especially hard for the partners of covert narcissists (and perhaps for their therapists too, in cases where the couple ends up in couples therapy) to identify the problem they're dealing with in the relationship. I'm focusing on men this time, because my clinical impression is that this presentation is more common among men, though there's no reason it couldn't occur among women too.

Overt narcissists are fairly easy to spot. People like Netanyahu and Trump display blatant self-centeredness, grandiosity, and a sense of entitlement. But the moralistic narcissism of Dor, Oron, and Mikey is disguised under a coating of humility and kindness, as they frame their interactions with others by positioning themselves as morally superior or as victims — which can confuse the people around them.

Even Dor's own therapist saw him, at the start of treatment, as an especially moral individual, someone ultimately more likely to be wronged by others than to wrong them. The moralistic facade is particularly effective precisely because it appeals to the other person's empathy and moral values, making it hard for them to question the narcissist's motives without feeling guilty or cynical themselves.

Because Mikey's treatment of his official girlfriend was always explained away in moral terms, it took the woman he was having the affair with a long time to recognize his manipulative patterns. In Dor's case too, his supposed search for a cure to his partner's emotional struggles was interpreted by her as devotion and intense involvement, rather than as an expression of a need for control that served his own self-image. And since Oron needed constant validation from the people close to him, his former partner spent years feeling appreciated and needed, without understanding just how distorted and toxic the relationship really was.

Mikey blamed his official girlfriend for his own inability to fully commit to the affair, and then flipped the story, turning his lover into the one to blame for the conflict that arose between him and his partner. He positioned himself as the perpetual victim of circumstance or of other people's actions, which obscured the real root of the problems in both relationships and led both women to believe that external changes or more favorable circumstances were what could improve things.

All of this adds up to why it's especially hard to leave a moralistic narcissist. Their partners may be bonded to them psychologically at a deep level and feel a distorted sense of loyalty and commitment toward them. Untangling this kind of manipulation can be confusing and can produce significant cognitive dissonance, since the partner now has to re-evaluate not just the relationship, but her entire value system.

Recognizing the covert toxicity too

What all these cases have in common is that the manipulations and negative behaviors of moralistic narcissists are much harder to identify as abusive and toxic, certainly compared with those of overt narcissists. It typically takes partners much longer to recognize that their guilt, their unmet emotional needs, and their self-doubt are the result of one-sided manipulation, rather than legitimate — if unpleasant — outcomes of the normal dynamics within a relationship.

Dor, Oron, and Mikey's partners have something in common. All three suffer from a high level of anxiety and a considerable sense of inadequacy, which makes them especially vulnerable to the seduction and manipulative tactics of moralistic narcissists.

Dor, Oron, and Mikey embody a subtle but destructive presentation of covert moralistic narcissism, rooted in an exaggerated sense of moral superiority. Despite their public persona as altruistic leaders, they live complicated private lives characterized by causing emotional — and at times physical — harm to their close partners.

This moralistic narcissism is a defense that compensates for a deep and often denied sense of worthlessness, loneliness, and insignificance through the pursuit of external admiration and a facade of super-ethical behavior. In reality, though, they weave for themselves a web of broken promises, deception, and manipulation. Their stories highlight the profound impact moralistic narcissism can have on interpersonal relationships, and illustrate the disconnect that can exist between an exemplary public image and harmful conduct in intimate life — a disconnect that is difficult to recognize, and even harder to confront.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page