The Mistake That Makes Bad Habits So Hard to Shake
Updated: Oct 22
When we try to fight ourselves, we may end up cementing our bad habits. The right approach is to focus on the positive side of the change we're trying to make
Bad habits: where would we be without them? On the one hand, they're a sign of our humanity; on the other, they weigh us down and make it harder for us to grow. It seems to me that many of our bad habits are tied to those "dopamine sandwiches" I wrote about not long ago. That is, situations in which we trap ourselves in the pursuit of a high that only takes us further from the joy, satisfaction and motivation we're after.
Bad habits come in many forms, but for the purposes of discussing the right way to get rid of them, I want to treat them, in principle, as different kinds of addiction. Smoking cigarettes, excessive weed or alcohol consumption, overeating, excessive porn use, gambling, or compulsively returning to a harmful social circle or a miserable romantic relationship: all of these may, of course, conceal a complicated and traumatic personal history. But in some cases, or more precisely, from a certain point of view, they can also be seen as extreme cases of bad habits.
What makes them habits is how automatic they are, and how quickly they launch. Just as with good habits, and perhaps even more conspicuously with unwanted ones, only a blink of an eye passes between the moment the possibility of the unwanted act occurs to us (pouring ourselves the drink, grabbing the chips, rolling the joint, texting that wrong person) and carrying it out.
A short, dark corridor separates the moment of the idea from the moment of execution, and when we're caught in the loop of "feeling bad, doing it, guilt, feeling bad, doing it" that belongs to the habit, it's especially hard to understand what's happening to us in that corridor. It's important to remember that this corridor exists, in order to understand something meaningful about the right way to get rid of bad habits. The more we can lengthen the corridor, light it up, and make it longer and more branching, the more we can loosen the habit's grip on us.
That's why meditation and mindfulness practice are meaningful ways to reduce the presence of bad habits in our lives. Practicing our awareness of details, including heightened awareness of our physical and mental state, and of the experience of consuming the unwanted substance, lights up the corridor and lengthens it. Once the corridor is brighter and longer, more time passes between the decision and the act, and more opportunities open up to wake from the autopilot we're in and change the script. Greater awareness that I'm irritable, or hungry, or tired, or lonely, for example, effectively creates exits off the highway that connects the urge to the unwanted habit.
These exits are an opportunity to deal differently with the uncomfortable feeling that helps set off the urge. And once I'm aware that I have a chance to do something other than the usual, it matters that we do it right. Here I'm connecting to an earlier column in which I tried to sharpen the right way to give ourselves a pat on the back. In that column I stressed that when we deny ourselves a dopamine sandwich, we can ease the suffering involved by using the brain's prefrontal cortex and its ability to serve as a source of dopamine that doesn't depend in the same way on interaction with the outside world.
When we think about our personal achievements, about our ability to steer our lives to good places and to live in line with our values, that awareness comes with a certain rise in dopamine. You can already see why this mental move is so important when we're trying to break free of bad habits too.
We can also look at it from the opposite angle, and spell out how not to try to get rid of bad habits. The common mistake we make when trying to quit something is to fight ourselves. Fighting ourselves simply doesn't work. We can suppress certain behaviors for a short time. We can hold out without quarreling with an annoying relative at the Passover seder, for example, or avoid getting drunk at the office party. But trying to suppress our habits over the long term is asking for trouble.
The deeper explanation is that these habits come to solve a certain emotional distress for us, and so, as long as we suffer from that distress, they'll eventually come to our aid, like a loyal bodyguard. And they'll do it even if their protection is in effect a bear hug, crushing us while it shields us. But if we want to loosen their hold on our lives even before deeper emotional therapy bears fruit, it's worth simply thinking about this: whatever we focus our gaze on grows in importance for us. For this reason, if, while trying to eradicate a certain behavior, we put the unwanted behavior at the center, we paradoxically increase its importance and its influence over us. To remember this, it's enough to think of Eve and the apple.
So how can you weaken a behavior without thinking about it? The right way is to put the positive outcome we're aiming for at the center. If you're trying to cut down on how many drags you take, for example, and all evening you keep your attention fixed on the drag and on the fact that you're forbidding yourself to smoke it, the cigarette's power over you will only grow. If, on the other hand, you focus your thinking on the outcome you want, being healthy, feeling that you respect your body, waking up fresh tomorrow morning, sleeping well at night, the expected mental result is that the gain will take up more room in your mind, while the drag itself will shrink in importance.
But meditation doesn't only lengthen the corridor and give us a chance to choose a different way of dealing with our feelings. Another point, which comes up in the self-hypnosis approach to addiction and also stands out in various meditations, especially Sadhguru's, is the idea that I am not my body. The dialectic in which I do depend on my body but am not wholly identified with it helps me tell the body's cravings and aches apart from myself. The more this automatic identification between body and self loosens, the more room I have to choose how to respond to the bodily reactions that usually led me to the drink or to the bad relationship.
Alongside these principles, there's another method for breaking up the tight, automatic link between the spark of an urge and giving in to it. I heard about it on Andrew Huberman's podcast, and although I haven't tried it myself, it's amusing and surprising, and logic says it should work. The method Huberman recommends for breaking the habit loop is to follow every bad habit with a good one.
Suppose, for example, that the habit you're trying to quit is eating a late-night snack meal after dinner. With this method, you pick a good habit you're trying to build into your life, such as doing sit-ups every day, getting back to reading fiction, flossing your teeth, or not leaving dishes in the sink overnight, and you attach it to the unwanted act. You decide on this "price list" in advance, and the moment you've finished off the Doritos at one in the morning, you move on to the sit-ups.
It may sound strange, but as I understand it there are at least two reasons this works. The first is that we start from the assumption that we turn to the objectionable habit out of some uncomfortable feeling. When we pair the objectionable habit with a positive one that helps us feel good about ourselves, we're also, along the way, reminding our brain that there are other ways to make ourselves feel less bad. Given that the good habit we've attached is one we truly believe in, we can help our brain learn that when it's trying to shake off the stress of the day, sit-ups in front of the TV can be more effective than polishing off an entire pizza.
The second reason is that adding the positive action makes the corridor more branching and less automatic. Instead of the path being: I want chocolate, I eat chocolate, the path becomes: I want chocolate, I eat chocolate, I do sit-ups. This is a far more complicated path, and as such it creates more exits off the highway. All of this while keeping to the earlier principle of avoiding a war with ourselves, and without putting the chocolate at the center.

My Recommendations
Books: Shantaram
When you hold this book in your hands, you'll think I've lost my mind. It's more than 900 pages, and the last time you read something this size was probably your Harry Potter phase. But Shantaram reads smoothly and fast. In days when it's hard to go on real adventures in the world, I got swept away by the adventures of the narrator (whose character is based, to a very large degree, on the author), who escaped from a maximum-security prison in Australia only to get tangled up in love affairs, crime and war in India. Literarily, Shantaram isn't a good book, but humanly and culturally, it's a great one.
Family Activity: Advanced "Categories"
Who would have thought that after two years we'd still be sitting home so many evenings looking for a family activity, as if we were Meg, Jo, Beth and Amy during the Civil War. One of the nicest variations on a classic game that I discovered in this period is called "Category Scattergories," in which you set new categories in place of the traditional country-city-animal-plant-object. (Note: this refers to the Israeli word game "Eretz-Ir.")
The categories can be anything, and the better they fit your family's character, the more fun it is. In our house, for instance, "Spider-Man" can be a category, and under the letter W you might write "web shooter." And there's a much more challenging version, which you can play with older kids, called "Second Letter." In this game you use the traditional categories, but once the letter is chosen, it has to appear as the second letter of each word. For example, if the letter is B, a city is no longer Berlin but Givatayim (the B is its second letter).
Corona Routine: Korean Masks
We're probably at the tail end of the Omicron wave, but you should still check out the Korean masks in the KF94 category, which stands for Korean Filter and 94 percent. These are thin, light masks that cover the face as fully as possible, fold under the chin, and leave plenty of room between your nose and mouth and the mask so you can talk and breathe easily.
As a glasses wearer, I've never come across masks that fog up the lenses so little. They're compact, and each one can be used for about 40 hours, continuously or in separate stretches, as long as you keep the mask clean and relatively snug against your face. If you buy them on Amazon, they cost about a dollar a mask. For now there aren't many fakes. Note that the "legitimate" masks are made in Korea and usually come in separate packaging. The masks come in adult and children's sizes.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




