The Trouble With Kitsch: Why Does the Left Struggle to Love What the Psyche Actually Wants?
Updated: Oct 22
Why the right embraces sentimentality and emotional imagery — and what the left loses by refusing to
"All art is propaganda; on the other hand, not all propaganda is art." (George Orwell)
A friend recently sent me a powerful, moving anti-war poem. Too powerful and moving, actually, for my taste. The poem argued that our children's lives matter more than our leaders' lives, that we have no children to spare for unnecessary wars, and that whoever wants to die for a patch of land is welcome to, so long as they leave the rest of us out of it. And when the poet writes "us," she means all of us — including Palestinian mothers (shhh, don't tell anyone). The poem struck me as kitsch, and so, aesthetically, it left me unmoved. Which is exactly why I forwarded it to everyone I know.
Kitsch, a term borrowed from German, describes artworks or designs marked by excessive sentimentality and simplistic aesthetics. It's associated above all with mass-produced items that appeal directly to the emotions by leaning on clichés. A prime example is the "Crying Boy" image by the Italian artist Giovanni Bragolin, ubiquitous in the second half of the 20th century — a picture of a child with huge, sorrowful, tear-filled eyes that triggered a strong emotional response and conveyed a message of innocence and vulnerability.
In Israel, as in many other countries, right-wing groups are better at using kitsch aesthetics, and do so far more effectively than the left. In the United States, Hungary, Poland, Russia, Brazil, and Italy too, conservative and nationalist political movements deliberately use kitsch as a tool to reinforce populist, traditionalist, emotionally charged narratives.
On Cleverness and Accessibility
The main reason for this connection is simple: kitsch communicates through emotional symbols that are accessible and immediate. Right-wing movements build on appeals to nostalgia, nationalist patriotism, and conservative tradition — and kitsch is a particularly effective tool for them, a natural language for reaching the public.
Kitsch evokes a sense of collective memory and emotional belonging — without demanding deep analysis or intellectual engagement. Symbols like flags, anthems, images of the traditional family, religious icons, historical heroes, and romantic landscapes can all be easily packaged as moving visual kitsch.
What's more, kitsch is unmistakably sentimental, and appeals directly to emotion rather than logic. Populist strategies tend to gravitate toward this kind of direct emotional appeal, aiming to unite broad audiences around narratives that are simple but powerful. And there's another important point here: kitsch functions as a tool of cultural and political resistance against what's perceived as elitist or intellectually distant culture — an image populist right-wing movements often pin on the left. By embracing kitsch, the right reinforces its claim to represent the "authentic voice" of ordinary people, as against the "out-of-touch elites."
The left — and here's where we start to see the problem — has historically leaned toward intellectualization, critique, irony, and the challenging of traditional structures, and so it often avoids using simple emotional symbols or overt sentimental expressions. Left-wing aesthetics tend to resist kitsch, or to deploy it only ironically or critically, as part of satire or artistic commentary.

Forgetting What It Means to Be Moved
But with all due respect to good taste, when the left avoids kitsch, it gives up a powerful communicative tool that speaks to basic human psychological needs. Kitsch has broad appeal precisely because it speaks to basic psychological needs. Its power doesn't come from artistic sophistication, but from its ability to touch, directly and urgently, emotional, cognitive, and social dynamics that are universal and comforting. In many ways, kitsch exposes the deep needs of the human psyche — and precisely for that reason, those of us on the left have a lot to learn from it, rather than dismissing it as cheap or simplistic.
Immediate emotional clarity. Kitsch delivers instant emotional gratification. It bypasses complexity and ambiguity, offering familiar symbols that are easy to read: a crying child, a flag waving in the wind, a romantic sunset, a family embracing, a dog leaping on its owner returning from battle. The emotion fires immediately, and the audience isn't required to do any intellectual work or deep interpretation. The left, which often prefers complex, critical discourse, risks losing that direct emotional connection with the broader public as a result.
Ease of cognitive processing. Our brains are drawn to what's familiar and easy to digest. Kitsch works through clichés and simple narratives, which the brain reads as safe and true. Precisely in times of exhaustion, anxiety, or confusion, that simplicity gets perceived as an asset. The left aims to challenge and sharpen, but sometimes overlooks the power of cognitive comfort.
Sentimental nostalgia. Kitsch takes us back to a world where everything was supposedly clearer — family, childhood, the homeland. When a society is grappling with crisis, that sentimentality acts as an anchor. The left, rightly focused on critique, forgets that people have an emotional need for a positive memory of identity and belonging.
A sense of belonging and group identity. Kitsch reinforces collective identity — an image of a soldier saluting a flag, or a mother embracing her baby, isn't merely personal, it's symbolic and public, and it lets people feel part of a shared system of values. The left, which sometimes prefers individualism and criticism of national symbols, struggles to tap into this communal feeling.
Protection from complexity and alienation. The modern world is full of complications, paradoxes, and irony. Kitsch offers a simple emotional refuge: the good are good, the bad are bad, and suffering is noble and meaningful. Even if it's simplistic, it provides deep psychological comfort. The left, which champions critical thinking, sometimes forgets that the need for moral stability also deserves a place.
An escape from cultural exclusion. Kitsch doesn't require a degree or an education to understand. It doesn't signal that whoever doesn't get it is somehow inferior. So for audiences who feel that high culture looks down on them, kitsch is democratic, accessible, inclusive. If the left genuinely wants to speak to the broader public, it has to ask itself why it sometimes sends exactly the opposite message.
Elsewhere in Europe
There's no fundamental contradiction between the left and the use of kitsch; the resistance to kitsch often stems from a cultural tendency toward intellectualization, skepticism, and irony, which sees kitsch as something too simplistic, sentimental, or manipulative. That reservation could well be seen as a form of cultural condescension — one that unwittingly keeps left-wing movements from forging an effective emotional connection with broad audiences.
In fact, throughout history, left-wing movements have sometimes managed to harness kitsch elements successfully — mostly in moments that called for an intense emotional connection in the service of solidarity or mass mobilization. Soviet Socialist Realism, for instance, repeatedly used idealized, uplifting images of workers and communal life. These images were emotionally powerful, simple, and accessible to a broad public, meant to inspire and unite people around a shared vision — even if, later on, they drew criticism for their ideological simplification.
In the United States, the iconic "We Can Do It" poster, created in 1943 by the artist J. Howard Miller, originally for the Westinghouse company to boost morale among factory workers during World War II, is a good example of this. The figure depicted, nicknamed Rosie, is shown as a strong, self-assured woman in work clothes, with a red polka-dot bandana, flexing her arm muscle — over the years, she became a feminist symbol and an expression of female empowerment. And the more popular she became, the more she naturally started giving off a distinctly kitschy scent. The poet Pablo Neruda, too, managed to be revered by the intellectual elite while writing in accessible language full of sentimental imagery.
To use kitsch effectively, the left needs to recognize, once again, that emotional simplicity isn't necessarily manipulation or shallowness — it can be a powerful, dignified way to communicate universal values like compassion, solidarity, and social justice.
What's more, when you're not afraid to be bold, every once in an age you manage to land an image or a phrase so iconic it becomes literal shorthand — like the man standing in front of the line of tanks in Tiananmen Square. An image that conveys resistance, vulnerability, and moral courage, with no caption, no slogan, no explicit emotional instruction. An image that captures a broad, complex idea in its most distilled, powerful form, and acts on the emotions instantly. In other words: you can start with kitsch — with the aim of stirring immediate feeling — without having to do it through exaggeration, sentimentality, and cliché. But like Rosie, and like the poet whose poem went around the internet, it's time to roll up our sleeves. We can do it. Because it's true: we have no children to spare for unnecessary wars.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




