Sitting Cross-Legged or Swallowing a Pill: How Meditation and Psychedelics Help Us
Updated: Oct 22
Psychedelic substances change the way our brains work, making everyday experiences feel new and thrilling. Like meditation, they let us experience oneness and give us a foundation for psychological healing
In an earlier column, I compared the relief offered by antidepressants and the pleasant feeling we get from a drink with the beneficial effects of classic psychedelics and of meditation. I put the last two in the same category, and since that is not a trivial theoretical move, this column is devoted mainly to the way psychedelics affect our brains, specifically in widening the sense of unity between an individual and their surroundings. For dessert, I have added a few words on how this effect parallels the effect of meditation.
The main aspect of this effect, for the purposes of this column, is known as "ego dissolution." It is the experience that people who have tried psychedelics describe with sentences like "I got rid of my ego," "I felt free of the everyday worries that weigh on me," "I felt connected to other people and to nature," and "I felt that my existence was timeless, and my existential anxiety dissolved."
It is impossible to talk about ego dissolution without noting that quite a few doctoral dissertations in philosophy and psychology have been written about the origins of the sense of self, and of course I have no way of presenting that subject here with the complexity it deserves. I will settle for saying that, of all the existing definitions of the sense of self, the simplest version that captures the phenomenological self, in my view, requires only the ability to locate the self, independently, in space and time.
That definition sounds complicated, but in fact every movie that deals in some way with a character who finds herself in another body defines the self in exactly this way. The maid turned into a teapot in "Beauty and the Beast," the talking baby in "Look Who's Talking," girls who wake up in the bodies of 30-year-old women, adults who wake up in the bodies of children, living people who turn into ghosts - all of these are different examples of defining the self by the brain's ability to identify its own location on the timeline and in physical space. We, the viewers, understand this definition completely intuitively.
This sense of self rests largely on a combination of visual, bodily and vestibular information (the last being relevant to our position in space). And this combination of sensory information from the outside world and information coming from within the body, together with the brain's own predictions, is consistent with the Bayesian model of the brain, which I began presenting in another column, a model also known as the "bodily/minimal self."
Let me remind you that, according to the Bayesian theory of the brain, the brain is a machine whose purpose is to test hypotheses. This machine builds an internal model of the sources of sensory information that exist in the world but are not directly accessible to it. The internal model keeps refining itself as it tries to avoid surprises, and it does so through a combination of perception and action that reduces the number of wrong predictions.
According to this theory, if the brain predicts the sources of sensory information in the outside world, we can assume it also predicts the organism's own contribution to that sensory information. In this way, the Bayesian model of the world should also include a model of the self, in the bodily/minimal sense I described earlier, since this is the statistically most plausible explanation for the existence of overlapping sensory-motor stimuli.
So how do psychedelic substances affect this process? The molecules of classic psychedelics (such as psilocybin or LSD) are apparently linked to a weakening of our ability to equip the foundations of our perception with accurate predictions, based either on information from the context or on earlier predictions. The result is more limited perceptual processing, "for better and for worse."

"For worse" because, in some respects, this perceptual processing is less reliable, and so it also comes with a feeling of uncertainty about what is perceived through the senses. "For better" because, at the same time, performance improves on tasks where overactivity of our prediction machine actually gets in the way. In studies, subjects who took LSD were less susceptible to the "hollow mask illusion" (an optical illusion in which the brain perceives a concave mask of a human face as if it were convex, like a normal face), and those under the influence of ayahuasca and psilocybin did better on tasks that required reducing binocular rivalry (the contest between the different information reaching the two eyes). Of course, these findings are related to the way people under the influence of psychedelics experience even routine experiences as new and exciting, and especially to the fact that the insights a person gains under the influence of psychedelics are so often labeled by them as "truth."
The fact that these experiences take place under the cover of a partial pause in our tireless prediction engine accounts for part of that labeling. The experiences are labeled as true because they are based on an encounter with sensory information coming from reality, one that is less constrained by the brain's predictions based on past events. In this sense, these experiences are more immediate. In other words, psychedelic experiences are labeled as more real partly because, to some extent, they really are more real.
Now, going back to the computational model that predicts the existence of a bodily/minimal self, we can speculate that the experience of ego dissolution is related to the psychedelic chewing gum stuck in the gears of the prediction machine, making it harder to produce the hypothesis of the self. That hypothesis routinely gives us the ability to locate the self in space and to draw a boundary between the self and the world.
Now, as promised, a few words about the similarity between the party going on in the brain under psychedelics and the one that takes place under the influence of meditation. The sense of unity is one of the foundations of the mystical experience. Its emergence is based, at least in part, on a reduction of the brain processes that are busy establishing the hypothesis of the self or contribute to it. Today there is significant evidence that brain regions such as the nodes of the area called the DMN (default mode network) are involved in self-related processing and in maintaining a sense of self that exists in space and time (the same sense of self I discussed at the start of this column). Brain-imaging studies using a variety of technologies have shown that activity in these regions decreases both after taking classic hallucinogens and during meditation.
One of the research hypotheses now widely accepted among psychedelics researchers is that, in both meditation and psychedelics, activity in this region goes down, and communication between its nodes and other targets in the cerebral cortex that are involved in associative and sensory processing changes fundamentally. These changes support a decline in the importance given to the prediction of the self's existence during mystical experiences. They are also consistent with the sense of having no frame of time and space that characterizes the mystical experience.
More specifically, during mindfulness meditation and after taking hallucinogens alike, the amplitude of spontaneous fluctuations in the brain's DMN drops. Other, consistent findings point to a reduction or cessation of brain activity in additional regions during meditation practices known as focused awareness and open monitoring practices.
For example, in ordinary brain activity there is an inverse relationship between activity in the DMN (a region associated with focusing attention inward) and brain networks known as task-positive networks, which are associated with directing attention outward. This inverse relationship, too, weakens significantly under hallucinogens and during non-dual meditation practice, and it may be part of the foundation of the mystical experience produced by this kind of practice.
These changes in brain activity are what we would expect to see when a person reports an experience of unity, in which representations of internal mental objects merge with representations of external objects in the way that characterizes mystical experiences. And this experience of unity is the basis for the psychological healing offered by both psychedelics and meditation.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com



