top of page

The Middle East Casino: Why Do We Keep Predicting When the Strike on Iran Will Come?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Feb 26
6 min read

Updated: Oct 22

The speculation mill around the date of the strike is not just an act of control but the perfect distraction from the real event. That way, we're not the potential victims who could lose everything any minute now

Jeremy, my hairdresser, is truly wonderful. Not only does he give a dreamy blowout, he also knows when the attack on Iran will happen. When I came to him a month ago, he knew, with certainty, based on his source on Telegram, that the attack would take place on the night between Sunday and Monday of the coming week. "Don't forget," he told me as I left all dolled up, "don't wash your hair for 24 hours, and get ready too, Sunday night there's going to be action," he said, firing imaginary pistols from both hands like a cowboy in a Western.

Michael, a lawyer in his seventies, well connected to all sorts of "those in the know" and a tough guy in his own right, also knew when the attack was about to break out. I told him the date of my son's bar mitzvah, and he said, "Too bad, that's exactly the weekend of the attack."

Shirley is a patient whose husband is a fighter pilot. Already a month and a half ago she knew the attack would come that weekend. Her husband was actually less in the loop. "But I read the news," she explained to me.

And Now, the Next Forecast

When I ran into Ronit on the street about two weeks ago, a respected journalist, she told me, based on the commentators she meets in the studios, "You know the attack will be this weekend," and then added, with characteristic insensitivity, "but I don't care, because I'm flying to Copenhagen for the weekend with my boyfriend."

And last week at the manicurist's, I heard another manicurist talking with a client and telling her she'd dreamed that the attack would happen on Tuesday at noon. The client objected that the previous attack had begun in the middle of the night. "True," the manicurist agreed, "but in my dream it was at noon." And she went on to describe how she'd seen many guns in the dream.

Between the lines I gathered that her authority rested on the fact that she had also foreseen the October 7 attack in a dream, except that back then she still lived in Russia, which misled her about the interpretation of the dream. As for me, whose sources are apparently less authoritative, I decided that in any case it would be wise to postpone the bar mitzvah.

When I told my close friends, one of them responded, "Too bad you fell into the loop." And last Saturday, I spoke again with that same veteran lawyer, a family friend, the one who told me the attack would happen on the weekend of the bar mitzvah. I told him that on Monday I'm going to some party, and he said to me, "But you know the party won't end up taking place. Because Monday is the day it's going to happen."

"Stop right there," I asked with a smile. "You have to explain to me how it's possible that even after your last three predictions were proven wrong, you're still completely sure you're right this time?"

And that's the question. Fine, Jeremy the hairdresser, who you can tell is a person who likes a mess, and maybe that explains his gleeful prediction of action already a month ago. But Michael is an educated man who has seen a thing or two in his life, facing a chain of failed predictions, and yet his eyes sparkle with the same confidence as he explains to me that the party won't happen.

And as noted, Michael isn't alone. The manicurist, the pilot's wife, the journalist, my downstairs neighbor (whose father, of course, reports to him straight from "the Bor," the army's underground command bunker), all of them hold the end of an invisible thread that, if we'd only follow it, would lead us out of the maze. Again and again reality proves to us that we have no idea, but the feeling of certainty stands firm. What's going on here?

Do we prefer to believe something mistaken over experiencing the fear of having no idea what will happen tomorrow? Perhaps the prediction, however absurd its reasoning, gives us structure, and turns the threat from a formless monster into something with a date and a time.

Maybe we enjoy the illusion of a secret? My grandmother was like that. She could whisper in your ear the headline of the day-before-yesterday's newspaper and give you the feeling that the Shin Bet had called her on the red phone to brief her.

The Middle East Casino: Why Do We Keep Predicting When the Strike on Iran Will Come? - illustration

When the Blow Will Land

When we feel we know something others don't, it gives us a little "high" of superiority and, whether or not related, a false sense of control: if we know when the blow will land, we're already less helpless in the face of it. The friend who said we'd fallen into the loop also enjoyed an illusion of control.

In addition, I think there's a need here for a community of fear, or of non-fear: information of this kind spreads virally. The contagion creates intimacy and connection in times of stress, as long as our predictions don't lead us into confrontation. It becomes a bit absurd when the content of the report is so dramatic, and yet turns out to be a less essential part, psychologically, of the interaction than the very fact that someone shared it with us.

But I think there are two more points. The first is that the insistence on predicting is also tied to the difficulty of internalizing that the world today is run by a creature as unpredictable as Trump. Dreams may be an information source that has gone out of fashion over the past few centuries, but until Trump, the father doing reserve duty in "the Bor" was a relevant source of information.

Until Trump, when a power like America went to war, a number of events had preceded it, one after another, with a shape, an order, and an internal logic, and so commentators well versed in history also had something to rely on. Trying to keep forecasting the future on the basis of the old algorithm is also a refusal to accept that this algorithm doesn't take one enormous variable into account.

Until the Next Thrill

The second point is almost biological. When Michael told me the party wouldn't take place, he smiled. My hairdresser smiled too. The friend who said I'd fallen into the loop was amused as well. What's going on here? What are they enjoying so much?

Their enjoyment made me realize that this isn't a rational discourse of risk assessment with a bug in it, but something much more closely tied to the mechanism of addiction. After all, this is how addicts behave, to drugs or to gambling: in the face of a string of past disappointments and refutations, they don't hand over the keys, but express absolute confidence that this time "this is it."

And for this they need nothing beyond their gut feeling. The addict is convinced that this is the last dose and that afterward he will regain full control of his life. The gambler is sure the roulette wheel must stop on red simply because it stopped on black five times. And why are the predictors addicted? I think we can say with confidence that they aren't addicted to the content (in this sense they differ from junkies), but to the act of prediction itself, which makes them much more like gamblers.

Jeremy may be seeking the "action" of war, and Shirley may be anxious about the fate of her pilot husband, but most people simply toss predictions into the air regardless of what they'd actually like to happen. The prediction is their dose. The moment they bet on a date when the attack will occur, or declare that it won't happen at all in the near future, they experience an inner high unrelated to external reality, injected into their brains independently, right now, regardless of what actually happens.

Physiologically, this is a process of addiction to anything. The very act of declaring emphatically "on Monday," "Tuesday at noon," or "at the bar mitzvah it happens" is the roll of the dice, and it's what releases a burst of dopamine in the brain. The gamblers' high is anesthetizing, and there are certainly enough things we don't want to feel. This thrill lets us not feel the terror of not knowing and, of course, of the deep meaning of what we're actually talking about: a real existential risk. In addition, betting creates distance and dissociation from the event.

The moment Michael, the manicurist, you, or I bet on the date of the strike, we distance ourselves from the actual event. We are no longer the potential victims who may lose everything any minute now, and have already lost quite a bit. No, no, we are the old men in the Muppets, spectators on the sidelines sitting in the great casino of the Middle East, waiting to see whether our guess hit the bullseye.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page