top of page

So You Fell for a Man With Kids — Now What?

Writer: Amalia Rosenblum
Amalia Rosenblum
Nov 14, 2024
7 min read

Updated: Oct 22

Part two. The issues that surface once your new partner already has children — from custody schedules for your love life to half-siblings: five things to think through before building a relationship with someone who has kids from a previous marriage

Many people — or, to be more precise, many women — whether divorced themselves or never married, find themselves entering a relationship with a man or a woman who has children from a previous marriage. Every couple is different, and no family constellation is ever quite like another, but there are a few points that anyone who has fallen for a divorced parent would do well to start thinking through — on their own, with their therapist, and of course, ideally, with their partner.

What's more, if you're the divorced parent standing at the threshold of round two with someone who has no children, it's worth looking at the same issues too, to help both of you gauge just how capable you really are of building a life together.

Custody Schedules for Your Love Life

Not every family has a conventional custody arrangement, and it's worth understanding what the actual time-sharing with the children looks like in practice — how old they are, and how that division of time is likely to change over the years — and, above all, to map out the pressure points.

If, for example, you fall for the mother of a child whose father — your partner's ex-husband — travels abroad often for work, and under their agreement the child ends up spending far more time with his mother than in other divorced families you know, that will have consequences for your relationship.

Even in a fairly conventional divorce, in terms of time and attention, a partner who's already a parent carries commitments and constraints that go well beyond custody schedules and child support. Children's lives are full of the unexpected, and plans you've made — from workdays to romantic weekends away — are liable to fall through, even for the most seemingly trivial reasons, and unplanned expenses will keep cropping up too.

In other words, when you enter a serious relationship with someone who has a family from before, or when you, as a divorced parent, bring someone who's never been married into your life, you need to lead the glittery unicorns back to the stable for a moment and ask yourselves what this really means. It's important to try to picture how divorce actually affects your partner's availability, and what they're carrying.

The Wallet of Round Two

Couples already struggle to talk about money, and the risk is that by the time they finally do, a lot of other things have gotten tangled up in the conversation. When you enter a relationship that includes children who aren't shared, and certainly when only one of you is a parent, the ideal solution is to get on the same page before conflicts surface — to look together at the full picture of your combined resources and obligations, even if, and maybe especially if, you don't intend to split everything equally.

How someone feels about their partner's money can shift over the years. As long as you have no children together, you might, for instance, feel perfectly generous. But the moment you have a baby of your own, and every trip to the pharmacy feels like it requires taking out a loan, you might start to feel anxious or resentful that so much money is going toward children who aren't yours.

At first, you thought it wasn't even legitimate to raise these questions, and now you feel differently. That feeling may be natural, but it also exposes a real question: to what extent do you see the children from the previous marriage as part of your own family unit?

Even if nothing this dramatic has come up for you, it only makes sense that a young person with no children of their own would have no idea what children actually cost, and no way to imagine expenses that were never spelled out in their new partner's divorce agreement.

But what happens if your daughter is approaching her bat mitzvah, her mother announces she has no intention of funding the event, and yet you feel you won't be able to sleep at night unless you give your daughter a proper, appropriately priced celebration? How is your partner supposed to handle an expense like that, which comes at her expense to some degree and is spent on a child who isn't hers? The solution, as noted, is to start this conversation from the top, long before it's actually time to reach into your pocket — even if that means consulting a professional.

So You Fell for a Man With Kids — Now What? - illustration

Other People's Children

What's the new partner's place in raising children who aren't theirs? If your partner goes to a parent-guidance session about one of her kids, do you come along? What about parent-teacher conferences? If it drives you crazy when the kids leave their things scattered around the house, is it your place to say something?

Finding that golden mean takes real sensitivity — the balance that lets you say, politely, something like: "I'm the one keeping this house in order all day, so it matters to me that when you get home from school, you don't dump your backpack and shoes in the middle of the living room — put them in your room instead."

At the same time, you need to factor in that her daughter from the previous marriage may feel like she's "on probation" — that her place in the household is at risk, that there's someone here (you!) whose influence over her mother is significant enough that she, the daughter, can no longer feel quite as secure in her own place.

And more broadly: what are you even allowed to say about a child who isn't yours? When it's your own child, you can feel comfortable telling your new wife, "Look, this behavior is unacceptable, and I think we need to handle it this way." But that freedom comes from how secure you are in your own love for him. So do you love children who aren't yours the same way? And if you don't love them the same way, is it even possible that your partner's child doesn't know it?

It's very hard to lie to children. If your partner's child senses that your support for him, and your motivation to maintain a relationship with him, come with limited liability, you won't manage to build a good relationship with him. Staying authentic on one hand, and staying close on the other, demands constant vigilance and self-examination — and questions about raising the children bring that challenge to the surface again and again.

A Half-Sibling — Or a Whole One?

Every child arrives carrying fantasies of their own. It's worth pausing to think about what your fantasies are. What kind of relationship do you expect between the children from a previous marriage and the new baby you've had together? Should your older child, for instance, have to babysit the younger one just because they're siblings? Do the same rules that apply in most standard families apply in your case too?

It may not be comfortable to think about, but picture children aged 12 to 14 who are already old enough to babysit a baby recently born to one of their parents and that parent's new partner — it's worth asking: should they have to?

That question leads to further ones you need to answer honestly: Are you raising them in a way that genuinely lets them feel this baby is like a full sibling to them? Are they supposed to love him the way they love their full siblings? What exactly do you expect of them?

It's not easy to accept, but no relationship between siblings is a given, and if it isn't nurtured, it may simply never develop. When people are close in age, share parents and a common history, they can grow into close siblings with a warm bond. But by those same measures, the relationship can also turn out to be quite fragile and precarious.

Children can be ambivalent about the birth of a full sibling — so it's no surprise that they can react even more strongly to the birth of a half-sibling. The answer isn't to pretend a full sibling has been born and expect the child to play along. Experience shows that when it isn't forced on them, older children actually tend to bond with the younger one on their own.

The Family Group Chat — and Others

Some parents have a WhatsApp group with their children from their first marriage that doesn't include the new partner. Even once there are shared children, that group may keep going, including only the full siblings and leaving the half-siblings out. Do you think that's perfectly fine, or does it sit uneasily with you? Like every question raised here, this isn't a matter of right or wrong — just something worth thinking about.

A group chat like that can be entirely legitimate, even if it comes at a cost. The important question to answer honestly is: what's the underlying psychological message of the group? If its hidden purpose is to exclude the current partner, and to withhold legitimacy from anything that isn't strictly "us" (the father and his children from the earlier marriage), that's a problem.

There's another, healthier possibility: the divorced parent uses that WhatsApp group to keep up a dialogue with their older children in a way that gives the relationship with them its own space and identity, sending the message that the two identities aren't in conflict — that the new marriage exists alongside the relationship with the older children, not instead of it. Something that comes up in that group might prompt a reply like, "I want to check this with Mitzi (code name) first, so let me bring it over to our general family group."


Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com

 
 
bottom of page