top of page

The Most Painful Betrayal Doesn't Necessarily Involve Sex

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Jul 17, 2018
5 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Saved money and kept it secret? Don't be surprised if your partner is hurt

Atalia and Ilan sit across from me, hurt and confused. On the face of it, a string of positive events has recently unfolded in their lives: their 22-year-old daughter has been accepted to an Ivy League university, where only four percent of applicants are admitted. The exciting news came with a certain anxiety, since tuition at the prestigious university runs about $30,000 a year, and that's before taking into account rent, living expenses, and flights for the daughter to come home or for her parents to fly out and visit her.

But then came a plot twist, when it turned out that Atalia had set aside a considerable portion of the money her father left her, $200,000 to be exact, which covers the entire cost of the education. Since it became clear that they have a way to fund the studies, Ilan's behavior has changed and he has become withdrawn and sullen. Atalia cannot for the life of her understand what the problem is. After all, she saved money, and she did it for the family's sake. She wasn't using it to finance a secret lover or compulsive online gambling.

I understand her; as the thrifty side of the relationship, Atalia justifies her behavior to herself. Ilan is a different type: very generous, but also less calculating than Atalia. She feared she wouldn't be able to stand her ground against him, and that instead of the money changing their lives in a meaningful way, it would be scattered to the wind.

Is hiding savings still hiding? Yes. Can the fact that Atalia doesn't trust Ilan enough to tell him how much she has saved do harm? Yes. Is this lack of trust a problem? Yes. Is she the only one who behaves this way? Not at all.

Many people lie to their partners about money, according to recent surveys conducted in the United States. According to another survey, about 60 percent of Americans hide money from their partner, and one in five hides financial problems from them. If we add up all this data, assuming that those who have financial problems have no money they could hide, we arrive at the conclusion that about 80 percent of Americans in relationships are dishonest with their partners about money.

From the standpoint of couple therapy, the reason isn't that human nature is evil from birth. The two main reasons for our dishonesty about money are that we fear our partner won't approve of the way we manage our finances, or that our fear is the opposite one and, like Atalia, we don't trust our partner in these matters.

So here we have a mirror image. If we betray our partner financially by hiding financial problems, it is probably because we fear they will judge our financial conduct. On the other hand, if we think we know how to manage money but don't trust our partners, there is a good chance we are expressing our fear in a crooked way, by hiding the money we save.

The Most Painful Betrayal Doesn't Necessarily Involve Sex - illustration

Even so, I see that Atalia is unable to understand why Ilan experiences the discovery of the secret savings as if it were the discovery of an affair. The idea that a secret savings account is a financial betrayal just like sliding into debt arouses in her, as in many people, enormous resistance. I'm not surprised, and so I try to slice this dish into very thin slices so that Ilan can convey his feelings in a way Atalia will be able to respond to.

Gradually, Ilan describes things from his point of view. For twenty-five years, he and Atalia have lived with a sense that there is no money. They've scraped by penny by penny, haven't bought new clothes for the kids, neither of them has ever traveled abroad as a couple, and the house, which quickly became too small for the family, was never expanded even though there was a theoretical possibility of doing so for everyone's benefit. And suddenly, on the day the family reaches an important milestone like their eldest daughter's studies, he discovers that his partner, the woman he loves and shared every dream and every hardship with, hid from him a large sum of money that now changes the entire picture.

The money allows the parents and the daughter to realize their coveted dream, and for that Ilan is of course grateful. But on the other hand, Ilan feels deceived. His reaction is extremely harsh and very similar to that of a partner who has been betrayed romantically or sexually. Ilan goes back in memory to significant junctures and understands them differently in light of the new information. He feels humiliated and afraid to get close to Atalia. Why didn't she share this critical information with him? What does her behavior say about how she regards his judgment? Where do his wishes and needs rank on her list of priorities? And what if, along the way, there were moments when he would have preferred to spend some sum on a meaningful experience rather than save it?

Atalia is devastated. As so often in couple and family therapy, I see two people who wanted the best for their relationship and acted to the best of their understanding, but out of fear of revealing their true feelings brought the relationship to the brink. Had Atalia shared with Ilan, in real time, her dreams and fears about money, the family traumas behind her anxious attitude toward spending and her difficulty believing she is allowed to spend money on life's pleasures too, chances are she would have discovered that the gap between her and Ilan is not as large as it seems to her. But she didn't. Out of fear of causing a fight or dealing with differences, she hid the money, and in doing so, tragically, put the relationship in great danger.

Financial surprises in a relationship are very dangerous, and we should try to avoid them. The way to avoid financial betrayals is to remember that even significant breaches of trust usually begin with fairly small secrets and lies. Did you buy a TV for the World Cup that cost 4,000 shekels and tell your partner it was on sale and cost only 2,000? Do you hide shopping receipts? Did you lend money to your sister and hide it from your partner because you're afraid he'll object? Or perhaps you took out a loan you never told your partner about, out of embarrassment at admitting the financial mistakes you made in the distant past?

Each of these things may be justified on paper, or in your head. But if we don't put them on the table and learn to talk about them, they will drag more and more lies in their wake, and usually the financial significance of those lies will grow as well. Like Atalia and Ilan, we may find ourselves in a situation where an enormous effort we made for the sake of the relationship is exactly the thing that endangers it and may even break it apart.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page