top of page

The Last Days of Pompeii: Are We Living on a Volcano Too?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Oct 31, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

It's common to think Pompeii's destruction was a sudden disaster, but knowing its residents had already been shaken once — and chose to carry on anyway — changes the story. Are we, too, clinging to false hope?

The train from Naples to Pompeii stops at a station that isn't called Pompeii. The announcer declares something in Italian and leaves it at that. The tourists, us among them, look at each other, and once the cars empty out, we understand that waiting for clarification isn't going to get us any closer to the archaeological site, so we get off the train.

This is apparently nothing unusual, because outside the station taxis are already clustering, charging tourists a flat rate of five euros a head from the station to the site. We climb into one of them, along with another couple and a family, and drive through unmistakably Italian outskirts toward the site.

When we walk into Pompeii, I'm stunned by the sheer size of the city. There was a great deal I didn't know about Pompeii. Actually, I knew almost nothing about it. The story of the city frozen mid-motion by the volcanic eruption was etched into my mind from repeated childhood browsing through issues of Life magazine, which my grandfather subscribed to.

The article was surely published sometime in the sixties, but the issue survived well into the eighties, and I had access to it whenever I visited the stone house my grandfather Noah built with his own hands in Kiryat Bialik.

It had haunting photographs of the plaster casts made from the bodies of victims of Vesuvius's eruption. After the bodies were sealed inside volcanic ash, they decomposed. In the 19th century, researchers poured plaster into the cavities left behind once the bodies had disintegrated, and in doing so managed to trace and preserve the details of Pompeii's residents in their final moments.

I drag my family around in search of the plaster casts, not all of which are on display at any given time. We find one exhibit showing the bodies of people who appear to have been slaves, caught in the middle of trying to escape their fate. Some of the parents are lying on top of their children, trying to shield them with their own bodies. We go quiet. It's hard to look at trauma like that today the way we would have looked at it before October 7.

The Writing Was on the City

There's a lot to take in. As always, it comes down to the fact that there's no real difference between us and people who lived two thousand years ago — except that they would surely be stunned to discover how much technical skill and craftsmanship has been lost over the centuries.

Wandering through the vast, imposing city — much of whose remains I'd later see at the Naples Archaeological Museum — I also learn that in 62 CE, some seventeen years before Vesuvius's catastrophic eruption, the region was hit by a powerful earthquake, the first in a series of geological disturbances. That earthquake was severe enough to cause major damage to many buildings in Pompeii.

I'd always thought of Pompeii as a story of sudden disaster — one day when thousands of lives were wiped out without warning. But learning about the earthquake changes the story: it wasn't a complete surprise. They had already been shaken once, and chose to carry on anyway, maybe out of hope, maybe out of denial.

I can't help thinking about us. About the earthquakes we've been living through since the start of the judicial coup, through the trauma of October 7 and the attempts to erase it, through turning our backs on the hostages, the leaderless war.

With every additional political and social earthquake, we check that everyone close to us is still alive, shake off the dust, and carry on. But maybe, like in Pompeii, these are signs of a far bigger disaster still to come, if we keep looking away.

After that powerful earthquake, many residents of Pompeii and the surrounding area undertook substantial rebuilding efforts to repair the damage. Walking through the vast streets, you can see that residents invested in restoring their homes, and some even used the opportunity to improve them.

They added decorative frescoes and built new architectural features that are still visible today in structures uncovered by excavations over the years. The frescoes and mosaics took my breath away.

It's hard to absorb. Even the children barely reach for their phones. I decide to give up the search for more plaster casts, and after a few hours, we start making our way back to Naples.

We decide to gamble on a different train line, but that bet fails too, and this train also stops on the outskirts of Naples, and once again hundreds of passengers pour out onto the street, every group left to fend for itself.

A passing bus can't hold all the passengers. A handful of taxis are doing a brisk trade. We order an Uber and are matched with Massimo, a charming older driver, who takes us all the way to the lovely apartment we'd rented in central Naples.

As Massimo's little taxi drives through Naples's outer neighborhoods, on its way to the heart of this magnificent city, I think about the residents of Pompeii who didn't read the earthquake as evidence of heightened seismic activity in the area — a possible warning sign that Vesuvius was unstable and posed an existential threat.

I was supposed to leave on this trip on October 13, but the moment I heard about the pager operation, I decided to move my flight up. I suppose I'd become extremely sensitive — maybe even allergic — to the absence of any whiff of statesmanship.

Since I already had a Tel Aviv–Rome ticket, and had somewhere to stay in Rome, I decided it was better to take my Zoom calls from Rome than from a bomb shelter, and moved my arrival in Italy up by three weeks. For the first three weeks I worked as usual, and when the trip's original date rolled around, family members converged on Rome from around the world, and we drove down to Naples, and from there, as I said, set out for Pompeii.

The Last Days of Pompeii: Are We Living on a Volcano Too? - illustration

Symptoms of Weakness

After the first earthquake in 62 CE, the region kept experiencing smaller aftershocks. Locals treated them as ordinary geological events, not as a preview of a volcanic eruption. They were used to minor tremors and didn't see them as a sign of unusual danger.

It's also possible they simply didn't know what we know today, and had no idea Vesuvius was an active volcano at all. I think about the buildings we saw, about the years between the big earthquake and the final, fatal eruption.

The residents of Pompeii, who chose to stay in the city despite the major earthquake that struck seventeen years before Vesuvius erupted, were probably walking, like us, that thin line between hope and denial, between ignorance and optimism.

The city wasn't rebuilt evenly. In some neighborhoods, damaged buildings were abandoned and never restored, for lack of resources or lack of interest in restoring them. Naturally, the public buildings — the forum, the temples, the amphitheater — were given priority in the rebuilding, since they played a central role in Pompeii's social and economic life.

Smaller homes and businesses in less well-off areas, by contrast, were often left in a state of partial neglect all the way up to the eruption in 79 CE.

Leaning on the Pillar of Routine

I imagine that for them too, for many of them, the belief that life would go on as usual was an expression of resilience — a refusal to let disaster dictate their lives. And on the other hand, that same belief also exposes a powerful human tendency, one that in Israel has become a national sport: to downplay risk, and cling to the comfort of routine.

The rebuilding efforts never fully restored Pompeii to what it had been before the earthquake. Was that simply the result of economic constraints, or is it also evidence of a mounting sense of instability?

It's possible the repeated tremors after 62 CE bred hesitation among some of the residents. What led to a situation where, by 79 CE, the city was a patchwork of renovated buildings, damaged buildings, and abandoned ones?

A week after visiting Pompeii we're in Rome, packing and getting ready to split up again. There are rumors in the air of a planned Israeli strike on Iran, and of a counterstrike expected that very same night.

Every time you open your phone you learn about more people who woke up that morning just like we did, but didn't live to see its end. My older daughter is about to board a flight to Israel. My heart is stretched thin to the point of pain; I want to keep being near her. It had been wonderful, being close to her for almost two weeks.

I pack slowly, sorrowfully. There's evidence that in the years after the great earthquake, wells and springs in the area began to dry up. Even if, two thousand years ago, there was no way to know that magma shifting beneath the surface was choking off natural water sources, or that faint gas emissions were changing the vegetation, there were people for whom it added up to too many worrying signs.

Some residents left Pompeii after the devastating earthquake of 62 and the aftershocks that followed it. Even if they didn't understand exactly what danger Vesuvius posed, they sensed the area was no longer safe, and that was reason enough for them to leave.

Ancient sources and archaeological evidence suggest that certain families — mainly those who could afford to — moved to other cities in the Roman Empire, like Naples or even Rome, where they had to start over, but without the fear of seismic activity hanging over them.

But I can't bring myself to get on that plane back to Tel Aviv. I help my daughter pack her mozzarella, creatively and thoroughly, and when I land at my hideaway on a remote Greek beach, she sends me a photo showing that the mozzarella made it safely, and not even her Zara skirt was damaged.

At midnight, in the quiet Aegean night, I still can't fall asleep. I sit down to write this piece. By the time I finish it, I get a notification that the Israeli strike on Iran has begun.

I understand that for me, Pompeii is a soot-blackened mirror, one in which we're reflected — torn between trying to balance optimism with realism, and between telling hope apart from the kind of denial that can blind us to dangers closing in.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page