top of page

The Ingredients That Will Make Your Sex Life Thrilling Again

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Dec 4, 2017
6 min read

To feel sexually aroused, we also need erotic obstacles — what are they, and how can we put them to use?

The leading categories on "Sleazy" — the Israeli erotic-stories site — are "More Than a Couple" (101 stories), "Infidelity" (83 stories), "Male Dominance" (81 stories), "Cuckold" (68 stories), and "Female Dominance" (50 stories). Other leading categories include "Violent Fantasies" (36 stories), "Away From Home" (36 stories), "Religious" (35 stories), and "Humiliation" (34 stories). On the Hebrew erotic-stories site "The Handle," the top categories include "Young Men and Older Women," "Forced Sex," "Religious Women," "Incest," and "Pregnancy."

On the face of it, there are big differences between these categories: someone who's turned on by infidelity stories might feel revulsion at stories about incest, and someone excited by "more than a couple" stories won't necessarily be drawn to violent fantasies. But if we look at these stories from the vantage point of the sexologist and therapist Jack Morin, known for his book The Erotic Mind, we can see that all of these categories point to the existence of an erotic equation underlying our sexual arousal.

Morin conducted a comprehensive survey of 350 people with diverse sexual orientations, who were asked to describe in detail the most exciting sexual experiences they'd ever had. When he analyzed these experiences (more than 1,000 examples), he found that they were in fact built from a small number of elements, which explain the mysterious process of erotic arousal. His core finding is that in order to become sexually aroused, we need to feel a combination of attraction and obstacle. The attraction part is self-evident, but what counts as an obstacle? Unfortunately, it's not simply that we don't have time for sex. Morin's twist is that anxiety, guilt, fear, and anger can, in the right context and the right dose, act like an aphrodisiac.

Morin identified four main obstacles that fuel erotic arousal: longing and anticipation, violating prohibitions ("we really shouldn't be doing this"), the pursuit of power (situations of submission or domination), and overcoming ambivalence toward the object of desire ("I hate you, kiss me"). Two specific situations contribute especially to a sense of erotic turmoil: the risk of being caught or exposed, and attraction to people considered unsuitable sexual partners (whether by the person themselves or by their social circle). In other words, while excessive anxiety will destroy our sex life (this is the "brake pedal" that Emily Nagoski talks about), anxiety itself doesn't contradict sexual arousal. More than that: if we keep it entirely out of our bedroom, it can actually hurt our sex life.

As an emotionally focused couples therapist, I feel this is a critical contribution to treating the sexual difficulties that characterize long-term monogamous relationships. Looking at it this way, we understand why even in relationships where the partners are still attracted to each other, desire can decline. From this vantage point, there's simply too little anxiety or obstacle of any kind left in the sex lives of committed partners: their living conditions don't let them long for each other; they're not offending public feeling when they close their bedroom door; their sex doesn't fill them with guilt; and they're not unsuitable sexual partners for one another.

The obstacle, then, is the "niche" that affairs outside marriage fill, and it's also the banner that sex therapist Esther Perel waves. An affair, after all, instantly produces the very conditions needed for erotic turmoil in one stroke: the risk of being discovered, plus an unsuitable sexual partner. This also explains why most affairs don't develop into meaningful relationships: once the obstacle is removed, the erotic magic fades. But while Perel does an excellent job framing the problem, in my view, without Morin's help, she doesn't really manage to offer a solution. Perel does draw inspiration from the relational psychoanalyst Stephen Mitchell, who argues that we only delude ourselves into thinking our partner belongs to us, and that no obstacle threatens their love for us. But between us, Mitchell's insight demands a very high level of awareness, suited to the spiritually accomplished. An affair, as the facts on the ground show, is a far more popular solution.

The Ingredients That Will Make Your Sex Life Thrilling Again - illustration

But an affair — even according to Perel — is a dangerous medicine. The dose required to revive sexuality in a committed relationship is dangerously close to the dose that could prove fatal to that same relationship. Morin's proposal — to explore our own desire, and identify the obstacle or erotic prohibition that most turns us on — is far more practical.

So why don't we look squarely at the erotic obstacles that excite us most? The answer is in the question, as they say. Most of us have pushed experiences of intense erotic arousal to the margins of consciousness precisely because they weren't "politically correct" by our own personal standards. If, for example, we found ourselves attracted to someone we find emotionally or morally repellent, or found ourselves aroused by the thought of an action that could put us at risk, it's naturally hard to dwell on that comfortably. But here's the paradox: those moments turned us on precisely because they were "wrong." Morin encourages us to stop thinking of these moments as pathological, and instead examine them in a way that helps us know ourselves better, and enjoy a more thrilling sex life.

The journey of self-discovery is based, according to Morin, on the assumption that there's a connection between our early childhood experiences and the basic erotic pattern that excites us. If we look honestly, between ourselves, at the most thrilling sexual experiences we've had, we're likely to discover that they're not scattered across the whole spectrum, but were in fact written by the same "screenwriter." This inner screenwriter returns again and again to situations that were emotionally complicated for us in childhood, and tries to work through them by means of sexual fantasy. A girl whose parents secretly carried on affairs might, as an adult, be aroused by fantasies in which she catches her husband cheating on her. A boy who underwent painful, invasive medical treatments might grow into an adult with BDSM fantasies, and so on. The variations in the kaleidoscope of the psyche are endless.

This is also why exploring our fantasies can improve our sex life. Because while we might think that the great sex we once had was tied to particular partners or circumstances that won't come again, and that for this reason we can't reach those same peaks within our current relationship, identifying the erotic pattern itself can let us think of ways to recreate those conditions within our own lives.

Suppose that, for you, the best sex you ever had was when you and your husband left the kids with grandma, took drugs, and got completely out of your heads — and another memorable encounter was the one you had at twenty in a parking lot with some idiot you barely remember at all. On the face of it, these situations seem unrelated, so there's nothing to learn from them. If anything, the suggestion to recall your sexual peak moments might sound like a frightening idea that could threaten your current relationship. But from Morin's perspective, it's possible that the obstacle that arouses you most is "breaking the rules." Identifying this pattern can open your eyes to other ways you might bring this secret spice into your sex life within your current relationship.

Let's take another example: suppose the best sex you ever had was with partners, but only after you'd broken up with them. This seems, on its face, like a recipe that can't be applied to your current relationship. But the picture changes if you realize that the attraction wasn't located in the partners themselves, but in the very ambivalence you felt toward them. In other words, maybe — contrary to what you might have assumed about yourself — you don't need to have sex with your husband specifically when you're relaxed at a romantic getaway on your birthday, gazing into each other's eyes, but rather close to the moments when you feel like hanging him from the ceiling fan.

Of course, for these self-discoveries to actually feed the relationship, you need the ability to talk about sex in a way that's difficult for a great many couples. It's frightening to share our combustible material with our partners, but the payoff in the quality of our sex life can be well worth it. In any case, each of us can take the first step toward that alone, since it's internal and private, and requires only that we suspend our self-judgment and extend ourselves some self-compassion. After all, if "more than a couple," "away from home," and "religious" are the leading categories in erotic stories, then maybe you're strange — but no stranger than anyone else.


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page