Seeking an Educated Young Woman (Ideally With an Apartment)
Updated: Oct 22
How did the economic emphasis disappear from matchmaking ads in Israel, and what replaced it? Reading a paper on 1950s classified ads reveals that young people are still looking for love — they've just shifted their focus to different things than what mattered to them back then
"On behalf of my relative, a lonely lady, cultured, a British national, refined and noble-spirited, from a distinguished, well-known family, graceful in appearance, age 41, not without means, I am seeking a partner from among educated, religious men."
The holidays are here, and singlehood is a hot topic — and it turns out it was one many years ago too. This delightful ad appears in a paper titled "Matchmaking and Personal Ads in the Israeli Press of the 1950s," written by Eyal Ginzberg and published in "Israelis," an academic journal put out by Ben-Gurion University. Reading this paper got me thinking: what can we learn by comparing the Hebrew matchmaking ads of the mid-twentieth century to the profiles Israeli men and women post on dating sites today?
"A beautiful 38-year-old woman, educated, of substantial means, wishes to meet a man in a liberal profession or industry." One thing that hasn't changed is the length of the message. Then, just as now, these ads were short, because their purpose was to attract the right audience. And just as today, back then too, a sense of shame accompanied the search for a match. "Approaching a matchmaker involved a degree of concealment," Ginzberg writes.
"Matchmaking in the 1950s was considered a discreet matter, not something people spoke or wrote about openly. Alongside the embarrassment of turning to a matchmaker, matchmaking itself was also a popular pastime that relatives, family members, neighbors, and friends of single men and women engaged in endlessly, sometimes in a downright intrusive way. Matchmakers themselves often pushed back against this negative image; for instance, the owner of a matchmaking office noted in an article on the subject in the magazine 'La'isha': 'Whoever comes to me feels ashamed, but there's no reason for it. Young people come to me who invested in their careers and then discovered they were left alone.'"
That heavy, oppressive shame, a product of our society's double standard, is still with us today. Hadar Zohar, a contemporary dating coach, explains this well in an interview: "One of the most significant barriers when it comes to finding a relationship is actually declaring it publicly — but without creating opportunities and visibility by using every available circle: family, friends, colleagues, and of course dating sites, we won't succeed in finding love and a relationship." Zohar adds: "Some people feel humiliated just opening a profile, and plenty of others are embarrassed that acquaintances might see them and that it will hurt their image."
Within the tension between the need to be attractive and the shame attached to that very need, single men and women tried to define, as concisely as possible, why they're appealing and what they're looking for in a potential partner — and to do so in the shortest, sharpest way possible. I have no pretense of covering every difference between these two eras in a single short post, but this delightful study, along with additional sources, lets me identify a few striking differences.
Ginzberg writes that the traits and characteristics highlighted in ads from decades past fell into the following categories: age; financial status (expressed through terms like "of means," "owns an apartment," "financially secure," and others); personality (who today markets themselves as "nice" or "cultured"?); physical traits; level of education (which, interestingly — and, in my opinion, rightly — was presented separately from level of intellect, in a way that today is far from trivial); occupation (with ranks whose meaning is hard to grasp today, such as "owns an office"); and family status (beyond the fact that the category of "it's complicated" wasn't really an option back then, it's interesting to note that some of these ads referenced the matchmaking candidate's family of origin, expressed through phrases like "good family").

Also appearing in these ads was status in the country (a characteristic that's hard to picture today, in an era of global mobility like ours, and one that mainly served to boast that the single person advertising themselves belonged to the elite of "old-timers"), gendered traits ("manly" or "feminine," terms that today we usually convey through a photo, since it's far less politically acceptable to state them outright), and, of course, ethnic background (which, if we're being honest, in those ads mainly amounted to a declaration that the prospective match was Ashkenazi, or, in the language of the time, "European").
The most striking difference between the old ads and the new ones is their attitude toward the economic dimension of matchmaking. One example is this ad, placed by a matchmaking office and considered fairly typical: "For the purpose of marriage, a nice 27-year-old man, born in Poland, a longtime resident of Israel, wealthy and financially secure, wishes to meet a young, attractive woman of good appearance, from a good family and of Ashkenazi background." Another ad put it this way: "For the purpose of marriage, an academic, single, 35, holding a public and financial position, seeks a single woman (not tall), pretty and put together. Please describe your appearance and aspirations, age and profession."
Sometimes there were ads in which the advertiser explicitly demanded that the potential partner be financially attractive. Particularly amusing is the following ad, which today is very hard to imagine being published: "Business owner (28), tall, European, wishes to meet an educated young woman of good appearance (ideally with an apartment), up to age 24." The paper's author brings additional examples, such as: "On behalf of my friend, a 32-year-old industrialist, medium height, speaks Hebrew, German and Hungarian [sic], owns a private car, I am seeking a suitable young woman for the purpose of marriage, ideally with a sum of 40,000–50,000 lirot," or "Widower, 50, very wealthy, owns a large house in Tel Aviv; wealthy widow, has 100,000."
A look at the advice given by people who consider themselves dating-site experts shows that today the emphasis is on creating a physically and emotionally appealing image. One of them, couples consultant Dr. Orit Arbel, is quoted in that same article. She explains to the beginner single: "It's best to write something short and sharp, and remember that the more interests and pursuits you mention, the more interesting you'll come across. Another tip is to avoid negativity — meaning, don't list what you don't like and don't want in your relationship." And what about the photo? "You need to smile — a smile is always winning and attractive," she explains. "And also show a bit of skin. Don't choose a photo with a golf shirt that hides your body. Other, more revealing shirts let people discover the person behind the clothes."
Today's single men and women describe themselves as unique and intriguing (as reflected, too, in how central quotes have become in dating profiles — not to mention how many "bakers" seem to bear no relation to their actual "dough") and physically attractive. Back then, by contrast, ad writers dwelled much more on financial potential. Ginzberg addresses this directly: "This can be understood against the backdrop of a period of economic hardship, in which single men and women tied the experience of love to an escape from a scarcity economy, and sought to extract the best possible outcome from a difficult situation. In such a reality, it makes sense that people would act to improve their own circumstances, while others, those with means, would exploit the hardship to highlight their own financial advantage."
The economic context is critical, but we can't really say today's young people are more financially secure or less materialistic than those of the past. That's why I think this comparison to contemporary ads also reveals the growing power of the romantic myth, a changing relationship to the body (which makes us feel that someone who wants us for our six-pack abs is somehow more authentic than someone who wants us for the diligence we poured into a lucrative career), and a belief that love is based on hidden, instant magic more than on a process and on compatibility of values, intellect, or the broader sense of cultural background.
Shall we check our calendars? If you would like to schedule a consultation, book me for a talk, or propose a collab, please send me an email at: amalia.rosenblum@gmail.com




