The Escape Route: When the Search for Healing Becomes the Problem Itself
Updated: Oct 22
People with borderline personality disorder often hop between treatment approaches and therapists, chasing whichever one will finally soothe them or rescue them from their distress. At what point does that search itself turn into a mechanism of distraction — a way of fleeing the very problem it's supposed to solve?
I recently read — or more accurately, listened to — a modest but deep and sharp-witted book by an American therapist named Charles C. McCormack, about working with couples affected by personality disorders. The book is called "Treating Borderline States in Marriage: Dealing with Oppositionalism, Ruthless Aggression and Severe Resistance."
From McCormack's perspective — his book can be read online for free — borderline personality disorder can be understood, at its root, as a difficulty with self-soothing that traces back to early parenting that wasn't good enough, and so never allowed the person, as an infant, to develop the internal machinery for regulating emotion. Parenting that falls short — whether neglectful or overly intrusive — leaves a child unable to internalize a reliable "soothing presence."
As a result, people with borderline personality disorder grow up without the emotional tools they need to regulate distress on their own, and turn instead to maladaptive self-soothing behaviors — self-harm, substance use, or chaotic relationship patterns.
A Thousand Shades of Escape
People suffering from this tormenting disorder develop all kinds of external strategies for coping with intense emotion and inner distress. Though these behaviors may bring temporary relief, some of them are dangerous, carry significant negative consequences, and perpetuate a cycle of dysregulation and distress.
Self-harm — cutting or burning, for instance — is a common self-soothing behavior among people in this state. It offers a sense of release from overwhelming emotional pain, a sense of control, or even a grounding mechanism in moments of detachment or dissociation. And yet self-harm often leaves physical scars, deepens feelings of guilt and shame, and can escalate to a life-threatening state.
Alcohol and drug use are often employed to dull intense emotions or to escape unbearable inner sensations. While substances may offer temporary respite, they typically worsen emotional instability, impair judgment, and lead to dependence or addiction — which only further complicates the person's ability to cope with stress.
Eating disorders — binge eating, purging, or extreme food restriction — can likewise serve as self-soothing strategies. These behaviors may provide a temporary sense of control or comfort, but they lead to health problems, feelings of guilt, and a worsening of emotional dysregulation.
Over the course of my life, I've seen up close, in this same context, impulsive behaviors like overspending or gambling, which can temporarily distract from emotional distress or provide a sense of excitement, but which usually create financial problems, interpersonal conflict, and regret — deepening the person's emotional struggle. I've also witnessed risky sexual behavior, another common strategy, which sometimes offers a sense of validation, connection, or distraction from inner pain, and which carries its own host of other costs.
The Art of Distraction
Listening to McCormack's book, and thinking about couples and patients — and, as I mentioned, about family members who seemed to struggle with this problem, together or apart — led me to ask myself whether a certain kind of search for mind-body therapies might itself be understood as one of the classic maladaptive self-soothing behaviors.
While mind-body-based therapies hold real potential for people with borderline personality disorder, the way these people approach treatment can sometimes mirror the very same maladaptive patterns seen in other self-soothing behaviors. Despite their seemingly positive nature, such therapies can become just one more expression of emotional dysregulation, avoidance, and external dependence — and can lead to negative consequences of their own.
Since a core feature of the disorder is reliance on external sources — people, substances, or activities — to manage overwhelming emotions, mind-body therapies, though usually considered a positive alternative, can end up becoming yet another external mechanism for regulation.
Mind-body therapies can also serve as a way of avoiding deep emotional work. People with borderline personality disorder often struggle to face painful emotions and unresolved trauma, and mind-body therapies, for all their genuine therapeutic potential, can end up functioning as a distraction.
Practices like massage or energy work, for example, can allow a person to avoid confronting their painful emotions — in a way that blocks any real engagement with the root of the distress and perpetuates the pattern of chasing immediate relief instead of doing the work of meaningful healing.

A Messiah Who Never Comes
A central dynamic in the relationships of someone with a borderline psychological structure is a cycle of idealizing others and then devaluing them — and this dynamic can show up in their involvement with mind-body therapies too. Practitioners like yoga instructors, meditation teachers, or somatic therapists can initially be idealized and seen as the perfect "messiah" for the patient's pain.
But when the practitioner fails to meet these unrealistic expectations — or when the person's deep emotional wounds remain unresolved — that same practitioner can turn into the one to blame, and a disappointment. This cycle leads to abandoning practitioners and searching for new ones, which prevents the formation of the consistent, trusting relationship that's essential to any effective healing process.
Which connects directly to the next drawback of chasing multiple therapies: the impulsiveness and sense of urgency with which these individuals try to fix themselves can lead them to pursue several mind-body therapies at once. While this might look like taking initiative and assuming responsibility, it can actually undermine the effectiveness of some of these methods.
Different therapies can contradict one another, leaving the person confused or destabilized. A psychotherapist, for example, might encourage a patient to take responsibility for their decisions, while a tarot reader might reinforce feelings of helplessness by delivering deterministic messages. On top of that, spreading one's attention across several methods keeps a person from truly committing to any single approach, or from absorbing the benefits any one therapy has to offer.
Splitting the Method
Many people with borderline personality disorder carry a deep sense of being flawed and needing external repair. Mind-body therapies can inadvertently reinforce this belief if the person sees them as a magic cure for their problems rather than as tools for genuine self-growth. This dependence on the feeling that "someone will fix me" can lead to helplessness and disappointment when a therapy doesn't produce immediate results — perpetuating a cycle of searching and abandoning.
This drawback connects directly to the fact that pursuing several therapies at once can also serve as a way of avoiding intimacy. Rather than risk emotional investment in a single therapist or a single approach, a person may split their attention across different methods and practitioners. This kind of splitting lets them keep relationships at a surface level, avoiding the vulnerability that deep emotional intimacy requires. But this avoidance also blocks the formation of meaningful connections and genuine therapeutic processes that could actually lead to change.
A more minor but still real drawback is that people with borderline personality disorder, because of the impulsivity and emotional vulnerability that characterize them, may be at especially high risk of falling for promises of therapeutic results that are scientifically unfounded or outright manipulative.
Finally, the tendency of people with this disorder to become enthralled with a new therapy can stem from all of these things at once: a sense of being flawed, the promise of a passive fix arriving from the outside, and impulsivity. This enthusiasm can also spread to the people around them, in the form of demanding that friends or family display support and belief in their new path — even when those close to them intuitively or openly sense the contradictions or risks involved.
The skepticism of people close to them — sometimes grounded in their own awareness of just how complicated the person's struggle is — may be interpreted by the suffering person as rejection or a lack of appreciation, leading to conflict and a sense of abandonment that only deepens the emotional pain.
In other words, while mind-body therapies can be a meaningful component of the recovery process for people with BPD, they need to be approached carefully and with awareness. When these practices are treated as external solutions rather than as part of a broader therapeutic framework, they risk replicating patterns that are both harmful and dangerous.
At the same time, unlike overtly maladaptive regulation strategies such as drug use, self-harm, or the other impulsive behaviors listed earlier — which mainly endanger the self — the search for mind-body therapies is a broad and varied category. While this search can reinforce over-dependence and avoidance of emotional work, it can also serve as a positive platform on which a person with the disorder can learn to better manage their difficulties.
Within these therapies (more so than in sex with strangers, driving under the influence, or rash financial decisions) lies the possibility of developing healthy tools for emotional regulation, strengthening inner resilience, and creating gradual change in one's patterns of coping. When engagement with these therapies happens consciously, in balance, and as part of a broader therapeutic framework, it can become fertile ground for growth, for reducing distress, and for becoming part of the larger journey of recovery.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




